GO
This topic is locked from further discussion.
evne though Demon's Souls is by far the best PS3 title this gen, Mass Effect 2 edges it by just a bit becuase of the incredible characters.
Demon's Souls by a landslide. ME2 is great, but lacks in re playability, length, challenge, and customization compared to Demon's Souls.Zoso-8I dont think this. I value your opinion in one over the other, but ME2 has good to great replay value.
[QUOTE="Zoso-8"]Demon's Souls by a landslide. ME2 is great, but lacks in re playability, length, challenge, and customization compared to Demon's Souls.BadNewsBenI dont think this. I value your opinion in one over the other, but ME2 has good to great replay value. I'm not saying it doesn't. I'm saying it lacks in comparison to Demon's Souls.
Mass Effect 2 is better than DS in every way. They're not even in the same league.
KarateeeChop
Lulz. You are an xbot. I've seen your "Is this a serious thread?" responses in all the threads putting anything xbox360 at question. You have the least amount of credibility in this matter.
I personally liked Mass Effect 2- IMO, the storyline and characters were better developed :P However, I must admit, Demon's Souls combat system is cool too :D
Ya story wasn't Demon's Souls strong point. It had a lot of very very cool subtle things about the background, but the plot of the game added up to "Save the world/Boletaria by killing things." Not a big deal though, the role playing and combat was incredible. I actually just beat the game last weekend, very satisfied, and ab it scared to start uo New Game + for fear of having my ego ruined :P.I personally liked Mass Effect 2- IMO, the storyline and characters were better developed :P However, I must admit, Demon's Souls combat system is cool too :D
bobbleheadrogue
Demon's Souls was awesome...but when it comes down to it.the game is just another dark fantasy dungeon crawler...not to mention Kings Field was way superior.
Mass Effect 2,despite people's opinions on it being a true RPG or not. provided a better overall unique experience.
Demon's Souls is my game of the generation so easy vote but I would like to say that Mass Effect 2 is amazing as well.
I haven't finished ME2 yet, though I own it so I'm just comparing ME1 to DS for now.
I enjoyed DS more. The multiplayer component is the kicker for me. Duels are awesome and Ganking a black phantom w/ a group of blue phantoms is lulz.
On another note, I have nothing bad to say about ME except about the vehicle. Enjoyable game.
Whats with the Mass Effect VS threads?
Anyway there is something about DS that always has me coming back for more. So its gotta be that for me.
I guess you could dumb it down to that, but I thought it was the incredible depth, combat, enemy design, atmosphere, and then of course the extremely unique online features with co-op, PvP, leaving hints, and the bloodstains, as well as the fact that the game constantly autosaved so it provided a very immersive sense of everything you do being absolutely permanent, whether it be wasting a valuable item, dying, losing 400k souls, or being Soulsucked in PvP, as opposed to standard games in which you make a mistake, you can just reset the system and start over with all resources back. I dunno, it all struck me as cool, and I see it as why it's a step up from a similar game like King's Field (which probably aspired to be like Demon's Souls but simply couldn't due to technology limitations. The only flaw I ever found in Demon's Souls was an occasional drastic framerate drop, but it only occurred during huge explosions of fire and when the Blue Dragon moved. Outside that I found it to be a rather perfect game. Sorry I'm rambling, it's just I would love to go start my New Game + and just forget about my essay I'm writing right now :P.Demon's Souls was awesome...but when it comes down to it.the game is just another dark fantasy dungeon crawler...not to mention Kings Field was way superior.
Mass Effect 2,despite people's opinions on it being a true RPG or not. provided a better overall unique experience.
Kandlegoat
[QUOTE="zarshack"]Ya, just because Demon's Souls has been out longer and to make significant progress you need to pour major hours into it. Not really. Once you get the hang of it it really isnt that hard. When i think back to my first playthrough. I died on Tower Knight, armored spider, and Maneaters (probably a hundred thousand times on these guys). Other than that i would die occasionally on levels, but never on the other bosses.ME2 was better even though i've spent 4 times as much time on Demon's Souls. Meaning to say 35 hours versus over 120 hours.
KRaDOSIV
How is this any diffrent than a 360 vs ps3 poll since there both exclusives?? Because theres no way possible that demons soul should be ahead on a poll against ME2 just no way. ME2 is by far the better game by a land slidebigboss5akApparentally not.
Apparentally not. But what im trying to say is that fanboys will just vote for the game thats on their console. If this was a poll on ME2 vs MAG im pretty confident MAG would be in the lead just like demons soul is because MAG is on ther console of choice and ME2 isnt even if they knew that MAG isnt a better game than ME2.[QUOTE="bigboss5ak"]How is this any diffrent than a 360 vs ps3 poll since there both exclusives?? Because theres no way possible that demons soul should be ahead on a poll against ME2 just no way. ME2 is by far the better game by a land slidebrennan7777
[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]I guess you could dumb it down to that, but I thought it was the incredible depth, combat, enemy design, atmosphere, and then of course the extremely unique online features with co-op, PvP, leaving hints, and the bloodstains, as well as the fact that the game constantly autosaved so it provided a very immersive sense of everything you do being absolutely permanent, whether it be wasting a valuable item, dying, losing 400k souls, or being Soulsucked in PvP, as opposed to standard games in which you make a mistake, you can just reset the system and start over with all resources back. I dunno, it all struck me as cool, and I see it as why it's a step up from a similar game like King's Field (which probably aspired to be like Demon's Souls but simply couldn't due to technology limitations. The only flaw I ever found in Demon's Souls was an occasional drastic framerate drop, but it only occurred during huge explosions of fire and when the Blue Dragon moved. Outside that I found it to be a rather perfect game. Sorry I'm rambling, it's just I would love to go start my New Game + and just forget about my essay I'm writing right now :P.Demon's Souls was awesome...but when it comes down to it.the game is just another dark fantasy dungeon crawler...not to mention Kings Field was way superior.
Mass Effect 2,despite people's opinions on it being a true RPG or not. provided a better overall unique experience.
KRaDOSIV
wow...I was personally expecting some fanboy wall of text that consisted of "U Neva played it"...but instead,you actually made a well thought,unbiased,retort.
I enjoyed Demons Souls.and I acknowledge the things you mentioned..But like I said...its just another Dark Fantasy RPG.
Mass Effect 1@2 made me feel like I was roleplaying 70's-80's Sci Fi like Dune,Blade Runner,Terminator,Enemy Mine,Brazil,Logan's Run,Buck Rogers,Battlestar Galactica.
[QUOTE="brennan7777"]Apparentally not. But what im trying to say is that fanboys will just vote for the game thats on their console. If this was a poll on ME2 vs MAG im pretty confident MAG would be in the lead just like demons soul is because MAG is on ther console of choice and ME2 isnt even if they knew that MAG isnt a better game than ME2.[QUOTE="bigboss5ak"]How is this any diffrent than a 360 vs ps3 poll since there both exclusives?? Because theres no way possible that demons soul should be ahead on a poll against ME2 just no way. ME2 is by far the better game by a land slidebigboss5ak
If this is battle of the fanboys wouldn't ME2 win? Hermits & Lems vs Cows.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment