So NOW who is the best QB in the NFL --- POLL !

Now that Manning has a ring and has beat Brady who is the best? Brady has 2 more rings, but we all know those rings were total team/coaching wins. Its not like Brady would have had those rings if he played on the Raiders. And Mannings stats are vastly better.

I say its not close Manning >>>>>> Brady. And I'm a Niners fan so I could care less about AFC teams.

Look at the Stats

Manning - 9 years played, has never missed a practice.

- 94.4 QB Rating, 4176 Average passing yards per season, 30.5 Passing TD;s a year, 15 INTs per year, 1 Title

Brady - 6 Seasons (did have 1 pass in '00 not gonna count that in averages)

- 88.4 QB rating, 3594 average passing yards per season, 24.5 Passing TD's a year, 13 INTs per year, 3 Titles.

Edit: If you choose "other" please post who you think.

Peyton EASILY :)

Brady

Well Peyton has the stats and a ring however Tom Brady has some pretty decent stats to but there not as good as Mannings so really though there both great quarterbacks they've done a lot since they entered the league theres no one better then them in my opinion.  I have respect for both quarterbacks but if your just going to vote against Brady or Manning because you hate one of them then you probably shouldnt even bother.

Brady, people are forgetting that the Pats lost their 2 best WR's Branch and Givens. Anyways I'd go with Brady.

Tom Brady

ummm oh did you manage add offensive weapons to your average? i didn't think so. the point is i will never acknowledge peyton until he show he can play on a team that's not as stacked on offense. Let's look at the Colt's offense.....beat lineman in football that's why peyton only get a sack a few times a year. Great WR like harrison and wayne. Even TE clark is not as bad as his stats might suggest. A pretty good RB Joseph Addai (1000+ yards). Now let's go back to Tom Brady....hmm a team with only 1 probowler and thats on D.....offensive wise...hmm dillon? huh? what? there's no one. P.S. I don't have any thing againts Peyton, just I don't see him as the best.
badaboom187

While I agree with you, the Pats have good RB's IMO with Dillon and Maroney, though their WR core is mediocre at best. I've wonder how they managed to get that far into the playoffs with those type of receivers, not to mention the loss of Harrison and Seau.

Tom Brady

ummm oh did you manage add offensive weapons to your average? i didn't think so. the point is i will never acknowledge peyton until he show he can play on a team that's not as stacked on offense. Let's look at the Colt's offense.....beat lineman in football that's why peyton only get a sack a few times a year. Great WR like harrison and wayne. Even TE clark is not as bad as his stats might suggest. A pretty good RB Joseph Addai (1000+ yards). Now let's go back to Tom Brady....hmm a team with only 1 probowler and thats on D.....offensive wise...hmm dillon? huh? what? there's no one. P.S. I don't have any thing againts Peyton, just I don't see him as the best.
badaboom187

If you wanna say Peyton wouldnt be as good w/o Marvin and reggie thats fine. Also take into account that the Pats would have 0 superbowls w/o their sick defense and special teams.

[QUOTE="badaboom187"]Tom Brady

ummm oh did you manage add offensive weapons to your average? i didn't think so. the point is i will never acknowledge peyton until he show he can play on a team that's not as stacked on offense. Let's look at the Colt's offense.....beat lineman in football that's why peyton only get a sack a few times a year. Great WR like harrison and wayne. Even TE clark is not as bad as his stats might suggest. A pretty good RB Joseph Addai (1000+ yards). Now let's go back to Tom Brady....hmm a team with only 1 probowler and thats on D.....offensive wise...hmm dillon? huh? what? there's no one. P.S. I don't have any thing againts Peyton, just I don't see him as the best.
SpideR_CentS

If you wanna say Peyton wouldnt be as good w/o Marvin and reggie thats fine. Also take into account that the Pats would have 0 superbowls w/o their sick defense and special teams.

manning is better at reading defenses and brady is better at making the clutch throws

Most not all but most people who say Peyton is better are either Colts fans or they hate Tom Brady but everyones entitled to there opinion.  Oh and by the way I know how we all like to say Vinatieri and the defense won those superbowls but guess what if that team didnt have Tom Brady at QB to lead them down the field for the win they more then likely wouldnt have been champions.

Most not all but most people who say Peyton is better are either Colts fans or they hate Tom Brady but everyones entitled to there opinion.  Oh and by the way I know how we all like to say Vinatieri and the defense won those superbowls but guess what if that team didnt have Tom Brady at QB to lead them down the field for the win they more then likely wouldnt have been champions.

