To people who played Madden 08 and NFL 2k5..

Can you tell me which one you liked more and why? I'm thinking about buying Madden 08, but may opt for 2k5 with some updated rosters b/c alot of people are calling it the best football game ever. Also it doesn't hurt Madden is $30 and 2k5 is $3.

madden 08 is absolutely dreadful

i'd opt for All-Pro Football 2K8

madden 08 should be called turnover '08.

manningbowl how do you get an updated roster? I'm thinking of picking up 2k5 now lol.

edit: I can't find ESPN NFL 2k5 on gamestop.com wierd.

manningbowl how do you get an updated roster? I'm thinking of picking up 2k5 now lol.

Just_Osmo

I thought it'd be easy, but sadly need action replay for it. Just bought the console, so I guess I'll just play without last three year's rookies.

Also, can you play as more than one team in a franchise? Me and my brother wants to play each other on franchise.

Obviously Madden 08. 2k5 is so overrated its pathetic.Sports-Fan

you know what's pathetic madden 08 still doesn't have online leagues while 2k5 does

you'll like espn a whole lot better, so pick it up

Obviously Madden 08. 2k5 is so overrated its pathetic.Sports-Fan

Obviously Madden 08. 2k5 is so overrated its pathetic.Sports-Fan

foolish talk like that is what merits 2k5 a worth while sit down. APF2k8 really sucked, so stay away from that recent train wreck... if you enjoy football and don't mindarranging yer own rosters 2k5 is the BEST football game tochoose;)

NFL 2k5 is now backwards compatible on xbox 360!!

Link

NFL 2k5 is now backwards compatible on xbox 360!!

Link

andyboiii

You, my friend, have just made my week. Oh and definitly go with 2k5, this game was madeover 3 years ago and Madden wont be catching up to it till 2015