VOte for the game you think is better ??

its really hard !! .. But try to choose only one xD

easy UC2

Red Dead Redemption for me:)

Actually it is not hard at all lol. All great games but I think it is quite easy to say UC2 is the best out of them ;). It was the most consistently awesome game of the three.

I'm going to have to say "Red Dead" right now, because I wasn't that into "Uncharted"... I know, I know... what don't I like? It's getting to be a constant question asked of me lately (I have also expressed dislike for "InFamous" & "BioShock" to gnashing teeth and cries of "Communist" and worse).

:?

Please Don't Hurt Me.

*cringe*

I'm just more cool with the novelty of the Ol' West at this point than tomb-raiding (though UC obviously teaches my fav Lara a thing or two in graphics and gameplay).

I'm going to have to say "Red Dead" right now, because I wasn't that into "Uncharted"... I know, I know... what don't I like? It's getting to be a constant question asked of me lately (I have also expressed dislike for "InFamous" & "BioShock" to gnashing teeth and cries of "Communist" and worse).

:?

Please Don't Hurt Me.

*cringe*

I'm just more cool with the novelty of the Ol' West at this point than tomb-raiding (though UC obviously teaches my fav Lara a thing or two in graphics and gameplay).

MonkeySpot

Infamous while a great game, was not AMAZING or anything, and the technical issues really hindered it. Bioshock seems great aswell, but I just cannot get into it for some reason. That being said UC2 is brilliant from start to finish. You should be ashamed of yourself! :P

This sounds like a "What game should I buy?" thread in disguise...If that's really what it is, then just check out the recommendation thread ;)

[QUOTE="MonkeySpot"]

I'm going to have to say "Red Dead" right now, because I wasn't that into "Uncharted"... I know, I know... what don't I like? It's getting to be a constant question asked of me lately (I have also expressed dislike for "InFamous" & "BioShock" to gnashing teeth and cries of "Communist" and worse).

:?

Please Don't Hurt Me.

*cringe*

I'm just more cool with the novelty of the Ol' West at this point than tomb-raiding (though UC obviously teaches my fav Lara a thing or two in graphics and gameplay).

NaveedLife

Infamous while a great game, was not AMAZING or anything, and the technical issues really hindered it. Bioshock seems great aswell, but I just cannot get into it for some reason. That being said UC2 is brilliant from start to finish. You should be ashamed of yourself! :P

I'll get back around to the "Uncharted" games... I intend to finish both but when I started one, it was just sort of the wrong time. I think I had finished "Tomb Raider Anniversary" or something. Like I said I'm a dyed-in-the-wool Lara Croft fan and I love those types of games, I'm just sort of taking a sebatical from games of that context (jungles, treasure, etc). So much has been said by people in the press and folks on this forum whom I respect that I will see them through... when the price drops a skad... Honestly, I looked at "Drake's Fortune" at a resale yesterday or the day before and it's still holding a price over $40 - Telling in so many ways, but still cost prohobitive for me at the moment.

And, I need to finish other games first... and maybe do the Evil side of "InFamous"... it has it's moments, I suppose. I'm expecting much greater things (and polish) out of the "Uncharted" games when I put a mind to them finally.

All of that said, I'm still really grooving on what Rockstar has done for the Western... it's the type of immersion I got from the 'First of it'sKind"Grand Theft Auto III". THe kind of world where there's a bunch of stuff to find, places to discover... and it's really beautiful to just stop and LOOK... and I love a good sandbox game that hypnotizes you, it's been too long since we've really seen one. Y'know?

While I'm on the subject I think it's kind of wrong to call "InFamous" a sandbox, it's more just Open-World... the difference in my opinion, stemming from a world having lots of side projects, activities, and general action. With "InFamous", outside of the Dead Drops, there really wasn't that much to do for, to, or in that city... after getting your "Doctor Cole" trophy etc., that is...

Hopefully they build on the solid foundation and promise of the first game... because blowing some of those bad guys up with electro-grenades from a huge distance getting the takedown, High Fall, AND live capture points (sometimes as a multiple!) really was cheer-inducing at times.

Wow... can I drone on endlessly or WHAT?!?

:oops:

Sorry.

This sounds like a "What game should I buy?" thread in disguise...If that's really what it is, then just check out the recommendation thread ;)

Ospov

Wow even though I like all of them a lot I will have to say its a tie between Uncharted 2 and God of War 3

Red Dead Redemption

I prefer Uncharted 2. God of War 3 and RDR then follow in that order.

ive only played the demo but uncharted 2 by a land slide

GoW has never been my cup of tea. I tried to play Red Dead Redemption but I had the most fun just randomly shooting people for the hell of it. Uncharted 2 still holds number 1 in my heart. There has yet to be a game to knock it off its perch. All I need now is Uncharted 3: Manifest Destiny... What did Lewis and Clark uncover with Sacagawea? (completely made up by the way...)

i cant really vote cause ive only beaten uncharted 2 and barely played gow 3 and red dead redemption.

I'd say Red Dead Redemption

I voted for Red Dead Redemption.. I felt the single player was waaay to short for GOW3 same with Uncharted 2... it was great an all.. but i beat both games in a day each... (uncharted 2 i beat twice in 1 day!, it was great but i could've just rented it,PoisoN_Facecam0

I have no idea how you managed to beat UC2 twice in a day? I must be doing it wrong....................

Anyway best of the 3 UC2 for me

Uncharted 2. I havent played GoW 3 yet, but it will be very hard for it to top U2.

Red Dead is very good. I especially love the setting, and all that entails, but the gameplay doesn't even come close to how silky smooth Uncharted 2 is.

Red Dead Redemption.