This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for AFK4Lifez
AFK4Lifez

691

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#1 AFK4Lifez
Member since 2006 • 691 Posts

Alright I realize this is the Playstation 3 forum and I can tell what the majority result will be, but i figured maybe you guys can help give me some more incentive towards my purchase. The question of course is whether I should invest in a PS3 60gb or a Xbox360 Elite.

I am not biased towards any company and want the best playing experience possible. (Which in turn means i'll eventually have purchased all of the new gen consoles.)

Here's a few of my buying points:

1. I currently lack an HDTV but I am planning on buying at least a 26ish inch 720p HDTV.

2. A few of the games I'm wanting to purchase for each console are:

PS3: Armored Core 4, Resistance: Fall of Man, and Motorstorm

360: Gears of War, Armored Core 4, and GRAW2

3. I enjoy a good single-player experience more than anything, but online does have its upsides.

Pros and Cons

 

PS3 PROS

Integrated Wi-fi

Free Online

Blu-ray

Upgradeable Hard-drive

PS3 CONS

$600 pricetag

Current lack of "must-have" games.

Current lack of rumble.

360 ELITE PROS

$480 Price tag

Current game line-up good.

Rumble

Good online service (Albeit monthly payments.)

120gb HDD

Achievements

360 ELITE CONS

Lack of integrated wi-fi.

Tray-loader DVD Drive

Hardware Failures.

 

I'd just like some opinions and incentive from the PS3 community to help my decision. While I know most answers will end up as PS3, please post your reasoning and ideals behind that decision.

Thanks

NOTE: THIS IS NOT A PS3 VS 360 THREAD, LET'S KEEP IT THAT WAY!

 

 

Avatar image for KurupSoldr
KurupSoldr

4094

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 0

#2 KurupSoldr
Member since 2006 • 4094 Posts

Alright I realize this is the Playstation 3 forum and I can tell what the majority result will be. but i figured maybe you guys can help give me some more incentive towards my purchase.  The question of course is whether I should invest in a PS3 60gb or a Xbox360 Elite.

I am not biased towards any company and want the best playing experience possible. (Which in turn means i'll eventually have purchased all of the new gen consoles.) 

Here's a few of my buying points:

1. I currently lack an HDTV but I am planning on buying at least a 26ish inch 720p HDTV.

2. A few of the games I'm wanting to purchase for each console are:

    PS3: Armored Core 4, Resistance: Fall of Man, and Motorstorm

    360: Gears of War, Armored Core 4, and GRAW2

3. I enjoy a good single-player experience more than anything, but online does have its upsides.

Pros and Cons

 

PS3 PROS

Integrated Wi-fi

Free Online

Blu-ray 

Upgradeable Hard-drive 

PS3 CONS

$600 pricetag 

Current lack of "must-have" games.

Current lack of rumble. 

360 ELITE PROS

$480 Price tag

Current game line-up good.

Rumble 

Good online service (Albeit monthly payments.)

120gb HDD 

360 ELITE CONS

Lack of integrated wi-fi.

Tray-loader DVD Drive

Hardware Failures. 

 

I'd just like some opinions and incentive from the PS3 community to help my decision.  While I know most answers will end up as PS3, please post your reasoning and ideals behind that decision.

Thanks

 

 

 

AFK4Lifez
you pretty much are answering your own question with all the pros and cons you have between both systems, it really comes down to what game you want more RFOM or gears of war, since the other two are on both systems. i have both systems and thy are both good. if you want to spend mor emoney bcuase of the blu ray get the ps3 if you dont care about that get the 360 but to go oline you pay close to the same as a ps3 if you want the wifi adapter since its 100$
Avatar image for AFK4Lifez
AFK4Lifez

691

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#3 AFK4Lifez
Member since 2006 • 691 Posts
Well of course I could just buy a 3rd party adapter for around $30. :P
Avatar image for dstryr13
dstryr13

6521

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#4 dstryr13
Member since 2007 • 6521 Posts
[QUOTE="AFK4Lifez"]

Alright I realize this is the Playstation 3 forum and I can tell what the majority result will be. but i figured maybe you guys can help give me some more incentive towards my purchase.  The question of course is whether I should invest in a PS3 60gb or a Xbox360 Elite.

I am not biased towards any company and want the best playing experience possible. (Which in turn means i'll eventually have purchased all of the new gen consoles.) 

Here's a few of my buying points:

1. I currently lack an HDTV but I am planning on buying at least a 26ish inch 720p HDTV.

2. A few of the games I'm wanting to purchase for each console are:

    PS3: Armored Core 4, Resistance: Fall of Man, and Motorstorm

    360: Gears of War, Armored Core 4, and GRAW2

3. I enjoy a good single-player experience more than anything, but online does have its upsides.

Pros and Cons

 

PS3 PROS

Integrated Wi-fi

Free Online

Blu-ray 

Upgradeable Hard-drive 

PS3 CONS

$600 pricetag 

Current lack of "must-have" games.

Current lack of rumble. 

360 ELITE PROS

$480 Price tag

Current game line-up good.

Rumble 

Good online service (Albeit monthly payments.)

120gb HDD 

360 ELITE CONS

Lack of integrated wi-fi.

Tray-loader DVD Drive

Hardware Failures. 

 

I'd just like some opinions and incentive from the PS3 community to help my decision.  While I know most answers will end up as PS3, please post your reasoning and ideals behind that decision.

