Alan Wake or Red Dead Redemption (POLL)

Im gonna pre-order new game soon and im not quite sure which it could be Alan Wake or Red Dead Redemption...

there both different style of games. and this is a ps3 forum alan wake is a 360 exclusive. so youre probably not gonna get a very honest opinion here. i own a 360&ps3 im not really into horror games anymore. so i would say red dead i love westerns but i didnt like red dead1 at all!!! so im only waiting tell the review to make my decision.

Ye im sorry that i made this thread here but i got ps3 and X360 too and i wasnt really quite sure where to put it :(

I own a 360 and PS3. and Alan Wake has never really struck my interest...

however that doesn't mean it'll be a bad game.

for me at least. Red Dead Redemption has a much bigger and longer story.

the multiplayer is different from your run of the mill multiplayer as well.

to me Red Dead Redemption is gonna quite possibly be my new Fallout 3...

a game that i can get lost in and play for hours.

Thats tough, they both look awesome, but I'll say Red Dead Redemption