red dead redemption vs gta 4

wich one should i get for both Single player and multiplayer

Grand Theft Auto 4 has too much city (in my opinion).

Red Dead Redemption doesn't have enough (again, also in my opinion).

However, I prefer Red Dead Redemption.

Yeah...RD by far....but let me warn you, the minute you step foot in free-roam...be prepaired for a bullet to the head. It's really just like the wild wild west!!!!

Red Dead Redemption i would say. It has a great campaign and a HUGE world to explore. When you complete the original RD be sure to get the undead expansion. it adds a whole new campaign and KILLING ZOMBIES :D

Red Dead Redemption is by far the superior game....get it

Red dead! Iv put over 200 hours into multiplayer alone.

red dead r.

Both amazing experience, but personally I'd recommend Red Dead Redemption because the amazingly replicated western atmosphere that is so authentic.

they amazingly replicated western atmosphere that is so authentic.

Venom_Raptor

Yeah, especially in the MP....fools running around causing all types of anarchy!!!:P

I wouldn't say "by a long shot" but Read Dead is a better game.