Bioshock or Fallout 3?...

im deciding between getting fallout 3 or bioshock but cant get both. Which one?

And please dont say get both cuz i still gotta get games like resistance 2 and Little Big Planet.

So which one should i get?

Ill get both eventually. Ive already played bioshock and its awesome but ive also played oblivion and i really enjoyed that so i really dont know which one

PSN ID: Gamester108

Well, I can't say because I haven't seen Fallout 3 PS3 gameplay. I want to preorder it, but I need to see gameplay. Even if they said their goal was to put the 360, PC, and PS3 versions side to side with no console visiable and no one to see a difference.

I do not buy lazy ports. BioShock on PS3 was a lazy port, like it or not. I LOVED the demo but it didn't look as good as the 360 version after a year more, thats being lazy, ive seen numerous games have the PS3 version looking the same or better that come out at the same time. Im not saying it takes a fraction of a precent away from the game, but I will not buy lazy ports.

So basicly, if you don't care or worry about lazy ports. Then get Fallout 3, it looks really good from what ive seen.

I think Fallout 3 will have more freedom and replay value then Bioshock has.

Bioshock is pretty straight forward and while it is by no means a bad thing it tends to loose the replay value after the second playthrough.

I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbNuKkU

WHA?!

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbthanos723

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

[QUOTE="thanos723"]

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbNuKkU

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

ok i can understand you not liking FPS, its respectable. but what got me was that you said they both look dumb.

of course you are entitled to your opinion, but even if i was a non fan i couldn't say they look dumb. i would have gone with "not my taste in games"

[QUOTE="NuKkU"][QUOTE="thanos723"]

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbthanos723

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

ok i can understand you not liking FPS, its respectable. but what got me was that you said they both look dumb.

of course you are entitled to your opinion, but even if i was a non fan i couldn't say they look dumb. i would have gone with "not my taste in games"

sorry when i said they looked dumb i meant they looked dumb to me sorry if i didnt make much sense

Fallout 3... If it has any replay value like Oblivion does your set for quite awhile.

With Bioshock once you beat it you may play it one more time or so. Took me about 12 hours to beat it on 360.

[QUOTE="thanos723"]

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbNuKkU

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

I am getting fallout 3 at launch, but am worried about it being to much of a shooter and not enough rpg. The targeting system makes it look like you don't have to be that great at FPS to enjoy this game though.

[QUOTE="NuKkU"][QUOTE="thanos723"]

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbcloud_strife007

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

I am getting fallout 3 at launch, but am worried about it being to much of a shooter and not enough rpg. The targeting system makes it look like you don't have to be that great at FPS to enjoy this game though.

since you still level and have a health bar, i think it'll be a good balance.

though the VATS system does have its limits, if you look at the gameplay videos, you have AP and when its depleted you can't use it until it replenishes. and i'm not sure how it does, if it's just over time or normal actions.

[QUOTE="thanos723"]

[QUOTE="NuKkU"]I say fallout 3 even thru i think both games are pretty dumbNuKkU

WHA?!

i dont like FPS all that much i know what ur bout to say Fallout 3 is a RPG but to me it looks 80%FPS and 20%RPG thats what it looks like to me if you disagree with me oh well but to me thats what it looks like

EDIT: Dont get me wrong i think both games will sell very well its just that FPS arent my type of games im more of RPG type of dude

You Dont have to play it in FPS you can play TPS/RE style its your choice and its more 50% shooting and 50% RPGing(if ya wanna call it that)

Man I cant really say but this is what I am getting: Saints Row 2, Fracture, Dead Space, LittleBIGPlanet, Fable 2, Fallout 3, Resistance 2, BioShock, Gears 2,Quantumof Solace, Midnight Club, Spiderman: Web of Shadows, GH: World Tour, Motorstorm 2, Naruto: UNS, COD: World at War, MK vs. DC Universe, Left 4 Dead, NFS: Undercover, Tomb Raider: Underworld, Shaun White Snowboarding, Naruto: The Broken Bond, Sonic Unleashed, Prince of Persia, Kingdom Hearts Re: Chain of Memories and hopefully Tekken 6 by years end. That is quite the pretty penny... But of course, I already have my money put aside for all of these. Even with the currenteconomicalstatus, I am spending alot anyways.

