Overrated games

Ok, I know these kinds of topics have been made before, but I just wanted to know what games people consider overrated.

And please, if you say a game that's generally considered good(read:most likely every game that will be listed), at least give reasons. :)

just look at gamespot top rated PS2 games of all time... TH's Pro Skater 3: 10.0!, Burnout Takedown 9.5? it wasnt a bad game, but 9.5??

just look at gamespot top rated PS2 games of all time... TH's Pro Skater 3: 10.0!, Burnout Takedown 9.5? it wasnt a bad game, but 9.5??

G-Man88

Burnout 3: Takedown is easily the best racing game out there. That gamespot 9.5 score isnt much different from the USER SCORE of 9.3 (8,068 votes).

yeah, GTA as well ... i dindt want to name it, but i think is overrated

GTA: San Andreas, every Madden game, the Jak series, and the Ratchet series.SmashBrosLegend

DIE!!!!!!!!! ... I mean... I respect your right to express your opinion but strongly disagree with it. =->

I'm going to say Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3. It was good but not 10/10 good. Then there's Marvel Ultimate Alliance which I hated altogether.

Every FF after 9

DMC 2 and 3 ... I don't even wanna talk about these two.

And same goes for the GTA's, after three it just got repetive. I still played them, just for the mayhem, but I actually never finished either of the 2 after GTA 3.

I love Kingdom Hearts :(

But I think Killzone was overrated.

i really actually hated the MGS series the controls where so blocky and slow to respond. and the camera never worked right. i ened up just putting it on easy wheres its almost imm[ossible to die and then blasting through the levels with the rpg.dberg9292

-Now on the topic, defintetly GTA:san andreas is the most overrated PS2 game, I mean 9.6? with the horrible graphics, cliché story and poor atmosphere I think it deserves at least a 8.0

I think the GTA franchise is overrated after 3, I'm not too big of a fan of GTA, but play them anyways. I rather just go commit GTA myself rather than play a game about it I guess, but my main reason why I think its overrated cuz its same story same game no matter what in my opinion (the franchise can't evolve in my opinion). Wanted to get that off my chest for those who complain about repetitive games666_Laventine

FF12 was overrated...

and God of war 1-2 were also, button mashing all over the place, great games still though, but that part of the game always keep me from replaying it a second time.

Okami, I didn't see why it got some many great reviews

I love Kingdom Hearts :(

But I think Killzone was overrated.

Godofnerdyness

I think Killzone was good and Kingdom Hearts was really overrated and boreing.

I respect your opinions but I think GTA series is one of those few games were being repetative is good.

On to the topic...

God of War 1& 2, Shadow of the Colossus, and all turn-based games. :)

Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3- 10 Perfect Score- Overrated = YES...haterex

i totaly agree with the skating game why it got a perfect ten, really overated or just the person who reviewd the game loved skateboarding, another one is winning eleven7

God of War

Final Fantasy

Devil May Cry

I find it funny how San Andreas is the most overrated just because it has a black guy in it.

If you're looking for overrated games: Halo series, GEARS OF WAR, GTA series, Metal Gear Solid series, Resident Evil series, Jade Empire, KOTOR, Final Fantasy series, Chrono Trigger/Chrono Cross, next-gen games in general(especially 360 games), shooters in general, music oriented games, etc.

The few games that deserve their praise:

Ninja Gaiden/Black/Sigma---deserve highest honors

God Of War 1 & 2---deserve highest honors

Shenmue 1 & 2(DC)---deserve highest honors

Metroid Prime

Jet Set Radio Future(it's sort of music oriented but still good)(underrated)

Monster Rancher series(wayyy underrated)

Soul Reaver(semi-underrated)

Gran Turismo

End of list...

All Ratchet & Clanks after the first one, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, every sports game ever, Need For Speed and Final Fantasy.Silent-Hal

Really? I thought Going Commando was good, honestly. Haven't played UYA, Deadlocked or Size Matters.

I'm a bit surprised FF, DMC, God of War, Gears etc. have been listed, but everyone's entitled to their opinions, I guess.

i think mgs2 should've scored lower and mgs 3 should have scored scored a little higher so 8.7 and 9.3 respectively.

kingdom hearts 1 and 2 should also switch their scores.

i didnt enjoy GTA SA as much as i would have hoped

then there's FF12

oh and games that users and other sites over rated i'd have to say metroid prime 3 and ratchet future

I Loved GTA and MSG, so I dont agree with you guys there, any tony hawk sucks, kingdom hearts, jak series, ratchet series, DMC series...Burnout was reviewed a little too high, but it was a good game...rahul_batta

I honestly don't know what's wrong with Jak, R&C and DMC.

DMC 2, I can understand, because that was the WEAKEST DMC game, but 3 was awesome, in my opinion. >>

oh yeah, how could i forget about another boring and childish game that everybody loves,

dark cloud 2

oh yeah, how could i forget about another boring and childish game that everybody loves,

dark cloud 2

KaiserDu

Dark Cloud 2, boring and childish?

...What?

kingdom hearts, omg i hate this game, so boring and childishKaiserDu

I agree. I thought I was going to like it, considering I like the FF series, but it's just boring and a waste of time.

kingdom hearts, omg i hate this game, so boring and childishKaiserDu

I agree. I thought I was going to like it, considering I like the FF series, but it's just boring and a waste of time.