gta 4 > mario galaxy. WHAT!!!!!!

can someone explain to me how how gta get 10 and mario only a 9.5. mario might not be the prettiest game, but it surely the most innovative and original game this gen, even if its not, GTA doesnt even touches mario. If mario got a 9.5 then deserve 9.0.

If miyamoto knew that gta was rated higher than mario galaxy in gamespot, it would break his heart.

can someone explain to me how how gta get 10 and mario only a 9.5. mario might not be the prettiest game, but it surely the most innovative and original game this gen, even if its not, GTA doesnt even touches mario. If mario got a 9.5 then deserve 9.0.

If miyamoto knew that gta was rated higher than mario galaxy in gamespot, it would break his heart.

virtuas

Because GTA is a much better game than Super Mario Galaxy. That is why it got a 10 and SMG didnt.

Opinions ftw.

What? WHAT! WHAT! WHAT!? Go ninja, go ninja, GO!ONLYDOD

can someone explain to me how how gta get 10 and mario only a 9.5. mario might not be the prettiest game, but it surely the most innovative and original game this gen, even if its not, GTA doesnt even touches mario. If mario got a 9.5 then deserve 9.0.

If miyamoto knew that gta was rated higher than mario galaxy in gamespot, it would break his heart.

virtuas

1. Standards.
2. Miyamoto probably couldn't care less about Super Mario Galaxy being 9.5 since it also got overall game of the year 2007.

can someone explain to me how how gta get 10 and mario only a 9.5. mario might not be the prettiest game, but it surely the most innovative and original game this gen, even if its not, GTA doesnt even touches mario. If mario got a 9.5 then deserve 9.0.

If miyamoto knew that gta was rated higher than mario galaxy in gamespot, it would break his heart.

virtuas

er wow I guess you've never heard a different opinion to yours before. well hate to say this to you but alot of people enjoyed GTA than stupid mario.

Mario galaxy??? innovate??? LOLZ

its Super Mario 64 wrapped with new graphics, and controls

thats Super Mario Galaxy

GTA4 at least have a descent online

IMO

They're both great games, can we leave like this? Oh, and I think Gamerankings have more credibility when it comes to judging which game is the best.

User based reviews aren't that reliable either, too biased IMO.

It's a .5 difference.

Who cares.

Personally I enjoy SMG more, then again im not a big fan of the GTA games, but I can see why it recieved a 10.
Haziqonfire

I totally agree with you.

While I'm not sure if GTA4 deserves a 10 since I'm only a quarter of the way through it, I do feel like that SMG is completely overrated at a 9.5 and GTA4 is a better game.

As someone else said, opinions FTW.

(Just as an aside, I don't think SMG is a bad game- just overrated)

We all have different opinions. They're both amazing games and whoever says otherwise... well, has a different opinion.;)

I agree with you but we dont write the reviews. I never played a GTA game for more than 10 minutes because the plot is laughable and the quests all seem so similar.

Mario galaxy had some really unique level design, amazing visuals and one of the greatest game soundtracks ever.

Because GTA is a much better game than Super Mario Galaxy. That is why it got a 10 and SMG didnt.

Opinions ftw.

AAllxxjjnn

I own both and my Opinion is that SMG > GTA4.

they both were good but neither deserve a AAAA (infact no game deserves it)SAGE_OF_FIRE

In my opinion (again) the only games that deserve 10/10, are....

Super Mario Bros 3
The Secret of Monkey Island

I would recommend those games to anybody until the end of time.

Mario Galaxy is approximately 1 million times greater than GTA 4.

Infact, GTA 4 is quite possibly the biggest letdown in the history of this Earth.

But theres no question, San Andreas > Mario Galaxy > Gta4

GTA IV >>> Mario

FACT!!!