And the best graphics award of E3 2011 goes to Uncharted 3!

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-graphics-best-of-e3/716371

Gametrailers E3 2011 best graphics award goes to Uncharted 3 out of stiff competitions such as BF3, Bioshock Infinit, Far Cry 3 and Metro First light. And guess which game didn't even get nominated, yeah you guessed it...Gears 3. Discuss away.

Anything other than BF3 winning is just wrong. Gamespot got it right.

We all know Battlefield won that award.

Uncharted 3 has the best graphics on consoles. Yeah BF3 looks good on PC with high settings, but most people will not be playing it that way. drakekratos

Most peoples will not play Uncharted too.

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-graphics-best-of-e3/716371

Gametrailers E3 2011 best graphics award goes to Uncharted 3 out of stiff competitions such as BF3, Bioshock Infinit, Far Cry 3 and Metro First light. And guess which game didn't even get nominated, yeah you guessed it...Gears 3. Discuss away.

gpuking

Anything other than BF3 winning is just wrong. Gamespot got it right.

cloudff7tm

http://e3.gamespot.com/special-feature/best-of-e3-2011/special-achievement/index.html?page=2

and not gears 3?me2002

[QUOTE="gpuking"]

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-graphics-best-of-e3/716371

Gametrailers E3 2011 best graphics award goes to Uncharted 3 out of stiff competitions such as BF3, Bioshock Infinit, Far Cry 3 and Metro First light. And guess which game didn't even get nominated, yeah you guessed it...Gears 3. Discuss away.

soulitane

BF3 should have won .... but apparantly they are chose it console wise ... I mean, any PC game can take it easily.

[QUOTE="me2002"]and not gears 3?lucky_star

BF3 destroys "Uncharted ice skating rink simulator 3".

DESTROYS! HEAD SHOT!

[QUOTE="cloudff7tm"]

Anything other than BF3 winning is just wrong. Gamespot got it right.

gpuking

[QUOTE="lucky_star"][QUOTE="me2002"]and not gears 3?soulitane

You really think they used that technology for a 360 game?

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="lucky_star"] Outdated engine with some lighting upgrades. What did you expect? :lol:edidili

You really think they used that technology for a 360 game?

No, that's why we need new consoles yesterday.

Nope, it went to Battlefield 3.

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="lucky_star"] Outdated engine with some lighting upgrades. What did you expect? :lol:edidili

You really think they used that technology for a 360 game?

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="lucky_star"] Outdated engine with some lighting upgrades. What did you expect? :lol:edidili

You really think they used that technology for a 360 game?

[QUOTE="cloudff7tm"]

Anything other than BF3 winning is just wrong. Gamespot got it right.

gpuking

http://e3.gamespot.com/special-feature/best-of-e3-2011/special-achievement/index.html?page=2

GS doesn't give a runner up. Those are the user votes. Gears 3 is close, but UC3 has the edge imo. Bioshock Infinite on PC will probably look better than UC3, and as another user said Farcry 3. Actually there are a bunch of games that are close imo.

If you tried to play BF3 on a console in it's full glory........

NM...you can't.

Uncharted ICE Rink Simulator 3 vs BF3

Who are these people?

Presumably, it was NOT a tech graphics only award!

Hence, their saying "A flawless cocktail of ART, physics, and tech..." in explaining why Uncharted won. I still wouldn't agree, but its not the "OMG! Failz, we all know its BF3 or ANY PC game" moment you guys are making it out to be.This was simply an award for the game that made the best visual impression to them, and they clearly took relative power of the platforms into account and said as much (not in so many words). It was not an award for the game that had the greatest draw distance or an award for the greatest polygon counts. Its an entirely subjective matter (it would be entirely subjective even if it were an overall tech graphics award, but that's another matter).

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-graphics-best-of-e3/716371

Gametrailers E3 2011 best graphics award goes to Uncharted 3 out of stiff competitions such as BF3, Bioshock Infinit, Far Cry 3 and Metro First light. And guess which game didn't even get nominated, yeah you guessed it...Gears 3. Discuss away.

gpuking

Gametrailers has a long reputation of giving technical awards to games that are consistently smoked by their competion (I mean, Crysis, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. and ArmA III never get the technical awards in that joke site).

