I need something terrifying to play..

Title says it all.

Beat Amnesia.

Beat Nightmare house 2.

Help me out.

Get Scratches and White Day (This one's free :D ). Those ones scared me much more than Amnesia or Nightmare House 2.

Also, if you have a PS3 then get Siren: New Translation, it's the most terrifying thing I've ever played this gen (Or any generation).

Don't mock me but Dead Space 2 has it's moments.

You can try this HL2 mod called Grey. The atmosphere reminds me so much of Silent Hill 3.

I find bioshock scary at times

Title says it all.

Beat Amnesia.

Beat Nightmare house 2.

Help me out.

jimmyrussle117

The Penumbra trilogy is basically the same as Amnesia, both developed by the same company, and both are great.

After that there's Sanitarium, which is the best psychological-horror adventure game ever created.

go try and play the stock market.. thatll make u sweat

sonic 2006

actually there aren't many scary games, though penubmra overture is pretty close

Title says it all.

Beat Amnesia.

Beat Nightmare house 2.

Help me out.

jimmyrussle117

Terrifying as hell games:

Condemned: Criminal Origins

Penumbra series (Overture, Black Plague then Requiem in order of canon and how you should play them)

Silent Hill 2/3 (not on Steam though, sadly)

Slender

The Suffering (and it's sequel, Ties That Bind)

The Thing

Not quite as scary, but thrilling and fun in other ways:

Alan Wake

Dead Space

Dark Souls (scary more due to the creepy locations and penalty for death)

Bioshock (like Dead Space, it isn't outright terrifying, but has an oppressive atmosphere and some terrifying moments)

Cryostasis

FEAR (first was the only truly scary one I'd say)

Manhunt

Metro 2033

Penumbra Overture and Black Plague

Call of Cthulu: Dark Corners of the Earth

all of those are great horror games with some similarities to Amnesia

Undying

Look for a russian game called Pathologic. It's a complex, bizarre and very atmopheric action-adventure game with RPG elements where you have 12 days to save a small town from the plague.

Undying

Baranga

If ya can find it.

I got a new upcoming game and it somewhat is terryfying. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/budleiser/web-and-ios-game-twin-stick-shooter-tower-defenseJAGS2012

Yes I'm sure this is a legitimate horror game and not some attempt at advertising by a new user. Budweiser twin stick shooter tower defense for ios sounds exactly like a horror game that fits for this thread, in the PC and Mac games board/

Condemned 1

Fear 1

Or play some of the better Amnesia custom story's / mods.

Bioshock

Slender

Dead Space 2

Don't bother with Slender. It's overrated in terms of how scary it is.

I'm also going to advocate F.E.A.R. since it relies on sound a great deal more than most 'scary' games. Visuals and monsters aren't everything.

The first F.E.A.R. and its expansions.

Try SlenderSweetbackhair

If trees and boredom scare you, then yes, try this.

But seriously, try SCP: Containment Breach.

Title says it all.

Beat Amnesia.

Beat Nightmare house 2.

Help me out.

jimmyrussle117

[QUOTE="Sweetbackhair"]Try SlenderFrankenstrat247

If trees and boredom scare you, then yes, try this.

But seriously, try SCP: Containment Breach.

You say Slender is boring, then list SCP Containment Breach?

I mean, it has good ideas, but it is so unfinished and underwhelming its just not worth playing until the developers actually take the concept somewhere. Still, the concepts are really cool.

play russian roullette IRL, guaranteed strong sensation included.