Battlefield 2 or Red Dead Redemption?

I have seen amazing reviews for both games but undecided which one I should get? If I can get some assistant here it would be greatly appreciated. I am looking for both single player and online play. Thanks

Red Dead Redemption;)

if you like Mulitiplayer Battlefield 2 is the better game, for Single Player Battlefield 2 is great but shorter, you will get more from Red Dead Redemption.

I still think Battlefield 2 is a much better game. RDR is good but way overhyped, also before going with RDR ask how much you liked GTA4, because its alot like that game.

rdr for singleplayer...bfbc2 for mp...simple.

wow thatsa hard question, but i would pick up red dederedemption still

Definitely Red Dead Redemption

In terms of multiplayer: Get Bad Company 2. That game is great online and will keep you hooked for a while.

Get RDR for singleplayer, the game is more engaging in that sense and an overall better experience. Bad Company 2's is fun though, as well.

I have them both! Personally, RDR is more fun to me for some reason. The campaign mode in BC2 was really dry and boring and the online play became lame after I unlocked all guns for all profiles (Assualt, Medic, Recon, etc) and it's not like MW where I can prestige. I stopped playing BC2. RDR on the other hand has a very good story that draws me in. I didn't think I'd like the "Western" setting much, but my gut reactions were WRONG! This game is awesome!

So... if you can't buy both... buy Red Dead Redemption!

Red Dead Redemption.

Battlefield: Bad Company 2.

Red Dead Redemption says I!

Red dead- Single player

Bfbc2- Multiplayer

Red Dead Redemption :)

I have seen amazing reviews for both games but undecided which one I should get? If I can get some assistant here it would be greatly appreciated. I am looking for both single player and online play. Thanks

hkymike

Those two games are not to be missed...

Red Dead Redemption;)

orbis_mortis

Thank you everyone with the responses although I am still on the fence since it was like 50 50 with peoples opinions. Although I did noticea lot of people say BF multiplayer is better.......These demos aren't in the PSN store are they?

Both games are truly amazing so both! :P
Ps. I would not have put those two on a comparison.
BC2 (FPS) RDR (TPS) :roll: