360 vs PS3 - Detailed game comparison

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

Nice work, but no one is going to accept this because you used IGN scores and you included multiplats.

The first game on the 360 list is a multiplat.

A decidedly awesome multiplat that has been confirmed as going to the PS3 later.

But, kudos for the work you put into everything.

i don't even care about the quality of the games. as long as my cell processor is happy running them then i am happy too.

dude, you could have used your time better than this, i'm sorry but no one cares honestly, i just game to have fun and people who get so caught up in the statistics need a new hobby

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

NaveedLife

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

Nice work, but no one is going to accept this because you used IGN scores and you included multiplats.

cloudff7tm

EDIT: sometimes. ok...well rarely at least.

u used ign scores? LOL at 9.3 for splinter cell conviction, i liked that game but will never respect ign again for that review, that game didnt score a 9 for any of the 5 categories but somehow got a 9.3 for overall score? LOL

PS3 excluisves are better.FantasyTwisted

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

slvrraven9

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

[QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.slvrraven9

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

gamebreakerz__

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

you see this is exactly what im talking about... lets try to understand here. STRICTLY speaking...not generaly speaking because then i would have to include the PC since it would then include a broader audience, but in this case for people who only own the 360 or ps3 this comparison is made up. yes they are truely multiplat games avalaible on the pc also but for this comparison, thats not an issue.

nevermind....i just realized im using logic and reason on system wars. what was i thinking....

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]mass effect 2 is better than uncharted 2. comvince me otherwise......gamebreakerz__

That's how it works. So that means MGS4 and GTA 4 are better than most games this gen. Ewwwwwwww

[QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.slvrraven9

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"][QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.gamebreakerz__

Why didnt you just use GS's spreadsheet?ferret-gamer

where do you find these?

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"][QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.Chris_Williams

Why didnt you just use GS's spreadsheet?ferret-gamer

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

slvrraven9

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

True he is comparing the two, but its not really fair to rule out another system that is just as much on the market as any other. Oh just ignore the PC, it will make my argument better (in 360's favor). You cannot just throw out facts when you feel appropriate :P. And yes if it is on PC and another system it is NOT exclusive. People act like PC is less of a system for some odd reason.

Where is PGR4?

The first game on the 360 list is a multiplat.

A decidedly awesome multiplat that has been confirmed as going to the PS3 later.

But, kudos for the work you put into everything.

Kickinurass

[QUOTE="ferret-gamer"]Why didnt you just use GS's spreadsheet?redbird19

it's in the stickied system wars information thread here.

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

NaveedLife

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

True he is comparing the two, but its not really fair to rule out another system that is just as much on the market as any other. Oh just ignore the PC, it will make my argument better (in 360's favor). You cannot just throw out facts when you feel appropriate :P. And yes if it is on PC and another system it is NOT exclusive. People act like PC is less of a system for some odd reason.

Where is PGR4?

Nintendo_Man

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"][QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.Chris_Williams

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

redbird19

True he is comparing the two, but its not really fair to rule out another system that is just as much on the market as any other. Oh just ignore the PC, it will make my argument better (in 360's favor). You cannot just throw out facts when you feel appropriate :P. And yes if it is on PC and another system it is NOT exclusive. People act like PC is less of a system for some odd reason.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

redbird19

True he is comparing the two, but its not really fair to rule out another system that is just as much on the market as any other. Oh just ignore the PC, it will make my argument better (in 360's favor). You cannot just throw out facts when you feel appropriate :P. And yes if it is on PC and another system it is NOT exclusive. People act like PC is less of a system for some odd reason.

this is system wars...not console wars.

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"]

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

9.5 Halo: Reach
9.5 Halo 3
9.5 Gears of War 2
9.4 Forza Motorsport 3
9.0 Dead or Alive 4
9.0 Alan Wake
9.0 Halo 3: ODST
8.9 Forza Motorsport 2
8.8 Fable II
8.8 Project Gotham Racing 3
8.7 Dance Dance Revolution Universe
8.5 Viva Pinata
8.5 Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
8.4 Perfect Dark Zero
8.4 Kameo: Elements of Power
8.4 MotoGP '06
8.4 Naruto: Rise of a Ninja*
8.4 Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
8.4 Halo Wars
8.3 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
8.3 Tony Hawk's American Wasteland**
8.3 Dead Rising
8.3 Far Cry Instincts Predator*
8.3 Naruto: The Broken Bond*
8.2 Lost Odyssey
8.2 The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
8.2 Tales of Vesperia
8.1 Project Gotham Racing 4
8.0 Crackdown
8.0 Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper

I am sure I missed some here, but when you get down to it, the 360's "exclusives" are actually a list like this. So many of their exclusives are on PC with more content, better graphics, better controls, and more. Also many are as you noted, timed exclusives. The 360's exclusive list is just not that good with these things in mind.

NaveedLife

ah but of course, the good old: "its on the PC also so its not actually an exclusive." comparing system to system like he has yes they are exclusive as they are not available on the ps3. lets just try and step out of our confort zones for just a second here and have a conversation without the cow or lem actually speaking for you all..

True he is comparing the two, but its not really fair to rule out another system that is just as much on the market as any other. Oh just ignore the PC, it will make my argument better (in 360's favor). You cannot just throw out facts when you feel appropriate :P. And yes if it is on PC and another system it is NOT exclusive. People act like PC is less of a system for some odd reason.

yeah i know what you mean and like i said before, i agree, they are definatly not exclusives. but when comparing one system to another for people who only look at the ps3 and 360 its a matter of which game can be found where. and thats what the point of the list that the tc created is for im assuming.

I can't believe LBP scored so high, the platforming is subpar at best. I have the game on my shelves collecting dust, I never understood the appeal of that game.

[QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.slvrraven9

[QUOTE="redbird19"] Hi, I wasn't ignoring the PC to favor the 360, it's just that the PC is a whole different animal, and I don't really see it as being in competition with the PS3 or 360. A gaming PC with all the bells and whistles is tough to beat but can also be very expensive, and (at least when I was into PC gaming years back) required regular upgrading of hardware to stay on the cutting edge, which only made things more expensive. If you can afford that, great, but I just don't think it's fair to discuss it alongside the 360 or PS3, which can be had for around $300 or less, and whose hardware will not change over the next 8-10 years.DragonfireXZ95

[QUOTE="FantasyTwisted"]PS3 excluisves are better.slvrraven9

360 clearly wins. Well, Sony fanboys hate facts and numbers since they never help their cause. They prefer something more vague like "PS3 has better exclusives" or "360 only has shooters" :P

..and a mute point but Oblivion and Bioshock are supposedly better ports on ps3. Atleast according to various sites. But the games although great are a bit old to really care about :)Antantics