bigger letdown? cedric benson, ronnie brown, or carnell (cadillac) williams

they r all bust. top 5 picks in 05 draft. but brown had a pretty good year b4 he got injured.

but benson was a huge letdown he cant run hes slow.

Brown is not a bust. He's a top 10 back who was injured this year.

Cadillact is really, really injury prone. But he's proven to be a good back, so unless he's injured for the rest of his career, he won't be a bust either.

Benson is supposed to be a bruiser, but he's never done anything yet.

Reggie Bush. :(JayPee89

All Busts?

Ronnie Brown - 1,915 yds in first two seasons, 600 in 2007 over 7 games in 2007...Nope. (4.4 ypc) Also, he missed the last 3 games of the season where he had 1,000 yards.

Carnell "Cadillac" Williams - 1,976 yds in first two seasons, 200 yds in 4 games in 2007...Nope. (3.8 ypc)

Cedric Benson - 1,593 yds total (yes, I know he split time with Thomas Jones first two seasons), injured in SB XLI, and after 11 games this season. (3.8 ypc)

The vote goes to Benson only. At his current rate, he would've fallen just short of 1,000 yards. Meanwhile, the other two backs have each done it once, and been close to it in the non-injury season that they didn't make it.