Comparison Uncharted 2 vs. RE5, technical graphics?

[QUOTE="funsohng"]i think the amount of polygons can be somewhat covered with good art direction. i remember watching a preview for uncharted 2 and they were saying the walls were actually flat, but because of the art direction (and texture res too) it looked like it was 3dMC3887

[QUOTE="MC3887"][QUOTE="funsohng"]i think the amount of polygons can be somewhat covered with good art direction. i remember watching a preview for uncharted 2 and they were saying the walls were actually flat, but because of the art direction (and texture res too) it looked like it was 3dronvalencia

I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

My opinion is that I agree with the majority of the world's gaming Reviewers and Critics, which is that Uncharted 2 blows RE5 away graphically.I'm talking visually, graphically, technically. Whatever you want to say. There is no comparison.

I have not compared any PC graphics (I don't like waiting for ports, I have to play NOW lol.), so if that's where this thread is going....

Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

[QUOTE="ronvalencia"][QUOTE="MC3887"] I remember Digital foundry stating that aswell. Also, yea it can but it irks me when people say X console can't do this because X game LOOKS so good. Uncharted does have DOF, SSAO, etc. But it just doesn't seem as technically advanced as other games (Like the ones mentioned)mitu123

UP.S I think GTA4 and KZ2 are beating other games(console) this gen (technically), so far. GOW3, Alan wake, H:R, that new ICO game, rage, and crysis 2 might change my mind. P.P.S: Happy new year!MC3887

I've NEVER been impressed by GTA4's graphics. They're probably the worst out of all the games I have for my PS3. I really do like Killzone 2 though.

My opinion is that I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

Uncharted 2 blows the game away graphically. I have not compared any PC graphics, so if that's where this thread is going. Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

SolidTy

[QUOTE="MC3887"]UP.S I think GTA4 and KZ2 are beating other games(console) this gen (technically), so far. GOW3, Alan wake, H:R, that new ICO game, rage, and crysis 2 might change my mind. P.P.S: Happy new year!iggyb387

I've NEVER been impressed by GTA4's graphics. They're probably the worst out of all the games I have for my PS3. I really do like Killzone 2 though.

[QUOTE="funsohng"]i think the amount of polygons can be somewhat covered with good art direction. i remember watching a preview for uncharted 2 and they were saying the walls were actually flat, but because of the art direction (and texture res too) it looked like it was 3dMC3887

My opinion is that I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

Uncharted 2 blows the game away graphically. I have not compared any PC graphics, so if that's where this thread is going. Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

SolidTy

In your opinion :P

[QUOTE="iggyb387"]

[QUOTE="MC3887"]UP.S I think GTA4 and KZ2 are beating other games(console) this gen (technically), so far. GOW3, Alan wake, H:R, that new ICO game, rage, and crysis 2 might change my mind. P.P.S: Happy new year!MC3887

I've NEVER been impressed by GTA4's graphics. They're probably the worst out of all the games I have for my PS3. I really do like Killzone 2 though.

Even technically, I've always found it to be full of jaggies. Some textures are great, but the character models, especially facial models, leave much to be desired. Plus, the game just looks flat sometimes.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="ronvalencia"] UC2 doesn't have fulltime SSAO.MC3887

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

My opinion is that I agree with the majority of the world's gaming Reviewers and Critics, which is thatUncharted 2 blows RE5 away graphically.I'm talking visually, graphically, technically. Whatever you want to say. There is no comparison.

I have not compared any PC graphics (I don't like waiting for ports, I have to play NOW lol.), so if that's where this thread is going....

Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

navyguy21

In your opinion :P

That is correct, I edited my post, but you didn't catch it I guess. :P

I have to edit a lot here at GS due to glitches.:(

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

My opinion is that I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

Uncharted 2 blows the game away graphically. I have not compared any PC graphics, so if that's where this thread is going. Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

navyguy21

In your opinion :P

No, not really an opinion. More like a fact. Uncharted 2 just looks better. I have both too. Resi5 has better explosions I guess, but everything else is better in Uncharted 2. But if we use the PC version of RE5, it probably looks better than Uncharted 2.

SilverChimera

Both games look great on my ps3. I have a hard time picking which one I think looks better.

[QUOTE="MC3887"][QUOTE="funsohng"]i think the amount of polygons can be somewhat covered with good art direction. i remember watching a preview for uncharted 2 and they were saying the walls were actually flat, but because of the art direction (and texture res too) it looked like it was 3dbrennan7777

[QUOTE="navyguy21"]

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

My opinion is that I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

Uncharted 2 blows the game away graphically. I have not compared any PC graphics, so if that's where this thread is going. Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

SilverChimera

In your opinion :P

[QUOTE="navyguy21"]

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

My opinion is that I have 1000 Gamerscore on RESIDENT EVIL 5, and I ALSO have a PLATINUM TROPHY on RESIDENT EVIL 5.

Uncharted 2 blows the game away graphically. I have not compared any PC graphics, so if that's where this thread is going. Let's just get it over with and post 100,000 CRYSIS pics and be done with it.

