Dirt 3 / GT5 and Portal 2 / L.A. Noire

GT5 and ummm, the other 2 are impossible to say.

Portal 2 has probably the best story and its a puzzler but same with LA Noire, the games cant be compared, they are entirely different genres.

In coming Lock in 3 2 1........

I haven't played Dirt3 but I love GT5.

Both Portal 2 and Noire are great but Portal is very addicting. So I'd go with Portal 2

dirt 3 is better and between portal 2 and la noir u would say la noir coz not everyone likes puzzle kinds of games like portal 2

Dirt 3 (GT5 is pretty lame if you ask me) and... I enjoyed Portal 2 more, but LA Noir was an experience that all gamers should at least try.

I absolutely love Dirt3, haven't played GT5 yet because it gets soo much hate. If you go for Dirt3, you cannot go wring. The online is a blast and the offline career mode a challenge. Liked Dirt2 just a little more though, although the online with Dirt3 is better (more modes to choose from)

I haven't played Dirt 3 yet, Dirt 2 was real solid. But I got way more hours out of GT5, so I guess if I had to choose I'd go with GT5.

I would also go with Portal 2 over L.A. Noire, but these games are so totally different from each other that it's kind of odd to be choosing. Really you should probably play both, but Portal 2 is alot more fun IMO.

Ultimately you should probably just get all 4.

Dirt 3 for me, and for the other choice, i would say both. i own both games and both are equally awesome!

This sounds an awful lot like a recommendation thread. Gonna have to lock it down. Ask here instead.

For what it's worth, though, Portal 2 is amazing. Totally worth checking out.