Ok, I just read Johnny U's biography, and it made me really appreciate his talent. So my question is now, who would you rather have have as a Quarterback?
No Joe Montana or Elway?! I want a QB that will win SBs. And that's Montana and Brady.dkhw
There weren't enough slots to put Joe Montana and John Elway. And Johnny Unitas won three championships, in '58, '59, and Super Bowl V. And the '58 Championship game was the game that made Professional Football popular.
Tom Brady hands down the guy can win games and he doesn't need probowl talent around him unlike others but and you can say "hes just a good system QB" well do system QBs lead the league in passing in 2005? and do they consistently put up great numbers each season? I know I might be just saying this because im a Pats fan but thats just who I would take.
Hey don't get me wrong I love those other guys and I respect the hell out of Peyton Manning (and his commercials). I would take Tom Brady but I guess you could say I'm being a little bias here.
Even though he isn't on the list, John Elways. The guy was incredible and im glad I got to see him play some games when I was younger. One of my favorite quarterbacks of all time.
No Joe Montana or Elway?! I want a QB that will win SBs. And that's Montana and Brady.dkhw
Just an "Other" option would be great since Namath was good but is mainly remembered for the fact that he guaranteed the game and won. Personally, I would go with Steve Young because he is a stud! He had one of, if not THE, greatest year any QB has ever had (it was their 94-95 Super Bowl year)! So yeah, take someone off and put "Other" on there and then I'll vote.
No Montana or even Young for that matter? Hmm, I guess I'll go with Marino then. Besides if it wasn't for Montana, he would have had a ring. :wink:Renegade_Fury
Marino sucked in the SB. It didnt matter who QB'ed the 49ers that day.
[QUOTE="M-e-t-h-o-d-206"]where the heck is Montana or Elway. why would you even put Brady in there?!bunchofpixels
Elway? He threw more INTs than TDs for a good portion of his career. He didnt win anything until he got a 2000 yard rusher. Good portion of his career? 4 out of 16 seasons is a good portion of his career?
[QUOTE="bunchofpixels"][QUOTE="M-e-t-h-o-d-206"]where the heck is Montana or Elway. why would you even put Brady in there?!Zero-Pirate
Elway? He threw more INTs than TDs for a good portion of his career. He didnt win anything until he got a 2000 yard rusher. Good portion of his career? 4 out of 16 seasons is a good portion of his career? Probably because more people rather have Marino or Elway than Brady he's getting upset :(
Honestly if I have any of those guys as QB on my team then I'm not really thinking much about my QB, I'm set there. I'm worried that I have no WRs or something ;)
[QUOTE="cametall"] Probably because more people rather have Marino or Elway than Brady he's getting upset :( Yep, Tom Brady equals most overrated quarterback in the NFL. Even a CFL backup could be a "great" quarterback on that team!
[QUOTE="Zero-Pirate"][QUOTE="cametall"] Probably because more people rather have Marino or Elway than Brady he's getting upset :( Yep, Tom Brady equals most overrated quarterback in the NFL. Even a CFL backup could be a "great" quarterback on that team! Brady just got SERVED!!
Ok, I just read Johnny U's biography, and it made me really appreciate his talent. So my question is now, who would you rather have have as a Quarterback? Tking1293
[QUOTE="Zero-Pirate"][QUOTE="cametall"] Probably because more people rather have Marino or Elway than Brady he's getting upset :( Yep, Tom Brady equals most overrated quarterback in the NFL. Even a CFL backup could be a "great" quarterback on that team!
ummm....it's more like a CFL backup could be a "great" quaterback for the colts. That team had for years, one of the best WR tandem in the league and arguably the best reciever in the league with Marvin Harrison. while tom brady had givens and branch who weren't even great until brady molded them into to good recievers. Just look at givens in tennesse. without brady, he's nothing.| I say peyton is more overrated than Brady
ummm....it's more like a CFL backup could be a "great" quaterback for the colts. That team had for years, one of the best WR tandem in the league and arguably the best reciever in the league with Marvin Harrison. while tom brady had givens and branch who weren't even great until brady molded them into to good recievers. Just look at givens in tennesse. without brady, he's nothing.| I say peyton is more overrated than Brady dkhw
But every team in the league has 1 or 2 exceptional recievers. I'm not saying that Manning is not overrated. I think he is, but only a little. I think Brady is much more overrated. As a whole, the Patriots have had a much better team, apart from the quarterback position than the Colts. Brady doesn't suck, but he is not even remotely as good as everyone makes him out to be. Payton, while not the best QB ever, like many people are saying for some odd reason, probably is the best QB in the game today.
Log in to comment