360 fall >PS3 Fall * UPDATED*

Well every game so far has come out and been rated and lets match them up and see why the xbox 360 beats the PS3 this fall.

Ps3-

LBP= 9.0 and still not able to play with friends online

R2-9.0 FPS which is really good

Motorstorm 2- 8.0 which is good but Pure beats it in its own genre

Socom- Flopped badly with a 6.5 and with nearly unplayable online ( with no singleplayer mind you)

Xbox 360

Gears 2- 9.0 shooter same as R2

Fable 2- Action RPG which scored a 8.5 and is a full blown adventure game

L4D- Online co op game which scored a 8.5 which is still impressive for a FPS these days.

*Banjo*- Not scored yet but has 77% on Gamerankings.com

**Extra's **

Xbox 360 has the better version of Fallout 3, one of the best games this whole year by .5 since it can run it better and makes the xbox version AAA.

Ign gave Mirrors edge Ps3 version a better score by .1

Basicly it comes down to which do you like more R2+LBP or Gears 2+L4D+Fable 2 and if you like Fallout 3 and dont have a good PC.

EDIT- People read for once in your life its XBOX 360 FALL vs. PS3 FALL 2008 nohting to do with PC, nothing to do with full year 2008.

Well every game so far has come out and been rated and lets match them up and see why the xbox 360 beats the PS3 this fall.

Ps3-

LBP= 9.0 and still not able to play with friends online

R2-9.0 FPS which is really good

Motorstorm 2- 8.0 which is good but Pure beats it in its own genre

Socom- Flopped badly with a 6.5 and with nearly unplayable online ( with no singleplayer mind you)

Xbox 360

Gears 2- 9.0 shooter same as R2

Fable 2- Action RPG which scored a 8.5 and is a full blown adventure game

L4D- Online co op game which scored a 8.5 which is still impressive for a FPS these days.

*Banjo*- Not scored yet but has 77% on Gamerankings.com

**Extra's **

Xbox 360 has the better version of Fallout 3, one of the best games this whole year by .5 since it can run it better and makes the xbox version AAA.

Ign gave Mirrors edge Ps3 version a better score by .1

Basicly it comes down to which do you like more R2+LBP or Gears 2+L4D+Fable 2 and if you like Fallout 3 and dont have a good PC.

lkjsdfjlk

Please correct me if I am wrong but in your list, doesn't the PS3 have 2 AAAE to the 360's 1 AAAE?

Valkyria Chronicles is yet to be rated, 86% on GR.

Valkyria Chronicles is yet to be rated, 86% on GR.

 

DarkCloud79

Well every game so far has come out and been rated and lets match them up and see why the xbox 360 beats the PS3 this fall.

 

Ps3-

LBP= 9.0 and still not able to play with friends online

R2-9.0 FPS which is really good

Motorstorm 2- 8.0 which is good but Pure beats it in its own genre

Socom- Flopped badly with a 6.5 and with nearly unplayable online ( with no singleplayer mind you)

 

Xbox 360

Gears 2- 9.0 shooter same as R2

Fable 2- Action RPG which scored a 8.5 and is a full blown adventure game

L4D- Online co op game which scored a 8.5 which is still impressive for a FPS these days.

*Banjo*- Not scored yet but has 77% on Gamerankings.com

 

**Extra's **

Xbox 360 has the better version of Fallout 3, one of the best games this whole year by .5 since it can run it better and makes the xbox version AAA.

 

Ign gave Mirrors edge Ps3 version a better score by .1

 

Basicly it comes down to which do you like more R2+LBP or Gears 2+L4D+Fable 2 and if you like Fallout 3 and dont have a good PC.

 

 

lkjsdfjlk

L4D is not exclusive, you're desperate to skew the results. And once valkyria chronicles is reviewed, it'll be clear even to the likes of you who has the best line up.

Socom is now very very playable. 1up reviewed and gave it a b+(8.5)

its funny how u left mgs4 out of there isnt it.10 of 10 isnt?claywalker21

No, that's not the funny part, let me explain it.

The thread topic says 360 FALL>PS3 FALL so that's why there's no MGS because it came out in summer, the thing however is that xbox 360 fanboys have to break the year up in several parts to "own" the ps3 = hillarius.

I mean, in summer was is then PS3>xbox 360 because of MGS?

btw - L4D is also on the pc so you can scratch that one out aswell.

Basicly it comes down to which do you like more...

lkjsdfjlk

Both have great Fall lineups if you ask me. I don't see one being > than the other.

So basically (exclusives)

360

• 9.0 - Gears 2
• 8.5 - Fable 2

ps3

• 9.0 - LBP
• 9.0 - R2
• 8.0 - M PF (as good as Pure)

Banjo and Valkyria Chronicles reviews incoming.

its funny how u left mgs4 out of there isnt it.10 of 10 isnt?claywalker21

Gears 2 - not interested

Resistance 2 - little interest

LPB - not interested

Fable 2 - I do not like RPG

Vary interested in COD: WaW which I will buy very soon

So 360 fall = PS3 fall in my opinion

Socom is now very very playable. 1up reviewed and gave it a b+(8.5)

fatzebra

Which on 1up is less than wii music...

