Gamespot overrated every single exclusive 360 launch game.That's just sad.

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81%

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82%

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86%

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

Even so.. By you standards those games are still AA, while RFOM is... AA even at gamerankings.

Three AA beats one AA.

Today's whine was made entirely with the best sour grapes. Here have a bottle.

Gears got AAA here and Gamerankings
Call of Duty 2 got AA here but AAA on gamerankings
Crackdown got A here and AA on gamerankings. an 85
and the list goes on. why would gamespot scores directly match gamerankings. only one of those scores is that big of a difference and thats PDZ. and either way its a good game. stop hating cow.

PGR3 got 88% from Gamerankings

And 1up gave PGR3 a 10

So Gamespot had too good of an opinion, ay?

Interesting...

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81%

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82%

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86%

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting aserious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules if this place is toremain fun.If the majority disagrees with me than i think this place is probably not for me.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

musacircuit

I was about to say and PGR3 beat Resistance...pgr3 has an 88...

Yea...i'll agree to some degree that some of the games were overrated ( like kameo and pdz...) but if u combine both launches on gamerankings the 360 still has the better launch.

Sooooo let me get this straight...We are no longer to use the rules of SW to argue in SW? What do you want them to do change the 360 game scores? Add +1 to every PS3 score out of fairness and pity?

What I would say is that if you are a big PS3 supporter then later when the Ps3 comes into its own and realizes it's "potential"(isn't that the word that gets thrown around here alot?) Then the ownage will be all the sweeter for the true believers that can tough it out through these dark days.

PGR3 got 88% from Gamerankings

And 1up gave PGR3 a 10

demoralizer

Gears got AAA here and Gamerankings
Call of Duty 2 got AA here but AAA on gamerankings
Crackdown got A here and AA on gamerankings. an 85
and the list goes on. why would gamespot scores directly match gamerankings. only one of those scores is that big of a difference and thats PDZ. and either way its a good game. stop hating cow.

jg4xchamp

Cod2 is not exclusive.

Motorstorm has AA at gamerankings as well.

Kameo gets 8.7 over here and VF5 gets 8.1.Kameo gets 81% at GR and VF5 gets 87%.What's up with that.

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81%

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82%

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86%

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

musacircuit

Do you want some cheese with that whine?

/thread

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81%

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82%

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86%

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

musacircuit

GRAW is also a 360 exclusive. The ONLY platform the 360 version of GRAW is on is the360. THE PC version is not ever a third person shooter.

So, I guess there goes your thread.

Today's whine was made entirely with the best sour grapes. Here have a bottle.

heretrix

well said.

Today's whine was made entirely with the best sour grapes. Here have a bottle.

heretrix

Also there are other games on the 360 that came out during the 7 month strecth that cover caseys thread. DOA 4, GRAW, Burnout Revenge, Oblivion etc. The 360 library had a better launch wether u like it or not. U can go by gamerankings, u can go by gamespot. 360 owned the PS3 library. PS3 only has 9 or 10 AA games on gamerankings after 7 months. and 1 being AAA. The 360 had 3 AAA, and about 15-18 AA games during that stretch u fail. jg4xchamp

U=FAIL

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86%

musacircuit

Also, PGR 3 an8 8.9 on GR.

WHat are you smoking man?

Yes, the 360 launch was overrated, the 360's best games are all on PC so unless you're on here via XBL you can play em, and in general the 360 is overrated.ShmenonPie

pdz on pc?no

pgr4 on pc?no

kamoe on pc? no

andmost of the best games on the 360 are not on pc

gears of war

graw(it stinks on pc and isnt even the saem game)

forza 2

pdz

guitar hero 2

dead or alive 4

and its not over rated at all

[QUOTE="demoralizer"]

PGR3 got 88% from Gamerankings

And 1up gave PGR3 a 10

mestizoman

Care to elaborate?

Disagree and this is SW. If you don't like it, take your biased opinions and leave.dhjohns

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]Also there are other games on the 360 that came out during the 7 month strecth that cover caseys thread. DOA 4, GRAW, Burnout Revenge, Oblivion etc. The 360 library had a better launch wether u like it or not. U can go by gamerankings, u can go by gamespot. 360 owned the PS3 library. PS3 only has 9 or 10 AA games on gamerankings after 7 months. and 1 being AAA. The 360 had 3 AAA, and about 15-18 AA games during that stretch u fail. musacircuit

U=FAIL

[QUOTE="ShmenonPie"]Yes, the 360 launch was overrated, the 360's best games are all on PC so unless you're on here via XBL you can play em, and in general the 360 is overrated.tree-branch

pdz on pc?no

pgr4 on pc?no

kamoe on pc? no

andmost of the best games on the 360 are not on pc

gears of war

graw(it stinks on pc and isnt even the saem game)

forza 2

pdz

guitar hero 2

dead or alive 4

and its not over rated at all

self owned

24 sites scored Kameo higher than GS

62 sites score PGR3 higher than GS did (1up.com gave it a perfect 10)

25 sites score PDZ the same or higher than GS.

