[QUOTE="blaznwiipspman1"]
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/85?vs=89
as you can see clock for clock the 8400 is stronger than any phenom available, usually by 10 %, so there is no point in "upgrading" to a ph II. If his mobo doesn't support any core 2 quad, even a q6600 then thats a shame, but the fact remains that going phenom II from where he is isn't a good idea.
hartsickdiscipl
We're not talking about clock for clock here. We're talking about dollar for dollar. I'm recommending that he spend less than $200 on a motherboard/CPU upgrade that will give his system a massive longevity and performance boost. His mobo may or may not support the Q8000 series, but the official CPU support list from EVGA's own website makes no mention of any support. It is absolutely a good idea for him to go for a Phenom II/mobo/GPU upgrade, especially since he's said that he can probably expand his budget to $350ish. What would you have him do, upgrade to a cheap LGA 1155 mobo with a 2500k and keep his 4850? That would be right in line with your choice to upgrade from an i5-750 to a 2500k and keep your 4770, but not the best choice for the TC to get a balanced gaming rig. A 955 (especially OC'd, which is so easy with unlocked multi) coupled with a GTX 460/AMD 6850 is a much smarter gaming combo. Unless he finds a nice cheap Q6600 (and overclocks the hell out of it) or somehow confirms that a Q8000 will work in his board (and overclocks it), the AM2+ mobo/Phenom II 955 upgrade option is the best within his current budget.
he has a few options that I would recommend:
a) buy a cooler and overclock the crap out of his current core 2 duo. If it reaches above 3ghz it will out perform a phenom II. Total cost would be $30
b) He could get a 955/am3+ mobo and ddr3 ram which would give him a path to bulldozer down the line and save him money. Approximate cost for this would be $100 for mobo, $135 for cpu and $40 for ram so around $280
c) He could save money on the ddr3 ram by trading his ddr2 ram on craigslist or selling it. Ive done just that recently. This would drive down his cost for am3+ mobo and cpu to $235
or he could do what you recommend:
d) buy am2+ mobo/955 for approximate cost of $200
Personally I would go with option a) or option c)
option a) gives him room to also get a good video card, while option c) will give him room for a bulldozer chip. Its a tough choice but I'd give option c) the edge since the 4850 is still a decent video card.
Log in to comment