I consider myself closer to the newbie end of the spectrum on HDTV-related topics. However, I have read several articles and posts as well as talked to some salespeople in the stores, so I think I understand all the basic differences among the competing technologies.
Here's a rundown of my current set-up:
- 30-32" (diagonal) SD TV set that is more than 10 years old but still works great; it only has composite and s-video inputs
- A relatively inexpensive but serviceable stereo receiver hooked up to a pair of old speakers (no clue of the wattage, but they can shake the house when cranked up)
- Game consoles: original XBox, PS2, and a Wii
I understand that if I get a big HDTV that my three consoles won't look great on it due to pixelation. However, at least the XBox has some games that can do 720p, so I would expect some games to look better, at least on a 720p HDTV. I assume pixelation would still be an issue even for those games with a 1080p set.
I expect to be getting an XBox 360 in the next few months (the Orange Box will be the primary cause, but Halo 3 and Bioshock will be in my collection early on, too, I'm sure). My fundamental question is this: How bad will the 360 (and these games) look on my SD TV?
I have been told that the 360 will actually look pretty good on an SD set, but am I selling myself short by not getting an HDTV? I will still be doing a lot (perhaps a majority) of gaming on the older consoles (everything is shared with the family, who won't be using the 360 so much).
I have also considered spending my budget on a home theater surround sound system instead, even though my existing speakers are fine (no surround though). So these seem to be my options:
- Get a plasma or LCD with 1080p, which will probably delay the purchase of the 360 because it will break my budget
- Get an HDTV that only does 720p and save some cash
- Keep the SD set and spend the money on surround sound and more software
- Save even more money by only getting the console
Clearly this is about balancing and determing relative values of different options. I am looking for advice to help inform my decision. In case it's not obvious from context, I am a semi-serious medium-core gamer who likes FPS and action/adventure games that tell good stories with high production values (or something). And I share my consoles with young kids and a wife who are more into "casual" games, at least for now. Oh yeah, we also watch a fair number of DVDs (just standard so far) and some TV shows on digital cable. I like NFL football, too (go Broncos).
Thanks in advance for any suggestions or guidance.
Log in to comment