Probably they like to troll to increase the visitors at their site, but probably at this moment no one cares about what GT thinks about graphics. People just read in Beyond3D or Digital Foundry when they want a rational and logic text about visuals and so...

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-graphics-best-of-e3/716371

Gametrailers E3 2011 best graphics award goes to Uncharted 3 out of stiff competitions such as BF3, Bioshock Infinit, Far Cry 3 and Metro First light. And guess which game didn't even get nominated, yeah you guessed it...Gears 3. Discuss away.

gpuking

I'd probably vote Rage on PC just because modern shooters bore me to death ...

Another one of these threads? Seriously? One would start to think that the only thing UC3 has are it's graphics. :|Sgt_Crow

One would be wrong ;).

Presumably, it was NOT a tech graphics only award!

Hence, their saying "A flawless cocktail of ART, physics, and tech..." in explaining why Uncharted won. I still wouldn't agree, but its not the "OMG! Failz, we all know its BF3 or ANY PC game" moment you guys are making it out to be.This was simply an award for the game that made the best visual impression to them, and they clearly took relative power of the platforms into account and said as much (not in so many words). It was not an award for the game that had the greatest draw distance or an award for the greatest polygon counts. Its an entirely subjective matter (it would be entirely subjective even if it were an overall tech graphics award, but that's another matter).

Seiki_sands

Well put. The 3D trailer for Uncharted is incredible. Looks like a Pixar in 3D.

[QUOTE="Seiki_sands"]

Presumably, it was NOT a tech graphics only award!

Hence, their saying "A flawless cocktail of ART, physics, and tech..." in explaining why Uncharted won. I still wouldn't agree, but its not the "OMG! Failz, we all know its BF3 or ANY PC game" moment you guys are making it out to be.This was simply an award for the game that made the best visual impression to them, and they clearly took relative power of the platforms into account and said as much (not in so many words). It was not an award for the game that had the greatest draw distance or an award for the greatest polygon counts. Its an entirely subjective matter (it would be entirely subjective even if it were an overall tech graphics award, but that's another matter).

Heirren

Well put. The 3D trailer for Uncharted is incredible. Looks like a Pixar in 3D.

Anything other than BF3 winning is just wrong. Gamespot got it right.

cloudff7tm

Uncharted 3 demo looked beautiful indeed but after the beta, it´s safe to say that Gears 3 will look at least as good. Overall the best looking game was obviously Battlefield 3 on PC.

Uncharted 3 demo looked beautiful indeed but after the beta, it´s safe to say that Gears 3 will look at least as good. Overall the best looking game was obviously Battlefield 3 on PC.

PAL360

Uncharted 3 demo looked beautiful indeed but after the beta, it´s safe to say that Gears 3 will look at least as good. Overall the best looking game was obviously Battlefield 3 on PC.

PAL360

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Uncharted 3 demo looked beautiful indeed but after the beta, it´s safe to say that Gears 3 will look at least as good. Overall the best looking game was obviously Battlefield 3 on PC.

Sollet

Based on the demos, sure, i wasnt impressed with that campaign demonstration aswell. Glad i played the game for a month.

BF3 period no contest.

Consoles, that is one for uncharted. However, Digital Foundry will decide who looks better.

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="lucky_star"] Outdated engine with some lighting upgrades. What did you expect? :lol:edidili

You really think they used that technology for a 360 game?

GT are renowned Uncharted fanboys. Its almost vomit worthy. But they never seemed excited for BF3 during the whole E3 coverage anyway. They don't like PC gaming because somehow they never seem to be able to run anything maxed. Its like they don't have a dedicated PC department to review PC games.

Also the video should have been named "Best Visuals" or something because graphics are the tech powering the visuals you see. Not the artistry or what looks good in one person's opinion. GT are fail

Ignoring BF3.

Gametrailers is a joke probably the most console centric site out there, thoughout discussing BF3 all that douche Geoff Keighly kept saying its sad we haven't seen any console footage completly dismissing the game just because it was PC footage. They have been naming games graphics kings when they are really just console graphics kings, which doesnt matter at all. Take a look at their crysis review, what a joke they were playing it at at low settings no wonder crysis was never given best graphics by them.

Excuse me while I get my cricket bat!