PatsFanVince

Peyton Manning's 2006 playoff stats:  3 TDs and 7 Ints.  We all know the reason why the Colts won the title this year was because their defense was excellent for most of the playoffs.

That being said, if Peyton is the best QB in the league, Tom Brady is definately #2.  Is there any doubt that Tom Brady would put up Peyton's regular season numbers if he had 2 Pro Bowl recievers and a Pro Bowl offensive line instead of a bunch of #3 wideouts.

There are a few QBs a step below them including McNabb, Palmer, and Brees.

Peyton Manning is, was, has been and will continue to be the best QB in the league. Just to add something. While everyone, fans, media, whoever talks about who is the best those two guys admire and respect the hell out of each other. Now that Manning has his ring, they can both be content knowing they are both champs and are the best two QB's in the league, no doubt.firefox59

Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings is the only stat that I look at.roulettethedog

Wait did I just see someone say that McNabb is better then Brady? Please don't make me laugh.  Yeah McNabb is a good quarterback definetly in the top 5 in the NFL, but come on Brady has put some pretty good stats of his own 24 touchdowns only 12 inteceptions and 61 percent completetion to me thats pretty good with the receivers they had this year. Sure Peyton is probably the better QB, but without question Brady is number 2 in the league and would pick him over McNabb any day.  He does more with less talent which to me and im sure a lot of people is amazing but of course a lot of people will say thats just a excuse but really its the truth.  Oh by the way hows Alex Smith working out for ya?

Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings is the only stat that I look at.roulettethedog

Wait did I just see someone say that McNabb is better then Brady? Please don't make me laugh. Yeah McNabb is a good quarterback definetly in the top 5 in the NFL, but come on Brady has put some pretty good stats of his own 24 touchdowns only 12 inteceptions and 61 percent completetion to me thats pretty good with the receivers they had this year. Sure Peyton is probably the better QB, but without question Brady is number 2 in the league and would pick him over McNabb any day. He does more with less talent which to me and im sure a lot of people is amazing but of course a lot of people will say thats just a excuse but really its the truth. Oh by the way hows Alex Smith working out for ya?

PatsFanVince

[QUOTE="roulettethedog"]Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings is the only stat that I look at.nickdastick

Care to name mediocre-decent QB's that have won 3 Superbowls?

[QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="roulettethedog"]Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings is the only stat that I look at.D3s7rUc71oN

Care to name mediocre-decent QB's that have won 3 Superbowls?

[QUOTE="D3s7rUc71oN"]

[QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="roulettethedog"]Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings is the only stat that I look at.nickdastick

Care to name mediocre-decent QB's that have won 3 Superbowls?

Wow, people are still mentioning the tuck rule? are you serious? You realize that they had to make a 45yd FG in the snow after that call right? Not to mention after the FG that was made, there was OT. I'm sorry but the Raiders couldn't stop them in OT, that's their fault. Just looking for excuses on why they lost the game.

Not to mention the Raiders went to the SB next year, so they got their chance and we already know how that turned out....

As for McNabb better than Brady? :lol: Look McNabb had mediocre WR's, that's why he couldn't get to the SB. By the time they got T.O., he got there but guess what? He lost to the Pats; meanwhile Brady has been winning SB's with mediocre-average WR's.

People...don't mention stats when talking about how good Peyton Manning is, his numbers are inflated. He has so many TDs and yards because he works in a pass happy offense, I mean, how can you NOT have 4000+ passing every year when you throw it 40-50 times per game? That and he has 2 of the top recievers in the league.

Manning is very good, but he's also way overrated too. I absolutely refuse to believe he is among the all time greats until he can prove that he can play under pressure, or on the run. Perfect example: I watched one game recently where he got sacked, and on the next play, was about to get sacked again, and threw the ball right to a defender for an INT, and when you get him out of the pocket, he utterly SUCKS. Plus he gets that stupid whiny face when he throws an incomplete.

[QUOTE="firefox59"]Peyton Manning is, was, has been and will continue to be the best QB in the league. Just to add something. While everyone, fans, media, whoever talks about who is the best those two guys admire and respect the hell out of each other. Now that Manning has his ring, they can both be content knowing they are both champs and are the best two QB's in the league, no doubt.nickdastick