[QUOTE="claywalker21"]its funny how u left mgs4 out of there isnt it.10 of 10 isnt?TTDog

Or maybe he was referring to the fall line up :P

I can play with my friends on LBP fine O_o;

Why are you listing Multiplats? Are you one of those silly "Console Exclusive" people? If so, GDIAFjonnyt61

Hes comparing 360 to ps3, you cant play L4D on ur ps3...

[QUOTE="jonnyt61"]I can play with my friends on LBP fine O_o;

Why are you listing Multiplats? Are you one of those silly "Console Exclusive" people? If so, GDIAFbirdman2111

Hes comparing 360 to ps3, you cant play L4D on ur ps3...

A valid point, but people don't like to acknowledge those here.

[QUOTE="jonnyt61"]I can play with my friends on LBP fine O_o;

Why are you listing Multiplats? Are you one of those silly "Console Exclusive" people? If so, GDIAFbirdman2111

Hes comparing 360 to ps3, you cant play L4D on ur ps3...

A valid point, but people don't like to acknowledge those here.

Motorstorm 2 is definetly better than Pure

Fable 2 is the most glitchy game I've played in years...

Gears 2 is sick though.......matchmaking still sux

Motorstorm 2 is definetly better than Pure

Fable 2 is the most glitchy game I've played in years...

Gears 2 is sick though.......matchmaking still sux

IcemanLBC

Fable was glitchy, but still a great game. I liked the whole property thing :P

[QUOTE="fatzebra"]

Socom is now very very playable. 1up reviewed and gave it a b+(8.5)

birdman2111

Which on 1up is less than wii music...

I know they cant bhut I would really like to see a re review of SOCOM here on gamespot, maybe just a mimi one or something. Now that the servers are fixed this game has to be an 8 or something.

To say its still only worth a 6 or something is silly.

[QUOTE="birdman2111"][QUOTE="fatzebra"]

Socom is now very very playable. 1up reviewed and gave it a b+(8.5)

NinjaMunkey01

Which on 1up is less than wii music...

I know they cant bhut I would really like to see a re review of SOCOM here on gamespot, maybe just a mimi one or something. Now that the servers are fixed this game has to be an 8 or something.

To say its still only worth a 6 or something is silly.

Hmm, ive never played a socom game before so im really talking about stuff i know nothing about :P but if l4d got an 8.5, with marks deducted for poor singleplayer, i dont like socoms chances...

Can you guys read?

PS3 VS XBOX 360 FALL LINEUP I NEVER MENTIONED ANYTHING ABOUT FULL YEAR AT ALL

Wow I am comparing the fall 2008 lineup of both consoles and I ONLY MENTIONED multiplats when one console had an advantage over the other

L4D is coming out for 360 NOT ps3 with more support by valve which they even said so

As you can see I didnt mention any japanese games since I know of none but wasnt there like 3 of them for xbox and 1 for ps3 but eitherway I didnt mention them.

personally i find both line-ups to be great... if i had to choose, well i wont :) i'll just pick the best games on each console..

i think the title should be 360 & PS3 Fall = Great gaming time for gamers...

[QUOTE="NinjaMunkey01"][QUOTE="birdman2111"]

Which on 1up is less than wii music...

birdman2111

I know they cant bhut I would really like to see a re review of SOCOM here on gamespot, maybe just a mimi one or something. Now that the servers are fixed this game has to be an 8 or something.

To say its still only worth a 6 or something is silly.

Hmm, ive never played a socom game before so im really talking about stuff i know nothing about :P but if l4d got an 8.5, with marks deducted for poor singleplayer, i dont like socoms chances...

I think SOCOM deserves an 8 or something.

If its just slightly better than the online on the psp, its instantly awsome enough to warrant a purchase.

[QUOTE="birdman2111"][QUOTE="NinjaMunkey01"]

I know they cant bhut I would really like to see a re review of SOCOM here on gamespot, maybe just a mimi one or something. Now that the servers are fixed this game has to be an 8 or something.

To say its still only worth a 6 or something is silly.

NinjaMunkey01

Hmm, ive never played a socom game before so im really talking about stuff i know nothing about :P but if l4d got an 8.5, with marks deducted for poor singleplayer, i dont like socoms chances...

I think SOCOM deserves an 8 or something.

If its just slightly better than the online on the psp, its instantly awsome enough to warrant a purchase.

dont let the average/bad scores fool you, SOCOM is a great game and there are always so many gamers online... servers are now running smoothly and its really fun...

So basically (exclusives)

360

• 9.0 - Gears 2
• 8.5 - Fable 2

ps3

• 9.0 - LBP
• 9.0 - R2
• 8.0 - M PF (as good as Pure)

Banjo and Valkyria Chronicles reviews incoming.

Nike_Air

You'd think stacking it like that it'd be clear who wins. Hollow victory but victory none the less. :P

Only two of those games on those lists interest me, and I already own one.

