analysis of grand turismo 5 trailer... not so impressed

the link came from a user from www.vgchartz.com/

in this article they state that grand turismo 5 got a long way to catch up to the quality of forza motorsport 3.

http://bullswarhoy.0fees.net/gt5vsforza3.htm

All that proves is that it is not CGI :lol:

All that proves is that it is not CGI :lol:

thelastguy

this

lol at the shopped GT5 pics

also the guy is a complete Forza fanboy so take this as a grain of saltstereointegrity

[QUOTE="stereointegrity"]also the guy is a complete Forza fanboy so take this as a grain of saltDead-Memories

anyone who takes this for real is a complete moron.

that's a bs site, it only has two articles, both about forza 3. gt5 pics were too blurry, and how did the writer know that a part of the gt trailer was cgi?

[QUOTE="Dead-Memories"][QUOTE="stereointegrity"]also the guy is a complete Forza fanboy so take this as a grain of saltstereointegrity

Well, he's right. If Prologue was any indication of Gran Turismo 5, and I'm guessing it was an early version, as it has Gran Turismo 5 in its title, then they've got a long, looong way to go. Prologue played and felt so damn outdated. The physics were incredibly wonky.

on a sidenote: didn't mythbusters prove that it is possible for something to be perfectly lit even if they are in a shadow. (The episode where some people claimed a lunar landing picture was fake because the astronaut in the shadow of the lunar lander was well lit)

well see when the game comes out i guess.

this is gonna be fun.

Fugazi 3 has less cars on the track the Mario Kart SNES version. GT fans aren't worried about this lower resolution two DVD totin' knockoff. Lemmings want to pretend people are worried about this game, what a laugh.

You know what I find so funny about this? The trailer looks so good, people assumed it to be CGI lol.Episode_Eve

The trailer did look good..It's more the lack of gameplay and history of Sony/Poly is what stirred the CGI bit

[QUOTE="Episode_Eve"]You know what I find so funny about this? The trailer looks so good, people assumed it to be CGI lol.masiisam

The trailer did look good..It's more the lack of gameplay and history of Sony/Poly is what stirred the CGI bit

Fugazi 3 has less cars on the track the Mario Kart SNES version. GT fans aren't worried about this lower resolution two DVD totin' knockoff. Lemmings want to pretend people are worried about this game, what a laugh.

MegajerkNYC

anyone who takes this for real is a complete moron.

Rza_rectah

that's a bs site, it only has two articles, both about forza 3. gt5 pics were too blurry, and how did the writer know that a part of the gt trailer was cgi?

swimdeadfish

[QUOTE="stereointegrity"][QUOTE="Dead-Memories"] He doesn't support the game you support. So that makes him bias :?Dead-Memories

[QUOTE="MegajerkNYC"]

Fugazi 3 has less cars on the track the Mario Kart SNES version. GT fans aren't worried about this lower resolution two DVD totin' knockoff. Lemmings want to pretend people are worried about this game, what a laugh.

TR800

Fugazi 3 has less cars on the track the Mario Kart SNES version. GT fans aren't worried about this lower resolution two DVD totin' knockoff. Lemmings want to pretend people are worried about this game, what a laugh.

MegajerkNYC

Im sure ppl dont care about what you think about it. Fugazi2 is still the best racing game this gen and its sequel is right on the corner :D

[QUOTE="masiisam"]

[QUOTE="Episode_Eve"]You know what I find so funny about this? The trailer looks so good, people assumed it to be CGI lol.Episode_Eve

The trailer did look good..It's more the lack of gameplay and history of Sony/Poly is what stirred the CGI bit

That's true...it will look good...but again the trailer was not in-game...The replay mode in all GT's have always look great.....Actual in game gameplay may or may not be like that...

But I agree I look forward to hearing more on what we should expect in features, tracks/cars and a release date

i just went over the trailer on gametrailers and u can see the shadow problems ( not that big of a deal though). and u can tell that there is cgi part and realtime part. u can tell in the beginning rally part, the car does not accumulate dust and the tires look like its sliding on the ground, then when the blu wrx comes up, it now accumulates dust and the tires are more detailed and the tires are actually on the ground. the weird shadow detailed it not that big a deal though. still looks good.

well he only had one forza 3 pic to compare with.

lol at the shopped GT5 pics

Trinners

the link came from a user from www.vgchartz.com/

in this article they state that grand turismo 5 got a long way to catch up to the quality of forza motorsport 3.

http://bullswarhoy.0fees.net/gt5vsforza3.htm

veryhappyyes

:lol:, No Forza 3 needs alot of catching up to do...

anyone who takes this for real is a complete moron.

[QUOTE="Trinners"]

lol at the shopped GT5 pics

TheGreatOutdoor

look att he trailer on gt. it looks exactly the same like those pictures. it still looks great though, he didnt shop those pics.

The guy is obviously a fanboy, but at least he put some effort into his argument. Certainly more than most of the fanboy drivel that comes out the GT and Forza fanboy mouths. I'd say he proved some points, and if anyone wants to prove otherwise, you'll need a better argument than because you say so.

[QUOTE="Trinners"]

lol at the shopped GT5 pics

TheGreatOutdoor

The most hilarious part about all of this is, that "trailer" isn't really ingame, it's a concept video made by Polyphony for E3. The game may look even better or it might just look exactly like Prologue. Thing is nobody knows and this analysis is a big waste of time.

Propaganda at it's finest. LMAO

1. GT5P not true 1080p. Is Forza 3 true 1080p?

2. Complaining about dirt particles. Does Forza 3 even have dirt tracks?

3. The link at the bottom containing F3 pics is noted as having upscaled pics LMAO.

Whatever, Forza is a great series and no one has seen anything reguarding GT5 so this debate is pointless.

I really can't wait for both of these games to come out so it can be done and over with. They both look good lets just move on and not speak until GT comes out.

F3 has no rally?

I wasn't impressed with Forza 3's trailer, it's trying to become a flashy arcade racer.

GT5 is the real racing simulator.. ;)

GT5 > Forza 3

:)

I wasn't impressed with Forza 3's trailer, it's trying to become a flashy arcade racer.

jakehouston88

:|

You are trying waay too hard.Forza has always been more of a racing sim that GT. I say this and I love both games.

I wasn't impressed with Forza 3's trailer, it's trying to become a flashy arcade racer.

GT5 is the real racing simulator.. ;)

GT5 > Forza 3

:)

jakehouston88

Where he points out the shadows, I don't think he realises that SUNLIGHT causes shadows, in the one where it shows NASCAR and he says "There is about 4 cars at the back missing shadows", they haven't even turned the corner fully yet, if you watch the trailer at that exact spot, and watch those 4 back cars, they have shadows just about 2-4 seconds after that shot was taken, its all about what direction those cars were facing.

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

I wasn't impressed with Forza 3's trailer, it's trying to become a flashy arcade racer.

heretrix

:|

You are trying waay too hard.Forza has always been more of a racing sim that GT. I say this and I love both games.

True that. goes GT5P tell you how hot your tires are in game?

It doesn't