The Witcher or UT3?

RPGs>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>FPSs

60hours long>>>>>>>>>>>>>9hours long

The Witcher can become repetitive if you compare it to other rpg's but overall the coolness factor is there for some new things never done before.

UT3 scales ok, but its a beast hog if you want decent graphics. Otherwise, consider it like GoW below 1024 res. Pixelated poop. ^__^

I would go Witcher.

The Witcher can become repetitive if you compare it to other rpg's

xavierdhjane

Which RPGs?

Oblivion and Morrowind namely, then of course the ever popular Neverwinter Nights 2. Then Fable of course.xavierdhjane

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

You're joking, right? Oblivion and Morrowind weren't repetative!!!??? :lol: :lol: :lol: All the missions are fetch this item or raid this dungeon and kill someone/something. The main quests in Oblivion are shut down the Oblivion gate

NwN 2 is as repetative as the Witcher (and I don't think that The Witcher is repetative)

Fable's combat was very repetative

The Witcher wasn't repetative at all

Kane, in The Witcher. All the missions are kill this monster, ask this person for something- kill whatever is bothering them, deliver this, light this candle, etc.

Oblivion was truly open ended as was Morrowind. The Witcher, is certainly not. And compared to Fable, there aren't nearly as many combinations of what you can become. There is no stealth or guile, no lightning bolts, and your "signs," aren't even really all that powerful. I applaud the Witcher for its other qualities. But certainly not groundbreaking originality.

Witcher - SP

UT3 - MP

RPGs>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>FPSs

60hours long>>>>>>>>>>>>>9hours long

Darth_Kane

I love The Witcher, but your logic is clearly flawed in this specific case. Me and most other people playing UT3 will probably put a lot more than 9 hours into it.

RPGs>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>FPSs

60hours long>>>>>>>>>>>>>9hours long

Darth_Kane

sorry but ur stupidity made me lol. UT 9 hours?? lawl. More like 500 (3000 in my case). haha. wow.

Kane, in The Witcher. All the missions are kill this monster, ask this person for something- kill whatever is bothering them, deliver this, light this candle, etc.

Oblivion was truly open ended as was Morrowind. The Witcher, is certainly not. And compared to Fable, there aren't nearly as many combinations of what you can become. There is no stealth or guile, no lightning bolts, and your "signs," aren't even really all that powerful. I applaud the Witcher for its other qualities. But certainly not groundbreaking originality.

xavierdhjane

I hope you aren't serious

[QUOTE="xavierdhjane"]Oblivion and Morrowind namely, then of course the ever popular Neverwinter Nights 2. Then Fable of course.Darth_Kane

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

You're joking, right? Oblivion and Morrowind weren't repetative!!!??? :lol: :lol: :lol: All the missions are fetch this item or raid this dungeon and kill someone/something. The main quests in Oblivion are shut down the Oblivion gate

NwN 2 is as repetative as the Witcher (and I don't think that The Witcher is repetative)

Fable's combat was very repetative

The Witcher wasn't repetative at all

I can't disagree more...

Oblivion = 0 repetative

Morrowind = a lot better then Oblivion but is it indeed highly repetative?

NwN2 = highly linear story, it has some replay value but not much

Fable = 0 repetative

The Witcher = semi-linear story, with limited skills features (you can't have max skills in everything) and diffrent ways of passing one quest i would say it is highly repetative

[QUOTE="Darth_Kane"]

[QUOTE="xavierdhjane"]Oblivion and Morrowind namely, then of course the ever popular Neverwinter Nights 2. Then Fable of course.herezjarchus

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

You're joking, right? Oblivion and Morrowind weren't repetative!!!??? :lol: :lol: :lol: All the missions are fetch this item or raid this dungeon and kill someone/something. The main quests in Oblivion are shut down the Oblivion gate

NwN 2 is as repetative as the Witcher (and I don't think that The Witcher is repetative)

Fable's combat was very repetative

The Witcher wasn't repetative at all

I can't disagree more...

Oblivion = 0 repetative

Morrowind = a lot better then Oblivion but is it indeed highly repetative?

NwN2 = highly linear story, it has some replay value but not much

Fable = 0 repetative

The Witcher = semi-linear story, with limited skills features (you can't have max skills in everything) and diffrent ways of passing one quest i would say it is highly repetative

I like Fable but it is repetitive
Lonelynight

Maybe it's just me but I did't found much replay value in it... i also liked Fable but most of its choices leaded to similar consequences or hadn't consequences at all...

I can't disagree more...

Oblivion = 0 repetative

Morrowind = a lot better then Oblivion but is it indeed highly repetative?

herezjarchus

Actually both are very repetative no matter how you look at them.

Please stop this nonsense. It is making my head hurt.

Very few games are actually not repetative. No matter what it will most always be the same controls, and combat will ALWAYS have repetitions. I challenge anyone to find a game where combat is constantly changing. Go on.

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"]I like Fable but it is repetitive
herezjarchus

Maybe it's just me but I did't found much replay value in it... i also liked Fable but most of its choices leaded to similar consequences or hadn't consequences at all...

I didn't find much replay value in it either

O sorry i mistaken repetivness with replay value and thought that repetivness = replay value (english isn't my native langauge)... sorry for my stupid posts :(herezjarchus

Ahh, now it makes sense

But still, The Witcher has more replay value than Fable because it has more choices

I Love the witcher. yes it's repetitive. But to say oblivion isnt more so is a joke. I have played a good dose of oblivion (over 60 hours) but once you have got to level 20, the game just grinds to a halt and its just the same thing over and over. The scaling system really is oblivions downfall. Never liked morrowind either, but I did love Daggerfall! (the grand daddy of the elder scrolls)

The witcher is just sublime. Elder scrolls has become a glorified FPS. (and a poor fps at that)