Resident Evil 5 vs Gta IV vs MGS4

they are all good

Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5JUSER1032

mgs4 stomps down everything this gen.. best game this gen hands down.

[QUOTE="JUSER1032"]Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5___gamemaster__

mgs4 stomps down everything this gen.. best game this gen hands down.

^ This. MGS4 is really really good.

The best game you have in your collection is MGS4, IMO, but the rest are very good games too.

The best one is Resident Evil 5. Second is GTA IV. I don't like MGS4.

They are all great but MGS4 beats all :twisted::twisted::twisted::twisted::twisted::twisted:

Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5JUSER1032

agreed!

Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5JUSER1032

well for me..

1. MGS4

2. Uncharted

3. Killzone 2

The best one is Resident Evil 5. Second is GTA IV. I don't like MGS4.

M0wen10

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

[QUOTE="JUSER1032"]Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5THQ88

mgs4 stomps down everything this gen.. best game this gen hands down.

^ This. MGS4 is really really good.

I personally rank those games in this order:

1. GTA IV
2. RE5
3. MGS4

I hate to repeat what 90% of people already wrote but....... MGS4. Best game this gen..... PERIOD!!

RE5

[QUOTE="M0wen10"]

The best one is Resident Evil 5. Second is GTA IV. I don't like MGS4.

JOHN117_basic

I have Dead Space, and yes it is better.

GTA IV > RE5 > MGS4.

MGS4 wasn't fun to me. It was just boring.

nothing comes close to MGS4 this generation till now.

Well i havent played mgs but out of the other 2 id say RE5 is the best

Hey Gamespot Users, Yesterday I just bought RE5 and I'm trying to see which is the best from my collection, personally I think the best game from these three is Metal Gear Solid 4 :) 1.MGS4 2.GTA IV 3.RE5JUSER1032

Yeah Mgs4 is the is the best ;) then Re5 then Gta 4 i really dont like that game

Personal Rank for those 3

1. GTA IV

2. MGS 4

never played RE5, resident evil was nevel my type of game, its control feels weird for me...

ranking for games i had

1. GTA IV (reason i bought ps3, hands down)

2. Killzone 2 (best shooter i've played in a while, i got bored of playing cod4 on my pc =.=)

3. MGS 4 (not as much fun as gta and kz but still great)

4. FIFA 09 (best soccer game i've ever played XP period)

5. Uncharted (great game, but just not as good as the rest)

I don't do very well "comparing" games as it seems to change with whatever mood I'm in. But Metal Gear Solid 4 is in my highest regard.

Personally I felt MGS4 was sooo overrated. Yes I played it and yes I'm over 20 years old. Honestly, of the three, I have had the most fun with RE5. All 3 were great games...but they were all disappointing to me in some ways.