GOTY (Game of the Year)

bioshock wont cut it against lpb, fallout.

at the moment the contenders are gta4, mgs4

I think GTA IV is gonna win GOTY, Gears 2 will be my GOTY.

I think GTA IV is gonna win GOTY, Gears 2 will be my GOTY.

EuroMafia

Damn right, can't wait for Gears...that game is gonna OWN!!!

You didn't put GTA4 or MGS4 on your poll but a BioShock port and Resistance 2 are up there?

Come on now. :|

how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?mephisto_11

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

Resistance2 has it all story tons of content and upgrades bigger co-op and massive WAR in multiplayer. And has a far better chance then gears of battle.killzowned24

Actions speak louder than words.

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?Djmaster214

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

Has Resistance 2 been made available to the general public? Do we have knowledge of its chances at GOTY?

Resistance2 has it all story tons of content and upgrades bigger co-op and massive WAR in multiplayer. And has a far better chance then gears of battle.killzowned24

Yeah....no.

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?Djmaster214

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

last i checked neither is resistance 2, fallout or lbp

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

[QUOTE="Djmaster214"]

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?mephisto_11

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

last i checked neither is resistance 2, fallout or lbp

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"][QUOTE="Djmaster214"]

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?Sony-tha-champ0

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

last i checked neither is resistance 2, fallout or lbp

What's your point?

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

Sony-tha-champ0

As stated by critics, Grand Theft Auto IV pulls Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots to pieces.

[QUOTE="Sony-tha-champ0"]

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

WhenTheTwoFace

As stated by critics, Grand Theft Auto IV pulls Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots to pieces.

GTA was a letdown,and sides we dont know who is GOTY...yet

[QUOTE="Sony-tha-champ0"]

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

WhenTheTwoFace

As stated by critics, Grand Theft Auto IV pulls Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots to pieces.

lol? Given that MGS4 came out AFTER GTA4 and still got a 10 I think your mixing things, IGN even said they'd give MGS4 an 11 if they could.

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"][QUOTE="Djmaster214"]

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?Sony-tha-champ0

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

last i checked neither is resistance 2, fallout or lbp

ign gave folklore a 9. and r1 and uncharted 9.1

"After I saw Gears of War 2 I headed over to the Sony booth and sat down with Resistance 2 on PS3. It just came across as boring after Gears."

http://www.8bitjoystick.com/archives/jake_pax_08_gears_of_war_2_for_xbox_360_hands_on_impressions.php

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"][QUOTE="Djmaster214"]

[QUOTE="mephisto_11"]how can you put resistance 2 in that list and lbp (barely AAA) and not have gears 2 (sequel to a GOTY)?Sony-tha-champ0

becuase its not out and you dont know if its goty material?

last i checked neither is resistance 2, fallout or lbp

Yeah but this Gamespot. I'm pretty sure they have different views on what games are "GOTY material."

[QUOTE="WhenTheTwoFace"][QUOTE="Sony-tha-champ0"]

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

Sony-tha-champ0

As stated by critics, Grand Theft Auto IV pulls Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots to pieces.

GTA was a letdown,and sides we dont know who is GOTY...yet

"GTA was a letdown"

According to you? Fascinating in a high degree.

"and sides we dont know who is GOTY...yet"

I agree.

[QUOTE="WhenTheTwoFace"][QUOTE="Sony-tha-champ0"]

MGS4 is for now GOTY,since LBP didnt quite impress GS as MGS4 did,MGS4>GTA4>other Nominated games

Eddie-Vedder

As stated by critics, Grand Theft Auto IV pulls Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots to pieces.

lol? Given that MGS4 came out AFTER GTA4 and still got a 10 I think your mixing things, IGN even said they'd give MGS4 an 11 if they could.

Does that change the fact that Grand Theft Auto IV tears Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots into small pieces, according to critics? "Given that MGS4 came out AFTER GTA4 and still got a 10" I am aware of that. "IGN even said they'd give MGS4 an 11 if they could." I have knowledge of that, as well.

Bioshock? No Gears 2? No GTAIV? No MGS4???

My nominations are GTAIV, MGS4, LBP, Gears 2, and possibly Resistance 2 or Fallout 3.

That list is full of fail. No GTA4 or MGS4, and you put Bioshock, a year old game in the list? And I personally think it will go to MGS4.comeonthehoops

Ah man!!! Your sig picture is awesome!!! I watched that part of that episode like at least 30 times. I roll everytime!!!

how did you not put MGS4 up there?Star67

I don't have a PS3 so I can't comment on MGS4 or LBP (really nobody can cuz the game isn't even out yet), but I can say that so far this year from the games i've played I can name whats been the best game, but I don't think its good enough to have the honor of being called "Game of the Year".

I wish they released Mass Effect early 08 instead of late late 07.

It could be any of about 5 games. even 6. No wii games though.Kratos_OMEGA

9.5 is nothing to sneeze at.

Umm..why isn't there Gears Of War 2 up there? Instead you put Resistance 2? :evil:

I would go with Gears Of War 2.

But Gamespot would give it to either GTAIV or MGS4.