DiRT vs. Forza vs. PGR4 vs. GTHD

GTHD Pawns all and its only a Tech Demo!! i wonder how GT5 will look like :shock:

GTHD Pawns all and its only a Tech Demo!! i wonder how GT5 will look like :shock:

arabi_89

*sigh* tech newbies...

you just answered right there, "tech demo"...it's easily to put all your processing power into one car.

That being said, from what I've seen of PGR4... I'd say that is the best looking. Dirt is very promising, although I'll wait for the full game.

Forza 2 is last of the group, but it's not an ugly game...and it's smooth as butter.

From what i've seen, PGR4 or DIRT. no offense but GT:HD cant be compared to anything cos its not a real game.

i would leave GT:HD out. it's a pretty car with bad sound, bad physics, NO car sim, bad surroundings, and 1 car on 1 track.....

The cars look the best though, but we can't assume they would look as great in a real game with physics, good sound, good surroundings, car sim options, multiple opponents and multiple tracks....

I would leave out PGR4 too, cause we know nothing about this game, except for from early screens and a clip that could very well be far from the finished game... 

so:

1 dirt

2 MOTORSTORM

3 Forza

4 PGR3 

i would leave GT:HD out. it's a pretty car with bad sound, bad physics, NO car sim, bad surroundings, and 1 car on 1 track.....

The cars look the best though, but we can't assume they would look as great in a real game with physics, good sound, good surroundings, car sim options, multiple opponents and multiple tracks....

 

I would leave out PGR4 too, cause we know nothing about this game, except for from early screens and a clip that could very well be far from the finished game... 

so:

 

1 dirt

2 MOTORSTORM

3 Forza

4 PGR3 

 

danneswegman

agreed

/thread

In it's present state PGR4 looks better than anything, but not a exact represantation of what we will get, but if I were to base this off of final product GTHD blows everything away in visual appeal.

.GazzaB

ur point? not gameplay graphics. IMO i reckon forza will b the best overall

[QUOTE="GazzaB"].fenwickhotmail

ur point? not gameplay graphics. IMO i reckon forza will b the best overall

Actually the trailer where those pics were taken from are in-game.

[QUOTE="GazzaB"].fenwickhotmail

ur point? not gameplay graphics. IMO i reckon forza will b the best overall

My point is it ****s all over Forza. Forza will be great, but you cant argue that its graphics arent great. It looked pretty bland to me when i played the demo. 

[QUOTE="GazzaB"].fenwickhotmail

ur point? not gameplay graphics. IMO i reckon forza will b the best overall

Actually the trailer where those pics were taken from are in-game.

GTHD Pawns all and its only a Tech Demo!! i wonder how GT5 will look like :shock:

arabi_89

I have not seen enaugh of PGR4 yet so i will compare only the other 3 games.

1.Forza 2 (looks the best overall, the most sharp picture with the most crisp textures, very nice environments great car models fantastic lightning and reflection and damn smooth framerate)

2.GT HD (also as Forza a very sharp picture with great car models and also as smooth as Forza but wih worse environments, lightning and reflections)

3.Dirt (very nice and rich environments with nice cars, but really really blury picture with total overused bloom, very brown orange picture and only 30fps which isn't even stable.

X.PGR4 (i will compare it when i will see it on my display)