After having played all 3 games, here's the breakdown:
F.E.A.R. - fun and exciting shooter. Depending on how often you have to get up and shake your head a bit to clear out that creepy tingling at the base of your spine, the game will probably last between 6-10 hours of gameplay (that's not including the expansion pack). Don't kid yourself, though. F.E.A.R. is an action shooter first while, at the same time, teasing you by trying to be a horror game. In other words, there are 'scary' moments separated by long, strung-together shooter moments (so long, in fact, that you'll forget that there's a creepy ghost girl wandering around causing people to bleed out every orifice on their body.
The Longest Journey - While I haven't finished the game, TLJ IS art. If people are complaining about the graphics, it's because of two things: 1) the pre-rendered sequences use an older (obviously) CGI engine and 2) character models can be HIGHLY aliased (which can be remedied by forcing your video card to an anti-aliasing setting for the TLJ executable file. Even though the CGI and character models are dated, the lush and vibrant backdrops are astoundingly GORGEOUS. Seriously, I've found myself staring at a scene for several minutes before realizing that I haven't even touched my mouse (let alone moved my character).
C&C3 - A throwback to the old C&C gameplay mechanic, C&C3 is, for the most part, just a fresh coat of paint (and a new faction) to the original C&C. The biggest draw here are the cheesy (but in a good way) FMV story clips. Michael Ironside, Jennifer Morrison, Billy Dee Williams, and Joseph Kucan all make the FMV sequences all the more memorable. While this game has the highest replayability of the other two options because of the option to play as either GDI or Nod (and a short, tacked-on Scrin campaign), most of your replay experience will be held in multiplayer matches. Unfortunately, most of those matches will be relegated to how quickly you can build a large force of tanks. Seriously, C&C3 multiplayer is simply an exercise in the tank rush. You've been warned.
So, out of those three choices, my vote goes unhesitantly to The Longest Journey. However, for RTS, I can't recommend enough Supreme Commander, Sins of a Solar Empire, and anything made by Relic.
Log in to comment