Maybe it's just me, but there aren't really any games I'm looking forward to right now.

Why should he scratch L4D off the list? This thread has nothing to do with exclusives. It's something the 360 has, that the PS3 doesn't.

Well every game so far has come out and been rated and lets match them up and see why the xbox 360 beats the PS3 this fall.

Ps3-

LBP= 9.0 and still not able to play with friends online

R2-9.0 FPS which is really good

Motorstorm 2- 8.0 which is good but Pure beats it in its own genre

Socom- Flopped badly with a 6.5 and with nearly unplayable online ( with no singleplayer mind you)

Xbox 360

Gears 2- 9.0 shooter same as R2

Fable 2- Action RPG which scored a 8.5 and is a full blown adventure game

L4D- Online co op game which scored a 8.5 which is still impressive for a FPS these days.

*Banjo*- Not scored yet but has 77% on Gamerankings.com

**Extra's **

Xbox 360 has the better version of Fallout 3, one of the best games this whole year by .5 since it can run it better and makes the xbox version AAA.

Ign gave Mirrors edge Ps3 version a better score by .1

Basicly it comes down to which do you like more R2+LBP or Gears 2+L4D+Fable 2 and if you like Fallout 3 and dont have a good PC.

EDIT- People read for once in your life its XBOX 360 FALL vs. PS3 FALL 2008 nohting to do with PC, nothing to do with full year 2008.

lkjsdfjlk

What people foget that MGS4 came this year and is a exclusive.

Why should he scratch L4D off the list? This thread has nothing to do with exclusives. It's something the 360 has, that the PS3 doesn't.

Mau-Justice

[QUOTE="Mau-Justice"]

Why should he scratch L4D off the list? This thread has nothing to do with exclusives. It's something the 360 has, that the PS3 doesn't.

Truth-slayer

going off that logic all sony + nintendo games will eventually go to 360 you knwo tis just a matter of time

Fallout 3 reveiw is a big deal because the 360 version is AAA and ps3 verison is not

Why should he scratch L4D off the list? This thread has nothing to do with exclusives. It's something the 360 has, that the PS3 doesn't.

Mau-Justice

...because this is system wars and there are rules in place.

On top of that, he fails to mention Valkyria Chronicles which is a critical hit everywhere but Gamespot is pretty much the only site not to review it.

[QUOTE="Truth-slayer"][QUOTE="Mau-Justice"]

Why should he scratch L4D off the list? This thread has nothing to do with exclusives. It's something the 360 has, that the PS3 doesn't.

lkjsdfjlk

going off that logic all sony + nintendo games will eventually go to 360 you knwo tis just a matter of time

Fallout 3 reveiw is a big deal because the 360 version is AAA and ps3 verison is not

You have the GALL to bring up that when Fable FLOPPED on system wars with a AA when it was hyped AAA?

Either you use the hype and A ratings or you don't.  Period.  You can't pick and choose just so your side looks better.

I don't know how much longer I can take the utter hypocrisy of these forums.

what a way to break up the year just to make the 360 shine a bit more eh? Even if you do it that way, the 360 may have won HOLIDAY of 08, but it barely scraped by. As for as the entire year, the 360 got smashed 

/FACT

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

So basically (exclusives)

360

• 9.0 - Gears 2
• 8.5 - Fable 2

ps3

• 9.0 - LBP
• 9.0 - R2
• 8.0 - M PF (as good as Pure)

Banjo and Valkyria Chronicles reviews incoming.

Lionheart08

You'd think stacking it like that it'd be clear who wins. Hollow victory but victory none the less. :P

Those are just GS scores. Gears and fable are both 3-4% higher, thus making them both AAA (more or less.) as well as LBP. R2 is not an AAA game according to GR. I think that list needs to be rewritten.

what a way to break up the year just to make the 360 shine a bit more eh? Even if you do it that way, the 360 may have won HOLIDAY of 08, but it barely scraped by. As for as the entire year, the 360 got smashed 

/FACT

ermacness

haha wow! this was an epic "fail" right from the get go.... the guy forgot MGS4. :lol:

Anyways, he was smart to add "Fall" because he knows better....

[QUOTE="ermacness"]

what a way to break up the year just to make the 360 shine a bit more eh? Even if you do it that way, the 360 may have won HOLIDAY of 08, but it barely scraped by. As for as the entire year, the 360 got smashed 

/FACT

Steppy_76

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

So basically (exclusives)

360

• 9.0 - Gears 2
• 8.5 - Fable 2

ps3

• 9.0 - LBP
• 9.0 - R2
• 8.0 - M PF (as good as Pure)

Banjo and Valkyria Chronicles reviews incoming.

Belwar555

You'd think stacking it like that it'd be clear who wins. Hollow victory but victory none the less. :P

Those are just GS scores. Gears and fable are both 3-4% higher, thus making them both AAA (more or less.) as well as LBP. R2 is not an AAA game according to GR. I think that list needs to be rewritten.