If you don't like Gamespot, you can always leave. 

I agree that those games are overrated personally....especially PDZ. But by the same token, I actually thought that games like Quake 4 were highly UNDERRATED. It comes down to your own personal preference anyway, so who really cares? We had enough of this discussion in Casey's thread yesterday, and the conclusion that I thought we came to was that the 360 did indeed have some good games out before Gears.

And another point that I also thought was also proven yesterday from my arguement within Casey's thread, is that the PS3 indeed does have some good exclusive games right now despite what people may say. And when you include exclusives and multi-plats, the first 7 months of releases for both the 360 and the PS3 were darn near identical in OFFICIAL scores here at GS. End of story. His point was proven, and it was also proven that the PS3 line-up for it's first 7 months is not as bad right now as people try to make it out to be.

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932731.asp

Forza 2 = 90% ;)

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81% Whats the difference its still AA

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82% PDZ deserved a low AAA

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86% again whats the difference its still AA

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

musacircuit

That site must be really messed up then...

[QUOTE="musacircuit"]

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81% Whats the difference its still AA

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82% PDZ deserved a low AAA

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86% again whats the difference its still AA

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

martin_f

That site must be really messed up then...

Yeah for sure.. Stupid bastards thinks that a bunch of reviewers could ever be as reliable as a GS reviewer... I feel sad for those lost souls.

I've got say the 360 had amazing launch titles Like Condemned, cod2 and pgr3, don't see ur problem

360 fans can't win. If it isn't a good game, it's a flop. If it is, it's overrated.

[QUOTE="martin_f"][QUOTE="musacircuit"]

Kameo...GS score 8.7...Gamerankings 81% Whats the difference its still AA

PDZ...GS score 9...Gamerankings 82% PDZ deserved a low AAA

PGR3...GS score 8.8...Gamerankings 86% again whats the difference its still AA

Basically u change those horrible overrated scores of kameo and pdz and suddenly the 360 launch is MISERABLE as what it was in reality.Only in gamespot reality 360 had a good launch.Come on ppl grow up.This is a forum and u dont have to blindly follow those illogical rules.I CANT BELIEVE THAT CASEY ACTUALLY MADE A THREAD ABOUT IT using gamespot scores to show how good 360's launch. was.Come on it's OK to use as means of ownage but seriously how can u possibly think of starting a serious discusion with that garbage.

RESISTANCE HAS OUTSCORED EVERY 360 EXCLUSIVE AT GAMERANKINGS EXCEPT GEARS.

BUT WAIT THERE ARE ACTUALLY 5 360 EXCLUSIVES THAT OUTSCORE RESISTANCE AT GAMESPOT.THAT IS JUST BEYOND RIDICULOUS.

We really need to change some rules over here if this place is to remain fun.If the majority disagrees with me then this place is probably not for me as ownage is dealt over here on CHANCE rather than accurate predictions and jugements.

NOTE:I HAVE NOT INCLUDED FORZA 2 IN THE DISCUSSION OF THIS THREAD.

omgimba

That site must be really messed up then...

Yeah for sure.. Stupid bastards thinks that a bunch of reviewers could ever be as reliable as a GS reviewer... I feel sad for those lost souls.

[QUOTE="musacircuit"]

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]Also there are other games on the 360 that came out during the 7 month strecth that cover caseys thread. DOA 4, GRAW, Burnout Revenge, Oblivion etc. The 360 library had a better launch wether u like it or not. U can go by gamerankings, u can go by gamespot. 360 owned the PS3 library. PS3 only has 9 or 10 AA games on gamerankings after 7 months. and 1 being AAA. The 360 had 3 AAA, and about 15-18 AA games during that stretch u fail. jg4xchamp

U=FAIL

So what ps3 got cod3 at launch and will be getting cod4 as well.And it's just ur opinion that 2 is beter.

Ok so ps3 is getting sigma.And revenge was justa port.

U say 360 had 3 AAA's and ps3 has one.Well one of them is cod2 and cod3 is on the ps3.Cod was an AAA game in 2005 but it wasnt in 2006 but that doesnt mean that 2 was beter.And ps3 already has oblivion.Ok so 360 got GRAW but the ps3 is getting vegas after 7 months of launch whereas 360 got it a year from launch.

Try AGAIN

A lot would agree (even lemmings) but this is Gamespot so we have to use that or this place will crumble.

360 fans can't win. If it isn't a good game, it's a flop. If it is, it's overrated.

Verge_6

It is the same way with the PS3....only much worse.