SilverChimera

In your opinion :P

[QUOTE="SilverChimera"]

[QUOTE="navyguy21"]

In your opinion :P

navyguy21

U2 no question

[QUOTE="navyguy21"][QUOTE="funsohng"]i think the amount of polygons can be somewhat covered with good art direction. i remember watching a preview for uncharted 2 and they were saying the walls were actually flat, but because of the art direction (and texture res too) it looked like it was 3draskullibur

stop using the opinion card.....its a FACT that uncharted 2 is techincaly better.......you do know that some of the background in resident evil 5 are prerendered right......that is massive fail in my book

RE5 blows away uncharted 2 in scale and things on screen,plus it supports 4xMSAA on xbox 360..let alone the superior PC version with 2 the detail and running over 60fps..Tessellation

stop using the opinion card.....its a FACT that uncharted 2 is techincaly better.......you do know that some of the background in resident evil 5 are prerendered right......that is massive fail in my book

Syn_Valence

[QUOTE="Tessellation"]RE5 blows away uncharted 2 in scale and things on screen,plus it supports 4xMSAA on xbox 360..let alone the superior PC version with 2 the detail and running over 60fps..Sandallman

Show some screen from RE5 and tell me where the f*ck are those polygons. Honestly, I completed RE5 on my PC and I think this game looks just average, shytty extures, low polgon enemies models, low polygon enviroment. I think this number came from porticular moment in a cutscene probably. I coudn't find good source but apparentlly Crysis render 2m polygons/frame, anyone thinks RE5 looks better? :) As for U2, this game is technically and artisticaly amazing.

I think RE5 looks great, however polygon count isn't a very good way to judge graphics imo. I think RE5's high polygon count comes from the large number of enemies on the screen, there can be over 20 of them in one place.

But that doesn't really make up for some of the poor textures and the lack of interactive environments/objects. It just feels a bit old-fashioned in the sense that that it's very linear and scripted, objects cannot really be moved or broken unless they're meant to be. That's why something like GTA4 is more impressive to me, the world feels dynamic and alive which is where games should be heading.

[QUOTE="Sandallman"][QUOTE="Tessellation"]RE5 blows away uncharted 2 in scale and things on screen,plus it supports 4xMSAA on xbox 360..let alone the superior PC version with 2 the detail and running over 60fps..Tessellation

[QUOTE="Tessellation"][QUOTE="Sandallman"] Is that a joke?Sandallman

am i the only one here that is not impressed with RE5 graphics? i have both PS360 version and didnt really impressed with the visual, yeah its great but gears2 and U2 are better IMO.

am i the only one here that is not impressed with RE5 graphics? i have both PS360 version and didnt really impressed with the visual, yeah its great but gears2 and U2 are better IMO.

___gamemaster__

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

am i the only one here that is not impressed with RE5 graphics? i have both PS360 version and didnt really impressed with the visual, yeah its great but gears2 and U2 are better IMO.

Sandallman

yeah and that one. and the game itself is very disapointing. luckily the coop is fun.

Uncharted 2=1.2 million triangles per frame- I think most people have seen the video were they state this... RE5= 3-4 million polygons, per frame http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/face-off-resident-evil-5-article. X360 version of RE5- 0-4xAA(Variable) PS3 Uncharted 2- 2xAA Now with that said, I do not know the texture resolution for each individual game, but it is safe to assume that Uncharted's are higher. I just wanted to do the comparison, shows that pretty visuals does not mean the actual graphics. P.S I think GTA4 and KZ2 are beating other games(console) this gen (technically), so far. GOW3, Alan wake, H:R, that new ICO game, rage, and crysis 2 might change my mind. P.P.S: Happy new year!MC3887

so much wrong with this statement coming from a CAD/3d modelling student.

1.A huge part of graphics is how they look and how pleasing they are to the eye.If we are talking bout games i can argue Crysis looks better but i feel Uncharted 2 or Halo were more pleasing to the eye due to their respective artystyles and that they were more pleasing to my eye as they make the game feel a more immersive experience and more enjoyable to certain people but there is a saying diffrent horses for diffrent courses since everyone feels diffrently.

2.Its not how much poly's you render its how you use em.Higher poly counts dont always mean better looking just more calculation on the chip.

I'm very impressed with its visuals. I'm playing the PC version at 1920x1200 with 4x AA and it's easily one of the best looking games I've ever seen.

This may sound weird, me being a hermit and all, but I'm actually playing it locked at 30 FPS. It makes for a much more cinematic feel, while if locked to 60, it's "too" smooth for me to actually notice the superb motion blur effect and animations.

I'm very impressed with its visuals. I'm playing the PC version at 1920x1200 with 4x AA and it's easily one of the best looking games I've ever seen.

This may sound weird, me being a hermit and all, but I'm actually playing it locked at 30 FPS. It makes for a much more cinematic feel, while if locked to 60, it's "too" smooth for me to actually notice the superb motion blur effect and animations.

the_delta

if it were locked to 24fps then it would be true cinema xD wonder if its possible to do that lol.But if you could then it would be the best.Still it shows in a way that higher FPS does not always mean for better experience.

Still need to get a shot of RE5 on the PC :( i only have the lowly PS3 version :'(

[QUOTE="Sandallman"][QUOTE="Tessellation"]RE5 blows away uncharted 2 in scale and things on screen,plus it supports 4xMSAA on xbox 360..let alone the superior PC version with 2 the detail and running over 60fps..Tessellation

[QUOTE="Tessellation"][QUOTE="Sandallman"] Is that a joke?killzowned24