Modifying PSP is 100% LEGAL in the UNITED STATES.
Custom Firmware violated pattern law, but is certain part of the Pattern law unethical or have loop holes to be unethical? M$ tried to sue Linux for violating 200+ M$ patterns, lots of engineering design and scientific research are modifcation and/or improvement of developed design and/or studies. Custom firmware is considered as modifcation and improvement of the official firmware. Though it does allow unauthorized software content to run; however, homebrew applications does not have authorization from SONY. The point is even though some homebrew that are developedare not ethical, but some are such as TV remote feature and emulators. Emulator does have ethical/unethicalside. You are the one who make that ethical decision -- Ask yourself, are you hurting others.
Backing up games LEGAL or NOT? It's very debatable you know? Even the law says Illegal, but think about what Ipod does. You can "convert" your music CD to your iPOD.... hmm... is that called backing up too? What about SONY Music got sued because they put copy protection which also has some spyware featureson their Music CD and people were complaining that theycouldn't "backup/transfer" their music to anyMP3 players? Is SONY selfish and not customer first? Ethical?
You have to break the copy protection before you backup, but is breaking this copy protection ethical rather than just Legal/Illegal? It really depends on your end purpose. For example, breaking a protection code from a terrorist computer to save the world vs. breaking the protection so you can play free games.
This is a topic more than Legal/Illegal. We are looking into whether it is ethical to backup your games. Does backing up the games going to hurt somebody? It really depends on the purpose. "Thou shall not kill" also applies to software backup. If you backup the game and hurting other's life and you do it even you know it, then possibly you violated not just the legal system but the God. However, if you backup for good and in God's way, you don't need to care too much about man made legal system. Do we have any lawyers here that can provide us a clear view of what's legal and what's not? I want a pattern lawyer's advice.
If you talk about custom firmware illegal or not, that's another totally different ethical debate as SONY also sent out spys to the custom firmware developers to steal their source code. Our world is full of evil. SONY can be evil, Hackers are too, but both maintain a certain balance.
It is illegal to download software that are copyright protected. Since all PSP games are copyright protected, therefore downloading from unauthorized website are considered as illegal. Playstation Network download is 100% legal.
My old Fat PSP is 3.30 OE-A and Slim PSP running 3.71 M33-2. Both are custom firmware and SONY claim to squeeze out 91gram weight from fat PSP to make SLIM? I now even squeeze out the extra UMD weight, HAHA!
BRICKING the PSP by modifying with custom firmware is HISTORY guys!
I can even UNBRICK any PSP using PANDORA BATTERY and Memory Card. That technique can save your money toward SONY's warranty, why? Because you can 100% backup your own PSP NAND FLASH and 100% restore it back in case your PSP is bricked. That means you don't need to void the warranty. This is also LEGAL because just like Norton Ghost or any other data recovery program to create an image of your storage device as a backup in case something goes wrong. All cooperates have backup servers so they don't need to pay thousands to million of dollars to data recovery service.
So we are in this ethical debate are we? Entering the Gray Area?
I personally like to download the full game of FFT for example then purchase it later in stores. Why? Convenient, and FAST! Because FFT is on the net weeks before the offical UMD release. If SONY wants to fight piracy or make full profit from games sales, they should start selling new PSP or PSP2 games via Playstation Network. I really HATE UMD! Waste my PSP battery physical storage space and makes the PSP heavy because of the UMD slot! Final ethical issue:do you think paying $39.99 for a game that was released back in 1997 plus some slight new video clips worth it? Is SONY charging ethically? With that price at least SONY can or may be able save tiny portion of their lost in their PS3 development. SQUARE-ENIX can also get more $$ to develop FF13 and so on. Love everybody including your enemies. Make your mormal judgement.
Sony should learn more from APPLE's iTunes. Download software content is the future not selling physical storage media. UMD is rubbish!
Log in to comment