Man I cant really say but this is what I am getting: Saints Row 2, Fracture, Dead Space, LittleBIGPlanet, Fable 2, Fallout 3, Resistance 2, BioShock, Gears 2,Quantumof Solace, Midnight Club, Spiderman: Web of Shadows, GH: World Tour, Motorstorm 2, Naruto: UNS, COD: World at War, MK vs. DC Universe, Left 4 Dead, NFS: Undercover, Tomb Raider: Underworld, Shaun White Snowboarding, Naruto: The Broken Bond, Sonic Unleashed, Prince of Persia, Kingdom Hearts Re: Chain of Memories and hopefully Tekken 6 by years end. That is quite the pretty penny... But of course, I already have my money put aside for all of these. Even with the currenteconomicalstatus, I am spending alot anyways.

Ultrabeatdown55

You dont have to try to impress people.....

[QUOTE="Ultrabeatdown55"]

Man I cant really say but this is what I am getting: Saints Row 2, Fracture, Dead Space, LittleBIGPlanet, Fable 2, Fallout 3, Resistance 2, BioShock, Gears 2,Quantumof Solace, Midnight Club, Spiderman: Web of Shadows, GH: World Tour, Motorstorm 2, Naruto: UNS, COD: World at War, MK vs. DC Universe, Left 4 Dead, NFS: Undercover, Tomb Raider: Underworld, Shaun White Snowboarding, Naruto: The Broken Bond, Sonic Unleashed, Prince of Persia, Kingdom Hearts Re: Chain of Memories and hopefully Tekken 6 by years end. That is quite the pretty penny... But of course, I already have my money put aside for all of these. Even with the currenteconomicalstatus, I am spending alot anyways.

hillelslovak

You dont have to try to impress people.....

And im not... I am seriously getting all those games by years end. Didnt say I will get all at release. And I can knock off at least 5 for Christmas gifts...

Fallout 3 will offer MUCH longer replay value and playing. You can also deeply customize your character in F3. Bioshokc is only about 10 hours long but I'd have to say Oblivion is better, therefore F3 i guess has better style and about 10x longer play time.Unkn0wn-W4rri0r

Ughh, you're forgetting 1 crucial point: Bioshock has 1 of hte best stories and settings around, and probably beats F3 in those areas. If F3 is ANYTHING like oblivion, F3 will have it's moments (out of thousands of quests), but it's overall quality will be sacrificed due to the open-ended gameplay (with glitches, lack of attention to detail and unpolished quality in some of its quests). Yes, the game is long, but for me, I'd rather have a really good story that stays constant along with the overall quality of the game. Also, only the hardcore will rEALLY beat F3 - if you have alot of time on your hands, get F3. If you want an overall tight package but only 10 hours long (with an aCTUAl end-game), get Bioshock. As for me, I;m waitin on the reviews for both. If the reviews say "If you liked Oblivion, get this game!", I'm totally going for Bioshock.

[QUOTE="Unkn0wn-W4rri0r"]Fallout 3 will offer MUCH longer replay value and playing. You can also deeply customize your character in F3. Bioshokc is only about 10 hours long but I'd have to say Oblivion is better, therefore F3 i guess has better style and about 10x longer play time.glitch2424

Ughh, you're forgetting 1 crucial point: Bioshock has 1 of hte best stories and settings around, and probably beats F3 in those areas. If F3 is ANYTHING like oblivion, F3 will have it's moments (out of thousands of quests), but it's overall quality will be sacrificed due to the open-ended gameplay (with glitches, lack of attention to detail and unpolished quality in some of its quests). Yes, the game is long, but for me, I'd rather have a really good story that stays constant along with the overall quality of the game. Also, only the hardcore will rEALLY beat F3 - if you have alot of time on your hands, get F3. If you want an overall tight package but only 10 hours long (with an aCTUAl end-game), get Bioshock. As for me, I;m waitin on the reviews for both. If the reviews say "If you liked Oblivion, get this game!", I'm totally going for Bioshock.