Thanks

 

 

 

KurupSoldr
you pretty much are answering your own question with all the pros and cons you have between both systems, it really comes down to what game you want more RFOM or gears of war, since the other two are on both systems. i have both systems and thy are both good. if you want to spend mor emoney bcuase of the blu ray get the ps3 if you dont care about that get the 360 but to go oline you pay close to the same as a ps3 if you want the wifi adapter since its 100$

well not necessarily because he also wants motorstorm so go by that- you want 2 exclusives over one i say PS3 if that is the case
Avatar image for soundthealarm
soundthealarm

316

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#5 soundthealarm
Member since 2007 • 316 Posts
all the cons you have for the ps3 are "current" by the end of the year they'll have sick games and perhaps a rumble controller, you're better off in the long run with the ps3
Avatar image for KurupSoldr
KurupSoldr

4094

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 0

#6 KurupSoldr
Member since 2006 • 4094 Posts
Well of course I could just buy a 3rd party adapter for around $30. :PAFK4Lifez
true you could but now with the elite you are spending 510 plus tax for that so lets say 535$ for 65$ more you get the blu ray player which is better deal then having to fork over for the HD DVD in the event you end up wanting smething ike that, its tough choice you get all the cables you need with the elite you have to buy them if you get the ps3 so pick your poison whats more important to you and like ^^^he said you want 2 exclusives over one so just comes down to what suits your needs better
Avatar image for Trek5200
Trek5200

599

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#7 Trek5200
Member since 2007 • 599 Posts

Alright I realize this is the Playstation 3 forum and I can tell what the majority result will be, but i figured maybe you guys can help give me some more incentive towards my purchase. The question of course is whether I should invest in a PS3 60gb or a Xbox360 Elite.

I am not biased towards any company and want the best playing experience possible. (Which in turn means i'll eventually have purchased all of the new gen consoles.)

Here's a few of my buying points:

1. I currently lack an HDTV but I am planning on buying at least a 26ish inch 720p HDTV.

2. A few of the games I'm wanting to purchase for each console are:

PS3: Armored Core 4, Resistance: Fall of Man, and Motorstorm

360: Gears of War, Armored Core 4, and GRAW2

3. I enjoy a good single-player experience more than anything, but online does have its upsides.

Pros and Cons

 

PS3 PROS

Integrated Wi-fi

Free Online

Blu-ray

Upgradeable Hard-drive

PS3 CONS

$600 pricetag

Current lack of "must-have" games.

Current lack of rumble.

360 ELITE PROS

$480 Price tag

Current game line-up good.

Rumble

Good online service (Albeit monthly payments.)

120gb HDD

Achievements

360 ELITE CONS

Lack of integrated wi-fi.

Tray-loader DVD Drive

Hardware Failures.

 

I'd just like some opinions and incentive from the PS3 community to help my decision. While I know most answers will end up as PS3, please post your reasoning and ideals behind that decision.

Thanks

NOTE: THIS IS NOT A PS3 VS 360 THREAD, LET'S KEEP IT THAT WAY!

 

 

AFK4Lifez
I have no beef with either system, ultimately the choice is yours. The one glaring beacon of trouble I see is the Cons for the 360. Hardware failure. Have you actually checked out the 360 forum for the posts there? Or looked around the net regarding the percentage of failure? If all those articles are true I have no idea how people are not looking for blood. I can say with certainty that if Sony had failrates anywhere near those numbers there would be a revolt!! The press and public outcry would be crazy! Look at all the bad press Sony got over BC for Europe even though they had 70% or better covered.
Avatar image for eclipsed4utoo
eclipsed4utoo

10578

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#8 eclipsed4utoo
Member since 2006 • 10578 Posts

Alright I realize this is the Playstation 3 forum and I can tell what the majority result will be, but i figured maybe you guys can help give me some more incentive towards my purchase. The question of course is whether I should invest in a PS3 60gb or a Xbox360 Elite.

I am not biased towards any company and want the best playing experience possible. (Which in turn means i'll eventually have purchased all of the new gen consoles.)

Here's a few of my buying points:

1. I currently lack an HDTV but I am planning on buying at least a 26ish inch 720p HDTV.

2. A few of the games I'm wanting to purchase for each console are:

PS3: Armored Core 4, Resistance: Fall of Man, and Motorstorm

360: Gears of War, Armored Core 4, and GRAW2

3. I enjoy a good single-player experience more than anything, but online does have its upsides.

Pros and Cons

PS3 PROS

Integrated Wi-fi

Free Online

Blu-ray

Upgradeable Hard-drive

PS3 CONS

$600 pricetag

Current lack of "must-have" games.

Current lack of rumble.

360 ELITE PROS

$480 Price tag

Current game line-up good.

Rumble

Good online service (Albeit monthly payments.)

120gb HDD

Achievements

360 ELITE CONS

Lack of integrated wi-fi.

Tray-loader DVD Drive

Hardware Failures.

I'd just like some opinions and incentive from the PS3 community to help my decision. While I know most answers will end up as PS3, please post your reasoning and ideals behind that decision.

Thanks

NOTE: THIS IS NOT A PS3 VS 360 THREAD, LET'S KEEP IT THAT WAY!

AFK4Lifez
looks like you answered your own question. and Xbox Live is one yearly payment($40 or $50, I can't remember), not monthly payments.
Avatar image for spazzx625
spazzx625

43433

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 54

User Lists: 0

#9 spazzx625
Member since 2004 • 43433 Posts
While I do appreciate the well thought out thread...This still isn't the right forum, sorry.