Gamespot rating system!

The only part of the review that should count is gamer's tilt. But that is what I believe. 

The only part of the review that should count is gamer's tilt. But that is what I believe.

nextgengaming18

I don't like their review system, if you actually find the average of the scores, it will differ from the score it generated.firestorm91

Gameplay & Value should be the most important.DementedDragon

People will complain no matter how they do it. BillGreen68

I think it is a good rating system because I can't really explain but I like this review system.

I think it is a good rating system because I can't really explain but I like this review system.

Nintendo_Ownes7

I'd rather see the categories weighted differently depending on the game type. For example, sound in a rhythm game is more important than graphics for that same game. MgunHunter

We have known this from the start. I'm afraid the whole system is flawed in my opinion, as a game may be technically bland yet exceed the usual boundaries of the tilt mechanism. For example, a game may have all 7s and 8s yet a 10 for tilt. That game will not get a AAA rating, yet deep down the reviewer knows it should despite its technical shortcomings. Unfortunately that can't be changed as tilt doesn't go up to 11 or 12. This is an area where the system is flawed, and needs adjusting for greater effect.

Putting a set value on other scoring areas is also flawed. Some people look for excellent sound design in a game over stunning graphics, so which area should then be weighted more heavily? This is the reason why rhythm games are often under-scored in my opinion..

We have known this from the start. I'm afraid the whole system is flawed in my opinion, as a game may be technically bland yet exceed the usual boundaries of the tilt mechanism. For example, a game may have all 7s and 8s yet a 10 for tilt. That game will not get a AAA rating, yet deep down the reviewer knows it should despite its technical shortcomings. Unfortunately that can't be changed as tilt doesn't go up to 11 or 12. This is an area where the system is flawed, and needs adjusting for greater effect.

Putting a set value on other scoring areas is also flawed. Some people look for excellent sound design in a game over stunning graphics, so which area should then be weighted more heavily? This is the reason why rhythm games are often under-scored in my opinion..

 

-Spock-

GS would become 1up if they started to review the game only on Tilt . Prid3r

True..

The only part of the review that should count is gamer's tilt. But that is what I believe.

nextgengaming18

We all know that the review system work that way.

I just want for them to use the same review card for Filmspot!
Willy105