Top 6 Young QBs

What is your top 6 young QBs who you think will be elite in the future?

My six (in no particular order)

1. Cam Newton

2. Andrew Luck

3. RGIII

4. Andy Dalton

5. Matthew Stafford

6. Jake Locker

Defining "young" as drafted 2009 or earlier:

1. Cam Newton

2. Matthew Stafford

3. Andrew Luck

4. RG3

5. Dalton

6. Freeman but honestly it's pretty much a crapshoot. Ponder and Locker are unproven, Bradford is talented but way too injury prone, and Freeman took a huge step back this year.

The better question would be like last year's "top 5 QBs 5 years from now" or something along this lines.

Stafford at 5? Did you forget that he threw for 5,000 yards this season?monkeytoes61

The better question would be like last year's "top 5 QBs 5 years from now" or something along this lines.

Boston_Boyy

Cam Newton

Andy Dalton

Freeman

RG3

Locker

Blaine Gabbert..lol jk

Jake Locker for the win. Also, Ryan Malletjuden41

Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling.

It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.

He's solid, but nowhere near as great as people try to make him into. I remember on ESPN the other day they said that the Panthers will be first place in the NFC South this upcoming season due to him. That definitely made my day.

Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling. It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.ice144

[QUOTE="ice144"]Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling. It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.sherman-tank1

Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling.

It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.

He's solid, but nowhere near as great as people try to make him into. I remember on ESPN the other day they said that the Panthers will be first place in the NFC South this upcoming season due to him. That definitely made my day.

ice144

I think you're fibbing

Taking two people who've never played over someone who's done pretty well in his first NFL season?

I don't buy it

[QUOTE="sherman-tank1"]

[QUOTE="ice144"]Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling. It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.ice144

brynden weedin

[QUOTE="ice144"]

Lol wow the cam newton love is baffling.

It's as if the entire world only watched his first two games. I'd take luck, RG3 and stafford over him any day.

He's solid, but nowhere near as great as people try to make him into. I remember on ESPN the other day they said that the Panthers will be first place in the NFC South this upcoming season due to him. That definitely made my day.

Jaysonguy

I think you're fibbing

Taking two people who've never played over someone who's done pretty well in his first NFL season?

I don't buy it

brynden weedin

Dalo12345

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

What do you consider elite? Yards? Wins? Division titles? Rings?
Stafford is already elite in my book.
Seasons from now...
Bradford has a chance, but I don't care for Fisher as Rams HC.
Luck has a chance, but I doubt he will be what Manning was and Colts will be rebuilding for a while.
RGIII, can't fathom Redskins emerging from that conference anytime soon especially with all those picks they gave up for RGIII.

Cam and Dalton will have the biggest impact this season outside of Stafford.
As a Jags fan, I still consider the Manningless AFCS to be as wide open as it's been in years. I'm expecting a night and day difference in our offense.

6. Matt Flynn: he will be another Matt Hasselbeck kind of player.

5. Josh Freeman: inconsistent at times, but i think he will improve.

4. Andy Dalton: He played well last year, i think he is a very serviceable qb in the NFL, top 10 qb one day

3. Robert Griffin III: Man is a hard worker, i think he will be a star from his 1st start, i really think he could be a top 5 qb in this league in 2-3 years

2. Jake Locker: Sitting his rookie year and maybe next year will benefit him a lot, look for him to be really good in the coming years.

1. Cam Newton: The man is just a beast, he reminds me a lot of vince young his rookie year, just i think he will not have a sophomore slump

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

Toxic-Seahorse

What do you consider elite? Yards? Wins? Division titles? Rings?
Stafford is already elite in my book.
Seasons from now...
Bradford has a chance, but I don't care for Fisher as Rams HC.
Luck has a chance, but I doubt he will be what Manning was and Colts will be rebuilding for a while.
RGIII, can't fathom Redskins emerging from that conference anytime soon especially with all those picks they gave up for RGIII.

Cam and Dalton will have the biggest impact this season outside of Stafford.
As a Jags fan, I still consider the Manningless AFCS to be as wide open as it's been in years. I'm expecting a night and day difference in our offense.

Jackboot343

[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"]

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

sherman-tank1

Stafford still doesn't have me convinced. If the Madden curse strikes this year and Megatron is out for a bit, everyone will see Stafford's true colors. He's nothing special in my eyes, he has the best WR of the past 10 years to throw to right now and a very nice team all around him.

Many other QBs would have identical success on that team.

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

Toxic-Seahorse

[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"]

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

Chutebox

I think I had Freeman in one of my fantasy leagues thanks to the 'experts' :(
He did put up yards and maybe touchdowns at the end of the game though...during garbage time

[QUOTE="sherman-tank1"]

[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"]

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

Toxic-Seahorse

[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"]

Puting Cam Newton over Matthew Stafford is such a joke.

Jackboot343

I think I had Freeman in one of my fantasy leagues thanks to the 'experts' :(
He did put up yards and maybe touchdowns at the end of the game though...during garbage time

Stafford still doesn't have me convinced. If the Madden curse strikes this year and Megatron is out for a bit, everyone will see Stafford's true colors. He's nothing special in my eyes, he has the best WR of the past 10 years to throw to right now and a very nice team all around him.

Many other QBs would have identical success on that team.

DaJuicyMan

Stafford still doesn't have me convinced. If the Madden curse strikes this year and Megatron is out for a bit, everyone will see Stafford's true colors. He's nothing special in my eyes, he has the best WR of the past 10 years to throw to right now and a very nice team all around him.

Many other QBs would have identical success on that team.

DaJuicyMan

[QUOTE="DaJuicyMan"]

Stafford still doesn't have me convinced. If the Madden curse strikes this year and Megatron is out for a bit, everyone will see Stafford's true colors. He's nothing special in my eyes, he has the best WR of the past 10 years to throw to right now and a very nice team all around him.

Many other QBs would have identical success on that team.

Toxic-Seahorse

[QUOTE="Dalo12345"]

brynden weedin