what ????? dragon dogma reviews ??

i just enter to metacritic site and search for dragon dogma and i found this reviews

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

and for other consol :

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

What's your point?

highest score is a 92, and then the lowest score is a 48?? wtf? that 48 score sounds highly biased and written by a casual call of duty gamer

What's your point?

MonkeySpot

highest score is a 92, and then the lowest score is a 48?? wtf? that 48 score sounds highly biased and written by a casual call of duty gamer

soundcellx

What if they do like CoD does that make them less of a gamer then you or I?DSkinMasque

[QUOTE="DSkinMasque"]What if they do like CoD does that make them less of a gamer then you or I?soundcellx

[QUOTE="soundcellx"]

[QUOTE="DSkinMasque"]What if they do like CoD does that make them less of a gamer then you or I?DSkinMasque

[QUOTE="DSkinMasque"][QUOTE="soundcellx"]why yes, yes it does.

oh and the thing is here that it reeks of bias since 2 out of 3 of those reviews are 85 and 92/100s and then this one scores it a 48/100. that is total BS and you and i both know it. something smells fishy in Denmark and I smell fish of dooty

soundcellx

capcom include resident evil 6 in dragon dogma, maybe this will make people buy the game , even the review is down Alessandro1001

capcom include resident evil 6 in dragon dogma, maybe this will make people buy the game , even the review is down Alessandro1001

It comes with the demo that will be playable in september if you buy dragon's dogma. And imo everyone is entitled to their own opinion, just because you think it is wrong doesn't make them wrong, which is why I only use reviews as one source of information about new games.

[QUOTE="Alessandro1001"]capcom include resident evil 6 in dragon dogma, maybe this will make people buy the game , even the review is down who77

It comes with the demo that will be playable in september if you buy dragon's dogma. And imo everyone is entitled to their own opinion, just because you think it is wrong doesn't make them wrong, which is why I only use reviews as one source of information about new games.

Since the demo didn't show any of the game, and just provided two combat scenarios, judging the entire game based on demo experience would be kind of pointless. Could you judge "Skyrim" on two fights? If TES came out as such a limited, truncated demo, the combat would seem clunky and if the game was new and had no precedent, one might be mistaken to think the game was unpolished and not worth playing. TES is about exploration and the individual experiences gamers have which are unique from case to case. So, judging it based on two combat scenarios wouldn't be right.

"Dragon's Dogma" might not be a good game. Who's actually being "biased" here? The reviewer who says it sucks or the one who says it's perfect? You have no idea who's been bought in this situation, or who's being biased... And in the end, a review is an opinion. That's all it is, nothing more.

;)

Its just opinions man. If you do not respect who wrote it it means nothing.

[QUOTE="DSkinMasque"]What if they do like CoD does that make them less of a gamer then you or I?soundcellx

Wow, I guess if enjoying COD makes me less of a gamer I don't want to be a good one. I bought the games and enjoyed them, and don't think any less for doing so. So tell me, who's the real loser?

And even if the review was biased how does that make them a Call of Duty gamer? What does that franchise even have to do with Dragon's Dogma?

[QUOTE="soundcellx"]

[QUOTE="DSkinMasque"]What if they do like CoD does that make them less of a gamer then you or I?brickdoctor

Wow, I guess if enjoying COD makes me less of a gamer I don't want to be a good one. I bought the games and enjoyed them, and don't think any less for doing so. So tell me, who's the real loser?

And even if the review was biased how does that make them a Call of Duty gamer? What does that franchise even have to do with Dragon's Dogma?

this game doesn't look good honestly, first video I saw was flawed technically (lots of collision bugs, mechanic movement of characters) and for layout of town, NPCs, menus ... the demo only confirmed that, customisation of the character is beyond poor

There are some things like the repetition of pawn combat phrases that don't bode well for extended play, and that's really what this type of game caters to. I was much more taken with the "Amalur" demo, though if they patch a few things I could see this game being fun. Trading and training pawns across the net is an interesting theme, they had something like it in "Gran Turismo 5" where you could use friend's AI driver pool for your races, and the drivers gained experience and cash they took home to thier "garage" the next time the owner signed on.

It promoted friend stuff and good will in the GT community, encouraging teamwork of sorts, I don't see where this game would be too different.

I think they have a lot to fix, though.

:)

And i still say that the demo of "Dogma" can't be very representative of the final game - It's two battles and nothing else. Imagine if all you had to judge "Skyrim" on was two quick fights? The game, as we all know, is SO much more.

(I don't play it and I'm not a fan, but millions of devotees can't be too wrong)

:D

I think DD should be on any fantasy gamer's list at SOME point. Perhaps not $60us (or your local equivalent), but SOME time...

i thought the demo was fantasic, although super short. i've completed it around 10 times, extremely excited about this game. day 1 buy for me.

i just enter to metacritic site and search for dragon dogma and i found this reviews

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

and for other consol :

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

Alessandro1001

[QUOTE="Alessandro1001"]

i just enter to metacritic site and search for dragon dogma and i found this reviews

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

and for other consol :

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/dragons-dogma/critic-reviews

carmelgene

Welcome to the forums, froshie. Read all of the posts in the thread, and then you would know where the conversation has progressed. The point is the vast difference in one review from the other two (one trashes it, the other two glow about it). If you had bothered to read first, THEN post, you would have seen that I asked the same question and there was an answer to your question already.

:roll:

I liked the character customisation alot, but the gameplay itself as not my idea of fun. Great idea, poor exectution overall.