Forza 3 vs NFS Shift vs Dirt 2 vs GT5

For now, who will win the best racing game ?

GT5 of course !!

Forza 3 looks good but it's like Saints row 2 vs Grand Theft Auto.

GT is the master !!!

GT5 >>> Forza 3 >>>>>>>>>Dirt 2 > NFS Shift. :P

NFS?? seriously?? those games havent been good since the late 90's, and thats being generous.

Forza!!!!!

GT use to be the king for many years, but Forza is now the king.

Forza 3, since we have actual seen the gameplay and new features

GT5 we have seen nothing

Dirt 2 meh

NFS meh

LOL NFS ?????????? wow man ! I hope you are kidding me since Dirt 2 beat NFS.

NFS is the last choice, look at last NFS games

I'm much more hyped for Forza 3, they already have a great francise and seem to get on with things.

LOL NFS ?????????? wow man ! I hope you are kidding me since Dirt 2 beat NFS.

NFS is the last choice, look at last NFS games

For now, who will win the best racing game ?

GT5 of course !!

Forza 3 looks good but it's like Saints row 2 vs Grand Theft Auto.

GT is the master !!!

Hydrolex

Except the Forza series has actually outscored the recent GT games. So analogy failed.

Forza 3 will be the best.

Two possible overrated games(GT5 and Forza 3) along with 2 possible bland games(Dirt 2 and NFS Shift), fair enough, Forza 3 then.

For now, who will win the best racing game ?

GT5 of course !!

Forza 3 looks good but it's like Saints row 2 vs Grand Theft Auto.

GT is the master !!!

Hydrolex

GT WAS the master. But that was before Forza came along and took the crown for console racing sims. You may not be able to recognize this, but reviewers certainly are ;)

Forza 3 > GT5 > NFS Shift > DiRT 2

Forza 3 = GT 5 > Dirt 2 > NFS

seeing asthough we havent seen any GT5 yet, its hard to tell. Though i would advise against assuming the addition of NASCAR and Rally will improve GT5 as much as some people are saying, the TRD series tried mixing production car races with rallying and single seaters to no great effect. If GT5 is lacking in damage for some vehicles i think reviewers may pick up on it.

This

Spilt/Second

nfs wii if it goes in nfs3 roots

Forza 3 for moi

I vote for NFS:Shift. GT5 and Forza 3 are both going to be top notch racing sims, but I would much rather play a NFS game over any total sim racer, just isn't really my style. Shift will be a mix of a sim with an arcade feel which is what I'm wanting more. I also preferred Grid over Dirt and if Grid 2 was ever to come out I would choose that.

Forza 3>>Pgr4>>Gt5>>Dirt 2>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Nfs shift

Whoa, a 360 game beating a PS3 game in votes in a SW poll?! This is a first for me! XD But anyways, I'll go with Forza, because I don't like NFS games, I've no interest in Dirt and I got a 360. Not to say I don't like Gran Turismo either, GT3 and GT4 were good, but I love Forza 2 just as much, if not more, so...=P