What's your favorite Id software Game?

What's your favorite Id software game? My favorites are Doom 3 and Quake 4 (although developed by Raven)

It's gotta be Quake 1 for me. Such an entertaining, fast, thrilling game, with an incredible feel, look, and atmosphere, especially at the time of release. I hadn't seen graphics like that back then. Although I suspect Doom 1 will win out for most.

EDIT: Oh, and btw, Return to Castle Wolfenstein isn't on your list, and it's about as eligble as Quake 4 is (Both are primarily developed by 3rd party companies). That's a great game that may raise the Wolfenstein poll up a bit.

Quake 1. Trent Reznor ftw! They need to make a sequel, maybe incorporating the RPG elements it was supposed to have.

definitely Doom 2 for me. I played it so much when I was younger. I still play and enjoy it now and again.

definitely Doom 2 for me. I played it so much when I was younger. I still play and enjoy it now and again.

broken_bass_bin

Quake 2 is the only game I've spent a good amount of time with - so I vote for that. flipin_jackass

why isn't Quake 4 grouped with I-III - shouldn't Quake III be the standalone title in the poll (it had no single player campaign)?

also, where's Return to Castle Wolfenstein?

Quake 1.

come on folks let's get some more votes in here! You can't truly call yourself a PC Gamer unless you've played a game developed by Id software!

Doom 2 the only i played...

Rtcw

Quake 3 Arena and Quake 3 engine games .. American McGee's Alice, Jedi Knight: Jedi Outcast, Soldier of Fortune 2

quake 3/4 and doom 2 are my personal choices though doom 3 wasnt all that bad..

why isn't Quake 4 grouped with I-III - shouldn't Quake III be the standalone title in the poll (it had no single player campaign)?

also, where's Return to Castle Wolfenstein?

JackBurton

Doom/Doom 2 to this address.

Quake 2 for me, first game I ever playied where online deathmatches seemed as natural as breathing, with no real hussle. Also the first game I remember that showed that a gpu was not just pointless moneywaste.

For me it would be Doom 3 with Quake II not far behind.

Quake 3 takes the cake, i think it's release was the offical kickstart of online multiplayer, Quake 3 is what made MP so much more popular and how many games can say that?

Quake and Quake 2 are my picks. Don't care for multiplayer that much so didn't play Q 3. Also really liked Doom 3. I liked all the games listed, (except Q 3) these were just my favorites.

I'll get some crap for this one, but I'm going to say Doom 3. If this thread was about inspiration/memorable I would've picked something else. Doom 3, I think, didn't get enough credit. Soooo many people hated on this game. This game was and still is brilliant. PCFr3ak89

so far I only played Doom 3 on that list. My only pick would be Doom 3.Jd1680a

DOOM 3 FTW!!

Space marines are always in fashion

Quake 3 Arena and Quake 3 engine games .. American McGee's Alice, Jedi Knight: Jedi Outcast, Soldier of Fortune 2

artistry_

Wooaaaa!!! Was "Jedi Outcast" developed by id software? Cuz if it is that is definetly my number one. Imo, best game ever!

I'm gonna have to go with Doom 3 but that's only because I've never played any of the others.