05 draft qb class worst ever? and will this yr class be real bad?

matt ryan will be like alex smith scouts love him but bad nfl player gtap00ner

Matt Ryan is already better than Alex Smith, he could go to SF and take his job right now. I think that he will have the best career of this years QB class by far.

I'm not out on Alex Smith yet. He had a pretty okay year with Norv Turner. Also everything has been working against him so far. 3 years and 3 different offensive coordinators, little talent on offense. He was horrible last year, but I think with some stability he'll be fine.

Campbell is a good player. He's the undisputed QB of the Skins and if he continues to improve, he will be that for a long time.

Rodgers simply hasn't had a shot. I don't think anyone is a bust yet.

Alex Smith has had a horrible career so far but he's had to deal with so much change and lack of weapons I don't know how much is him and how much is what he's dealt.

Jason Campbell's career is in real danger. He never got his job back after being injured last season and he wasn't going to be the starter in camp next season, he was going to have to earn it again. Many sources in the Redskin offices said that they thought Collins would be the starter next season also.

With a new coaching system in place he has a chance to come in and earn the starting job much easier because all the QB's there will be starting from scratch with the new people.

Aaron Rodgers is a very good QB and I'm not sure why no one had traded for him. While Favre's been screwing with the people of Green Bay for years (only coming through last season) Rodgers has been waiting for any time to play and last season when he was on the field in Dallas he ran the team better then Favre was doing.

He might be able to be a starter for a team or he could be another Craig Nall, the problem is that we don't know.

Smith is just not doing what an nfl qb is supposed to. Hes agile but rarely attempts running. He can throw but his recievers cnat catch so thats not his fault. Im sure if he was traded to the dolphins who have a decent WR core or even the Jets hed be better

Campbell had a rough year but I think he'l sit back up for Collins after what the Redskins saw in COllins. He hasnt played for 12 years and he brought the redskins to a playoff loss(but he still took them to the playoffs)

Rodgers like everyone says rarely plays. He has a good arm and good accuracy he could be the next favre. If he ever retires that is.Favre could be like testaverde and play till 41 and the packers would never FA him since hes been around for so long