This topic is locked from further discussion.
[QUOTE="moose_knuckler"]Never knew one Gears emo trailer could start so many non-graphic Gears threads :P.Crysis333It wasn't really emo is was a partiality a re-cap of previous games. And it wasn't written by Travis. Has moody song, so that's enough for me to call it emo.
It is very difficult in a game like Gears of War to have a good story. Gameplay and stroytellying in videogames fight over one another and aren't cohesive at all. They fight with each other for spotlight and it is difficult to find a balence with the two. Especially in a game like gears that has a mediocre premise to begin with. Games need to find another way of telling a story other than gameplay,cutscene, gameplay, cutscene.
The storytelling was good, the story itself was alright. Karren Traviss is a good writer though, I have a feeling she will do an above average job.
Never knew one Gears emo trailer could start so many non-graphic Gears threads :P.moose_knucklerHaha Gears always releases some amazingly emotional looking trailer than then the game falls flat. I wish the games were half as epic as the trailers were.
Never knew one Gears emo trailer could start so many non-graphic Gears threads :P.moose_knucklerCan someone link me the new trailer? I'd like to see it.
[QUOTE="moose_knuckler"]Never knew one Gears emo trailer could start so many non-graphic Gears threads :P.carljohnson3456Can someone link me the new trailer? I'd like to see it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5AVJXw--IQ&hd=1
Here you go man. :)
The Gears of War novels from Karen Traviss are fantastic. I love them.
As for "redeeming" the story... Well is the Gears story really in need of redeeming? Is it really any worse than the typical shooter plot? Sure, the original wasn't too deep or emotional but did it need to be? It was enjoyable and the banter and sarcasm between the characters was funny. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
And I feel the same way about Gears of War 2 aside from the whole Maria schtick which personally I do not understand why that whole story arch recieves so much hate on system wars. Why is Dom having a wife and being upset that she's been gone and then later having to... put her out of her misery a hilariously bad story by the accounts of other users here? Guys with big muscles and guns aren't allowed to have emotions or lives outside of the battle, is that right? But if a game doesn't try then you see it get lambasted for being a brofest.
Gears of War is a shooter about guys with huge muscles and lots of blood. No matter what it may try it's going to lose in the story department because of that in system wars regardless of any of it's actual merits.
Pretty much this. While ill agree gears doesn't have an RPG-level story, i belive that its good for a shooter. I was in disbelief when the Dom-Maria cutscene happened, i haad to stop playing for about 10 minutes.The Gears of War novels from Karen Traviss are fantastic. I love them.
As for "redeeming" the story... Well is the Gears story really in need of redeeming? Is it really any worse than the typical shooter plot? Sure, the original wasn't too deep or emotional but did it need to be? It was enjoyable and the banter and sarcasm between the characters was funny. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
And I feel the same way about Gears of War 2 aside from the whole Maria schtick which personally I do not understand why that whole story arch recieves so much hate on system wars. Why is Dom having a wife and being upset that she's been gone and then later having to... put her out of her misery a hilariously bad story by the accounts of other users here? Guys with big muscles and guns aren't allowed to have emotions or lives outside of the battle, is that right? But if a game doesn't try then you see it get lambasted for being a brofest.
Gears of War is a shooter about guys with huge muscles and lots of blood. No matter what it may try it's going to lose in the story department because of that in system wars regardless of any of it's actual merits.
vashkey
I don't mind the weak story; the game is more about the sci-fi war and over the top visceral action.
I'm still on the fence if I'm going to start off on SP or MP. I want to know the ending; but at the same time I want to rank up quicker than my friends. Argh!
-Gears Fever-
Does anyone actually care about the story in GeoW? If you want a good story, you'd be playing Mass Effect or Uncharted.Timstuff
Uncharted doesn't have a good story either :?
[QUOTE="Timstuff"]Does anyone actually care about the story in GeoW? If you want a good story, you'd be playing Mass Effect or Uncharted.FoolwithaLancer
Uncharted doesn't have a good story either :?
It doesn't have a good plot, but that doesn't mean it doesn't have a good story. On paper GeoW has a great plot (humans are the aliens, and are being driven to extinction by the locals who are taking back their land), but the story is crap because ultimately it's just a bunch of bald space marines eviscerating monsters and it never explores the deeper implications of its setting. Uncharted takes a fairly standard treasure hunt story and makes it so friggin' fun and the characters are so lovable that it doesn't matter if the basic "get the treasure before the well-funded villain" scenario is nothing new.Because it's a horribly directed cutscene(I think the script was the worst offender on that part), not because they aren't allowed to have emotions.And I feel the same way about Gears of War 2 aside from the whole Maria schtick which personally I do not understand why that whole story arch recieves so much hate on system wars. Why is Dom having a wife and being upset that she's been gone and then later having to... put her out of her misery a hilariously bad story by the accounts of other users here? Guys with big muscles and guns aren't allowed to have emotions or lives outside of the battle, is that right? But if a game doesn't try then you see it get lambasted for being a brofest.
vashkey
[QUOTE="tagyhag"]Storytelling is fine, the story itself is what sucks, but that doesn't matter, 99.9% of video game stories are doodoo. As long as the gameplay is good the game will be fine.Crysis333I think you've got it reversed my friend. i agree with you.. i enjoy the gears story... the storytelling is is meh.
Gears has to be redeemed? how Its story is fine and so is its storytelling.
as I've said before maybe you should stop, look around stop skipping cutscenes and put down the lancer because there is quite a good story there. If I go into most any fps or tps this generation and skip the cutscenes and ignore the story then I can say then I will also think those games have bad stories...doesn't mean they actually do though.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment