Can you match the screenshot to the system?

I got this idea from a different topic where some people thought some 360 screenshots came from the Wii. I am not comparing graphics capabilities, but can you tell which screenshot came from which system? All pictures are links to the Gamespot galleries. They have not been altered.

Can you tell? PS3, Wii, or 360? There is one pic from each.

Pic A

Pic B

Pic C

Please don't complain about the game I used for screenshots. It just needed it to be the same for all three consoles. Also, I did not choose the most flattering shots from each console. Still, this should be easy shouldn't it?

A - 360

B - PS3

C - Wii

:)

my guesses:

pic A = ps3

pic B = 360

pic C = Wii

Hmm...I'm gonna go A. 360, B. PS3, and C. Wii. Honestly though, it's not really an amazing game graphically and it manages to look pretty close in all those pictures.

my guesses:

pic A = ps3

pic B = 360

pic C = Wii

ogvampire

Ditto, based on what we can see.

I don't get the point, but I'll bite.

A- 360

B- PS3

C- Wii

A. 360

B. ps3

c. wii

I don't think there would be a point to this thread unless TC is trying to trick us, so I'm going to call your bluff and say:

A) Wii

B) 360

C) PS3

1. 360

2. Wii

3. PS3

I have no friggin idea what game it is. But, lemme try:

1. 360

2. PS3

3.Wii

1. 360

2. Wii

3. PS3

Reemer99

You got it. My point? Shouldn't it be a little easier to tell the difference between the powerful HD systems and the crappy Wii graphics?

Not gonna lie, you just chose one of the worst graphical games and tried to use it to support an argument, let's put Mario Galaxy up against Uncharted 2 because a multi-plat 6/10 game like Planet 51 doesn't really prove much... :)

[QUOTE="Reemer99"]

1. 360

2. Wii

3. PS3

mrfokken

You got it. My point? Shouldn't it be a little easier to tell the difference between the powerful HD systems and the crappy Wii graphics?

Not when the developers don't try. *sigh* I was afraid that would be your point.

Pointless thread, since the game is not demanding of any of the consoles.

I personally wouldve used a multiplat that was actually considered good, like Modern Warfare oe something.

Not gonna lie, you just chose one of the worst graphical games and tried to use it to support an argument, let's put Mario Galaxy up against Uncharted 2 because a multi-plat 6/10 game like Planet 51 doesn't really prove much... :)

sensfanVone

But you have to use a multi-plat game to compare. I would never argue that the Wii has the graphics power of the other systems. By the way, the Gamespot 360 Planet 51 score was 7/10. Also, IGN scored the 360 graphics 7/10 but the Wii graphics 5/10. I'm not saying this game is a stellar example for any system.

Pointless thread, since the game is not demanding of any of the consoles.

jimkabrhel

Meh. It's still fun to guess.

...and it does make a point about how lazy developers can be. It's pretty obvious that game doesn't push anything.

I'll put it to you this way: Banjo-Kazooie Nuts and Bolts for 360 and Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack In Time. Both beautifully realized cartoony art styles on their respective consoles.

Neither is possible on the Wii. And no, not just in the licensing issues kind of way.

Not gonna lie, you just chose one of the worst graphical games and tried to use it to support an argument, let's put Mario Galaxy up against Uncharted 2 because a multi-plat 6/10 game like Planet 51 doesn't really prove much... :)

sensfanVone

What would they be battling about? Which systems they're on. Well that'd be easy since one is Mario and obviously would be on Wii. If we were going to argue which looks better, I'd vote galaxy.

Pic A

pic A = ps3

pic B = 360

pic C = Wii

I think ps3 usually has more washed out graphics on multiplats.

^ Hooray I'd say Wii and Xbox 360 ?Ravensmash

Which is which?

Yeah TC, they are so hard to tell apart... which one could be the Wii version.... geez, its just so hard to tell.

Pic A

Pic BMatch away...NVIDIATI

Really, a native platform against its port? You shouldn't have to try that hard. Remember, I'm not arguing what the systems are capable of.

Let's do it again.

Pic A

Pic B

Pic C

^Wii
PS3
360

[QUOTE="Reemer99"]

1. 360

2. Wii

3. PS3

mrfokken

You got it. My point? Shouldn't it be a little easier to tell the difference between the powerful HD systems and the crappy Wii graphics?

Heres one:

vs

Which is which?

Yeah TC, they are so hard to tell apart... which one could be the Wii version.... geez, its just so hard to tell.

moistsandwich

Not overly fair since the games are completely different. The Wii version was developed jointly with the PS2 and PSP versions and has nothing to do with the HD versions, but I'm game.

Pic A

Pic B

Pic C

ps3

360

ur wii wii

Pic A

Pic B

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

Pic A

Pic BMatch away...mrfokken

Really, a native platform against its port? You shouldn't have to try that hard. Remember, I'm not arguing what the systems are capable of.

Let's do it again.

Pic A

Pic B

Pic C

I'm guessing:

A - PS3

B - 360

C - Wii

I find it funny how most people guessed pic 2 the blurry one was PS3. Just shows how bad PS3 multiplats are compared to the 360.SilentlyMad

Pic A

Pic B

NVIDIATI

Did you really choose to compare a 3 year old Wii game to one that is currently under develpment for the 360?

These would be more appropriate.

By the way, the top one is from the 360.

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

Pic A

Pic B

mrfokken

Did you really choose to compare a 3 year old Wii game to one that is currently under develpment for the 360?

These would be more appropriate.

By the way, the top one is from the 360.

Considering you don't like a "3 year old game" being compared to its port then lets comapre NMH2 to NMHP

[QUOTE="mrfokken"]

[QUOTE="Reemer99"]

1. 360

2. Wii

3. PS3

SaltyMeatballs

You got it. My point? Shouldn't it be a little easier to tell the difference between the powerful HD systems and the crappy Wii graphics?

They are normal res for galleries from Gamespot and IGN (they are their pics). Umm let's see, can you tell the difference between these two, same game, same room. Wii VS PS2

I don't see the point of this thread

the 3rd pic is plain dumb, u shoulda used in game comparisons for all 3, cutscenes can look crappy across the board

[QUOTE="mrfokken"]

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

Pic A

Pic B

NVIDIATI

Did you really choose to compare a 3 year old Wii game to one that is currently under develpment for the 360?

These would be more appropriate.

By the way, the top one is from the 360.

Considering you don't like a "3 year old game" being compared to its port then lets comapre NMH2 to NMHP

You know, you really shouldn't need to compare a rendered cut scene from a yet to be released game off a superior system to a in-game graphic from its weaker foe. Overcompensate much?

I just put up comparible real graphics from the systems, you go out and find extremes. Does it bother you that much that your precious HD system, on occasion. puts out graphics that aren't that different than a less capable console? Life's tough huh.

I don't see the point of this thread

thelastguy