360 component cable vs PS3 HDMI

not really most videophiles still agree that hdmi just doesn't offer super amounts of advantage over component till you get into hdmi 1.3 and audio codecs, I personally use optical audio as my chosen standard its cables are thin, light and it doesn't give me any problems.


WilliamRLBaker

I am really wondering if developers will take advantage of True DD sound.  

[QUOTE="WilliamRLBaker"]not really most videophiles still agree that hdmi just doesn't offer super amounts of advantage over component till you get into hdmi 1.3 and audio codecs, I personally use optical audio as my chosen standard its cables are thin, light and it doesn't give me any problems.


rogue_leader_5

I am really wondering if developers will take advantage of True DD sound.

me too or the DTS HD of which i favor, For me 5.1 dolby diglity just isn't as good as 5.1 DTS I love that sound format yet hardly any movies use it, and hardly any theaters whenever a movie uses it i make sure to watch it.

Sadly I don't know exactly if optical audio supports True DD or DTS HD....If games and movies support both i might have to upgrade my insignia receiver and 6.1speaker setup.

yep did the research DTS HD, and True dolby only work over hdmi 1.3 or hdmi 1.2 if your receiver can decode it from lossless. 

Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?rogue_leader_5

Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?rogue_leader_5

[QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?familyguyvs360

some tv's do allow 1080p thru component, some don't. VGA will definitely run 1080p analog....and I don't know what "true" 1080p is, nor do I know what "false" 1080p would be.

[QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?familyguyvs360

What are you talking about? component supports 1080p!!

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?whoisryanmack

some tv's do allow 1080p thru component, some don't. VGA will definitely run 1080p analog....and I don't know what "true" 1080p is, nor do I know what "false" 1080p would be.

you said it your self VGA = analog...HDMI is an all-digital...true 1080p is digital

[QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?familyguyvs360

 Ok Tv not letting you do 1080p over component is fact, But true 1080P? there is no difference from the 1080p shown over component then that of the hdmi, all forms of 1080p can be shown over component the only differences between the 2 is digital signal vs analog, and cable length.

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?whoisryanmack

some tv's do allow 1080p thru component, some don't. VGA will definitely run 1080p analog....and I don't know what "true" 1080p is, nor do I know what "false" 1080p would be.

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?michael098

What are you talking about? component supports 1080p!!

sound wise yes HDMI is the best sound output. Video wise not really.ttobba07

Bah, i just play my consoles into a surround system vie Optical cable ;)

Much quicker, and nicer too. 

 [QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?WilliamRLBaker

 Ok Tv not letting you do 1080p over component is fact, But true 1080P? there is no difference from the 1080p shown over component then that of the hdmi, all forms of 1080p can be shown over component the only differences between the 2 is digital signal vs analog, and cable length.

[QUOTE="whoisryanmack"]

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?familyguyvs360

some tv's do allow 1080p thru component, some don't. VGA will definitely run 1080p analog....and I don't know what "true" 1080p is, nor do I know what "false" 1080p would be.

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?michael098

What are you talking about? component supports 1080p!!

My PS3 instructions tell me i can get 1080p through component cables. 

[QUOTE="WilliamRLBaker"]

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?familyguyvs360

Ok Tv not letting you do 1080p over component is fact, But true 1080P? there is no difference from the 1080p shown over component then that of the hdmi, all forms of 1080p can be shown over component the only differences between the 2 is digital signal vs analog, and cable length.

To usher in HDCP o.O to get people to upgrade TV's with a new HD player. 

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="whoisryanmack"]

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?toxicmog

some tv's do allow 1080p thru component, some don't. VGA will definitely run 1080p analog....and I don't know what "true" 1080p is, nor do I know what "false" 1080p would be.

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?michael098

What are you talking about? component supports 1080p!!

My PS3 instructions tell me i can get 1080p through component cables. 

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="WilliamRLBaker"]

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"][QUOTE="rogue_leader_5"]Both consoles can do 1080p but does it REALLY make a difference over which medium?toxicmog

Ok Tv not letting you do 1080p over component is fact, But true 1080P? there is no difference from the 1080p shown over component then that of the hdmi, all forms of 1080p can be shown over component the only differences between the 2 is digital signal vs analog, and cable length.

To usher in HDCP o.O to get people to upgrade TV's with a new HD player. 

My PS3 instructions tell me i can get 1080p through component cables. 

toxicmog

[QUOTE="toxicmog"]

My PS3 instructions tell me i can get 1080p through component cables. 

xbox_daddy

LINK!? TV's Don't support 1080p thru component, name one TV that has this feature. Show me some credible proof or get lost, stop trolling. Plus 1080p is supported by component, but Finding a TV that supports 1080p thru component is the real adventure.familyguyvs360

Here you go most of the tvs on that list support component 1080p.

1080p Through component TVs

another

http://www.pricegrabber.com/rating_getprodrev.php/product_id=20384866/id_type=M

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"]LINK!? TV's Don't support 1080p thru component, name one TV that has this feature. Show me some credible proof or get lost, stop trolling. Plus 1080p is supported by component, but Finding a TV that supports 1080p thru component is the real adventure.WilliamRLBaker

Here you go most of the tvs on that list support component 1080p.

1080p Through component TVs 

 another

http://www.pricegrabber.com/rating_getprodrev.php/product_id=20384866/id_type=M

familyguyvs360

 

I edited my above post but ill just paste it here...

P.S: let alone the FACT DIGITAL has been around for a long time, I want you to give me proof that digital hdmi..ect is better the component in every single way....

