Do you think all the games Gamespot gave 10 out of 10 deserved it?

The legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time

Soulcalibur

Chrono Cross

Tony Hawk's Pro skater 3 (Playstation 2)

Grand Theft Auto 4

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Are there any games up there that shouldn't? If there is why shouldn't they be also which out of all the 10/10 games at Gamespot if the best of all time?

GTAIV was a solid 9.0 IMO. It had a stronger narrative than the previous games in the series, but it also lacked a lot of the fun. That, and the missions started getting overly repetitive.

Only Crono Cross, Soul Calibur and Ocarina of time imo

Ocarina of Time, Soulcalibur and Crono Cross deserve every bit of it.

The other two don't. GTAIV is an amazing game, but it's not a ten. Same with MGS4.

Though GTS4 deserved probably a 9.0-9.5.

MGS probably deserved a 9.0.

Well a Gamespot 10/10 does not mean perfect, so I would say that of the one's i've played, yes they do (played Chrono Cross, OoT, MGS4, GTA4).

GTA IV and Chrono Cross, that's it.

I just disagree with GTA IV. a 9.0 if anything.

OOT, Chrono Cross and MGS4 deserve it.

I haven't played SoulCalibur but if it's anything like its sequels I don't see how it could be a 10 out of 10 game.

GTA4 Ocarina of time. Maybe pro skater lol

GTA IV and Chrono Cross, that's it.

BioShockOwnz

Out of the ones I've played, the only one I think that realy deserved the 10 was Soul Calibur.

GTA IV deffinately didn't IMO. Ther others, I can't really say too much about because I haven't spent that much time with them

Yes on zelda, yes on soul caliber, no on everything else.

GTA IV and Chrono Cross, that's it.

BioShockOwnz

Ive played OOT and CC and they deserve it. GTA4 doesnt deserve it though. Dont know about the others since I havent played them but SC seems like it deserves it as well.

Well a Gamespot 10/10 does not mean perfect, so I would say that of the one's i've played, yes they do (played Chrono Cross, OoT, MGS4, GTA4).

lundy86_4

It used to. Only recntly did they change it from perfect to prime.

Mgs4,Zelda those are the 10s......GTA4 should get an 8 9 at best.

Everything except Tony Hawk, MGSIV, and GTA4 should have gotten a 10/10

Id say Soul Calibur and tony hawk deserve it, the others deserve solid 9.5's, but no not 10s imho.

I think all of them deserve their score. I enjoyed all of those games very much.

certainly not GTA4.

soul caliber + OOT deserved the 10

the others (especially GTA IV) fell short of perfect IMO

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time- No.
Soul Calibur- No.
Chrono Cross- No.
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3- LOL NO
Metal Gear Solid 4- WTF NO
Grand Theft Auto IV- NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!

IMO Only OOT deserves it.

but the only perfect game is MM:D

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Well a Gamespot 10/10 does not mean perfect, so I would say that of the one's i've played, yes they do (played Chrono Cross, OoT, MGS4, GTA4).

goblaa

It used to. Only recntly did they change it from perfect to prime.

True. Now i'm wondering if they scored the games as perfect, or if it was jst categorized as such. Hmmmm... The way I see it, no game could ever be perfect.

Well a Gamespot 10/10 does not mean perfect, so I would say that of the one's i've played, yes they do (played Chrono Cross, OoT, MGS4, GTA4).

lundy86_4

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time- No.

MetroidPrimePwn

Epic Phail.

[QUOTE="MetroidPrimePwn"]

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time- No.

LegatoSkyheart

Epic Phail.

Oh noez! There are people out there who are not you that don't have the exact same opinion as you! :o

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Well a Gamespot 10/10 does not mean perfect, so I would say that of the one's i've played, yes they do (played Chrono Cross, OoT, MGS4, GTA4).

adman66

Yup, another posted corrected me :P

Now i'm wondering if the reviewers actually found the game before this change to be perfect :? Ahhh well.

No game can be perfect, but the first few on that list came about as close as you could reasonably expect. GTA 4 and MGS4 imo did not deserve a 10 though, as they both had some serious flaws.

Only Ocarina of Time deserves it.

All but GTA IV.

Get rid of MGS4 and GTA4 then that list sounds about right.

Stringerboy

Pretty much the right answer. MGS4 is a 9 at best and GTAIV is an 8.5 at best...

I not think MGS4, GTA4, THOS3 and Chrono Cross deserved 10's. Sure they are ll great games but they weren't 10 out of 10 games.

MGS4 and GTA4 deserve 10.