Manning vs Brady...

Really do you? Do you realize before their career is over, these two quarterbacks could EASILY be the undisputed 1-2 quarterback in the history of football? I feel sad for football fans 10 years from now. No matter who they have, they'll never get to experience the greatest, purest quarterback rivalry in the history of the sport. By purest I mean, two quarterbacks of this caliber where it's as much a QB rivalry as a team rivalry.

Man I feel lucky.

For sure they're two of the best to play the game. I don't think it is really possible to rank them by numbers but to me there is no question they're two of the best of all time.

It is amazing because there are maybe two or three other QBs out there that are "ok" and the rest mostly poor.

*Slaps forehead*

O boy, I am really going to have to hear this all week :?

*Slaps forehead*

O boy, I am really going to have to hear this all week :?

limpbizkit818

If anything is worth hearing all week, it's this.

LMAO I just posted in the thread about the Pats "running up the score" and this was something I posted.

"EDIT: If players are having a good game why should they be benched? Records would never be broken if that was the case. In the future Brady's stats will be compared with the greatest known but with people wanting him benched his true stats would be discarded. I can imagine a future thread with the topic being: "Brady or Manning" (kinda like Young and Marino) and people would pull out facts like the single season TD passing record."

I guess the future is here!!!!:shock:

EDIT: The EDIT above was for the thread but this EDIT is for this topic. I think Manning and Brady are both equal but both play a different style. Really what makes their stats are the different players around them.

The way my friend summed it up, this is superbowl 41 1/2.

This is a great game every year.

*Slaps forehead*

O boy, I am really going to have to hear this all week :?

limpbizkit818

Right now, I feel lucky to be able to watch quite possibly the greatest football player to ever play the game.

Manning and Brady are great QBs but Favre is a great football player and a legend. Madden doesn't have a man crush on him for his looks.

[QUOTE="limpbizkit818"]

*Slaps forehead*

O boy, I am really going to have to hear this all week :?

mastershake575

I agree

The fact that I have seen "Over-Rated Manning" in this thread tells me that someone doesn't know about football. Peyton Manning is THE best QB TO EVER play the game of football. I'm putting him above Dan Fouts, Warren Moon, Steve Young, Johnny Unitas, and everyone else. Peyton's ability to find the open man, and to deliver the ball with such perfect touch, is simply amazing.

I don't like Tom Brady, but I respect his play. He is another great quarter back; he is probably one of the most composed QBs in the game today. You could send a train at him and he would stay in the pocket. But I think Brady is second to a lot of people. Peyton for one. So I would take Peyton any day over Tom Brady. Taking nothing away from Tom tho, Peyton is just better.

I'll take Brady all day everyday over Over-rated Manning...tryfe_lyn

The fact that I have seen "Over-Rated Manning" in this thread tells me that someone doesn't know about football. Peyton Manning is THE best QB TO EVER play the game of football. I'm putting him above Dan Fouts, Warren Moon, Steve Young, Johnny Unitas, and everyone else. Peyton's ability to find the open man, and to deliver the ball with such perfect touch, is simply amazing.

I don't like Tom Brady, but I respect his play. He is another great quarter back; he is probably one of the most composed QBs in the game today. You could send a train at him and he would stay in the pocket. But I think Brady is second to a lot of people. Peyton for one. So I would take Peyton any day over Tom Brady. Taking nothing away from Tom tho, Peyton is just better.

Romer318

How lucky are we to see the best RB of all time play?HurricaneHugo

Barry Sanders retired years ago.

Yes they are two of the greatest QBs of our time at the moment. But as I have always said before, history/tradition was meant to be broken. NFL records come and go. How long until the next Brady or Manninge like QB to come out and compete, no one knows. It will eventually happen.

Brady is on fire right now!!

The fact that I have seen "Over-Rated Manning" in this thread tells me that someone doesn't know about football. Peyton Manning is THE best QB TO EVER play the game of football. I'm putting him above Dan Fouts, Warren Moon, Steve Young, Johnny Unitas, and everyone else. Peyton's ability to find the open man, and to deliver the ball with such perfect touch, is simply amazing.

I don't like Tom Brady, but I respect his play. He is another great quarter back; he is probably one of the most composed QBs in the game today. You could send a train at him and he would stay in the pocket. But I think Brady is second to a lot of people. Peyton for one. So I would take Peyton any day over Tom Brady. Taking nothing away from Tom tho, Peyton is just better.

Romer318

It was just one guy. Ignore him. Anyone calling either of these quarterbacks overrated is just trying to incite a response.

How lucky are we to see the best RB of all time play?HurricaneHugo

Yeah, LT is the man ;)

[QUOTE="HurricaneHugo"]How lucky are we to see the best RB of all time play?mrgab

Barry Sanders retired years ago.

yup best RB already retired

Colts and Manning is gonnna win

Eagles and McNabb can beat both