Digital was created to give you a lossless signal so no conversion had to take place, as well digital allows for a longer cable lenght with higher speed data rates, This is why it was created, At the 1-3 meter length which is long enough for most any one, thats 9 FEET PEOPLE, at the most after that the signal degrades.

This is why Digital signal carrying cables were invented....oh and to allow hollywood to control your content, Component is a very robust cable and input output protocol it can handle most every thing visually hdmi can, the only reason hollywood hates it? cause they cannot use it to block what you watch, record...ect

Thats in reply to your reply to my first post to you.

Now here is my reply to this post....

Edit: good job on editing your post to what you understand, i will remove my sarcastic comment.

do you know that DVI supports HDCP as well? or ICT flags? do you know that ITs only HDMI 1.3 that supports HDCP or ICT?

Do you know that no blu ray movie, or hd dvd movie out right now supports hdcp or ict?

DO you know all most 80% of of movie studios support HDCP and the ICT protocol but will not force people that run said movies over component to downgrade the picture from 1080p to a lower resolution?

Do you know that no matter what happens in the future, all movies released from now till the time HDCP and ICT are implimented will play fine, that the ICT and HDCP tags are built into the disks them selves?

the HDCP protocol means nothing since it will be breached easily just like all the protection schemes in dvd.

 

edit 2: im off to bed. 

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"]WilliamRLBaker

 

I edited my above post but ill just paste it here...

P.S: let alone the FACT DIGITAL has been around for a long time, I want you to give me proof that digital hdmi..ect is better the component in every single way....

Digital was created to give you a lossless signal so no conversion had to take place, as well digital allows for a longer cable lenght with higher speed data rates, This is why it was created, At the 1-3 meter length which is long enough for most any one, thats 9 FEET PEOPLE, at the most after that the signal degrades.

This is why Digital signal carrying cables were invented....oh and to allow hollywood to control your content, Component is a very robust cable and input output protocol it can handle most every thing visually hdmi can, the only reason hollywood hates it? cause they cannot use it to block what you watch, record...ect

Thats in reply to your reply to my first post to you.

Now here is my reply to this post....

Edit: good job on editing your post to what you understand, i will remove my sarcastic comment.

do you know that DVI supports HDCP as well? or ICT flags? do you know that ITs only HDMI 1.3 that supports HDCP or ICT?

Do you know that no blu ray movie, or hd dvd movie out right now supports hdcp or ict?

DO you know all most 80% of of movie studios support HDCP and the ICT protocol but will not force people that run said movies over component to downgrade the picture from 1080p to a lower resolution?

Do you know that no matter what happens in the future, all movies released from now till the time HDCP and ICT are implimented will play fine, that the ICT and HDCP tags are built into the disks them selves?

the HDCP protocol means nothing since it will be breached easily just like all the protection schemes in dvd.

[QUOTE="WilliamRLBaker"]

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"]familyguyvs360

 

I edited my above post but ill just paste it here...

P.S: let alone the FACT DIGITAL has been around for a long time, I want you to give me proof that digital hdmi..ect is better the component in every single way....

Digital was created to give you a lossless signal so no conversion had to take place, as well digital allows for a longer cable lenght with higher speed data rates, This is why it was created, At the 1-3 meter length which is long enough for most any one, thats 9 FEET PEOPLE, at the most after that the signal degrades.

This is why Digital signal carrying cables were invented....oh and to allow hollywood to control your content, Component is a very robust cable and input output protocol it can handle most every thing visually hdmi can, the only reason hollywood hates it? cause they cannot use it to block what you watch, record...ect

Thats in reply to your reply to my first post to you.

Now here is my reply to this post....

Edit: good job on editing your post to what you understand, i will remove my sarcastic comment.

do you know that DVI supports HDCP as well? or ICT flags? do you know that ITs only HDMI 1.3 that supports HDCP or ICT?

Do you know that no blu ray movie, or hd dvd movie out right now supports hdcp or ict?

DO you know all most 80% of of movie studios support HDCP and the ICT protocol but will not force people that run said movies over component to downgrade the picture from 1080p to a lower resolution?

Do you know that no matter what happens in the future, all movies released from now till the time HDCP and ICT are implimented will play fine, that the ICT and HDCP tags are built into the disks them selves?

the HDCP protocol means nothing since it will be breached easily just like all the protection schemes in dvd.

He just explained it to you, or can you not read?

He just explained it to you, or can you not read?

coolviper2003

[QUOTE="coolviper2003"]

He just explained it to you, or can you not read?

xbox_daddy

LINK!? TV's Don't support 1080p thru component, name one TV that has this feature. Show me some credible proof or get lost, stop trolling. Plus 1080p is supported by component, but Finding a TV that supports 1080p thru component is the real adventure.familyguyvs360

sound wise yes HDMI is the best sound output. Video wise not really.ttobba07

[QUOTE="ttobba07"]sound wise yes HDMI is the best sound output. Video wise not really.imprezawrx500

In terms of gaming I don't think we will ever get the full experience that HDMI has to offer.  Maybe next gen.

component? VGA is much better than component-supercharged-

[QUOTE="familyguyvs360"]LINK!? TV's Don't support 1080p thru component, name one TV that has this feature. Show me some credible proof or get lost, stop trolling. Plus 1080p is supported by component, but Finding a TV that supports 1080p thru component is the real adventure.WilliamRLBaker

Here you go most of the tvs on that list support component 1080p.

1080p Through component TVs

another

http://www.pricegrabber.com/rating_getprodrev.php/product_id=20384866/id_type=M

Ownage approved!! :D

Great job.

Cows need to stop listening to Sony and do some research for themselves.