How many multiplat games have come out same day 360/PS3 and PS3 scored better?

I am just wondering how many games there has been that a game for the PS3 and the 360 that came out the same day but the PS3 version scored better? I am not talking about other websites either. It is easy to find any info you want if you go from site to site.

If there is none this is not a flame thread because honestly I do not know.

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened this gen, for any system.

EDIT : I stand Corrected. Half Life 2 : The Orange Box was 9.5 on PC/360 (Although the PS3 version came out on Dec 11th, the 360 version came out OCT 10th, NOT the Same day).

-------------------------------------

THE TALLY SO FAR :

Bionic Commando : Rearmed (360 : 7.5) (PS3 : 8.0)

Tiger Woods Pro 2008 (360 : 6.5) (PS3 : 7.0)

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened, for any system.

SolidTy

only one I can think of is Bionic Commando.

PS3 8.0

X360 7.5

but its just an 'arcade' game, nothing major.

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened, for any system.

SolidTy

The other versions of Orange Box got a 9.5.. so it is the same thing.

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened (This Gen), for any system.

Eltroz

I meant this generation, but I guess the only other one found so far, was Bionic Commando.

only one I can think of is Bionic Commando.

PS3 8.0

X360 7.5

MightyMuna

Thanks for this find. It's an odd but fun question to answer.

[QUOTE="Eltroz"][QUOTE="SolidTy"]

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened (This Gen), for any system.

SolidTy

I meant this generation, but I guess the only other one found so far, was Bionic Commando.

only one I can think of is Bionic Commando.

PS3 8.0

X360 7.5

MightyMuna

Thanks for this find. It's an odd but fun question to answer.

[QUOTE="SolidTy"][QUOTE="Eltroz"][QUOTE="SolidTy"]

I don't think any...

The decision to knock Fallout 3 down .5, was odd, considering that Orange Box suffered last year, and got a 9.

It's probably the only time this has happened (This Gen), for any system.

Eltroz

I meant this generation, but I guess the only other one found so far, was Bionic Commando.

only one I can think of is Bionic Commando.

PS3 8.0

X360 7.5

MightyMuna

Thanks for this find. It's an odd but fun question to answer.

Sort of, Orange Box wasn't a same day release. EA had to make it, and it was like a month later for PS3, if memory serves me. I only brought it up because of the Fallout Score Variance, not because it was shipped same day.

EDIT : Orange Box OCT 10th on 360, December 11th on PS3.

--------------------------------

So, just onemore found, so far it seems.

Bionic Commando : Rearmed. (PS3 8.0) (360 : 7.5)

As others say, BC : Rearmed.

Not sure about retail though.

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

Hmmm...This thread took an interesting turn. I thought it was doomed to page 1.

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

user_nat

[QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

angelkimne

Dang, like Orange Box, it doesn't count then.

EDIT : Just checked, but WHAT THE?...Did I read that right? I checked and it said the same day! :(

I thought you would check before posting? Is it me? Am I too tired to read?

[QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

angelkimne

[QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

Eltroz

Yeah, exactly. I went to check the score, but didn't look at that date. D'oh! :P

[QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

Eltroz

Orange Box 360 - Oct 2007

Orange Box PS3 - Dec 2007

2 months

[QUOTE="Eltroz"][QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

MightyMuna

Orange Box 360 - Aug 2007

Orange Box PS3 - Dec 2007

2 months

You mean OCT, not AUGUST.

[QUOTE="MightyMuna"][QUOTE="Eltroz"][QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

SolidTy

Orange Box 360 - Aug 2007

Orange Box PS3 - Dec 2007

2 months

You mean OCT, not AUGUST.

Edited. lol, thanks.

[QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

angelkimne

Just curious, what are you smoking? I want some, 'cause I'm drowsy!

How did you get those dates? Maybe I'm too sleepy, but I think you are wrong.

[QUOTE="Eltroz"][QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="user_nat"]

Tiger Woods 08.

6.5 360

7.0 PS3

MightyMuna

Orange Box 360 - Aug 2007

Orange Box PS3 - Dec 2007

2 months

Dang touchy. Like I said same day release so does not matter anyways. I was pointing out if one mattered then so does this. I did not bother looking at the dates because like SolidTY pointed out at the start they came at a different time. Also like he pointed out one month not 2 :PEltroz

Just for the record, I guessed. :P I bought it on 360, and My brother got it on PS3, in what seemed like a month later.

Anyways, Tiger Woods Does Check out, I don't know what's going on With Angel....

the point is, for the PS3 version to be same/better than the 360 version, PS3 has to be the lead version or be released later (with the exception of Orange Box). games like Burnout, Soul Calibur IV, DMC 4, Tiger 08, Oblivion, and soon to be Alone in the Dark: Inferno, were developed on PS3 first or were released later. thats they are the same or betteron PS3.

if its developed simultaneously with 360, there is a very good chance that the 360 version will be better.

With Tiger Woods 08, the games were released on the same day in North America, but the PS3 version was later elsewhere. So as far as reviews go they were on the same day.

Another game I was able to find with different scores on the same day is Need for Speed Carbon (again North America only). 7.6 360, 7.4 PS3.

Tony Hawks Project 8 also has different scores, PS3 7.3 360 7.9. But the PS3 version was released one week later.

Both THP8 and NFS Carbon were PS3 launch titles though.

I don't think there is any.

I don't think there is any.

epic_pets

I've been where you've been, and I said exactly what you said. However, that 1st page is a doozy, check it out!

[QUOTE="Eltroz"] Dang touchy. Like I said same day release so does not matter anyways. I was pointing out if one mattered then so does this. I did not bother looking at the dates because like SolidTY pointed out at the start they came at a different time. Also like he pointed out one month not 2 :PSolidTy

Just for the record, I guessed. :P I bought it on 360, and My brother got it on PS3, in what seemed like a month later.

Anyways, Tiger Woods Does Check out, I don't know what's going on With Angel....

But they must only be for UK.

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

[QUOTE="Eltroz"] Dang touchy. Like I said same day release so does not matter anyways. I was pointing out if one mattered then so does this. I did not bother looking at the dates because like SolidTY pointed out at the start they came at a different time. Also like he pointed out one month not 2 :Pangelkimne

Just for the record, I guessed. :P I bought it on 360, and My brother got it on PS3, in what seemed like a month later.

Anyways, Tiger Woods Does Check out, I don't know what's going on With Angel....

But they must only be for UK.

Yeah, you UK guys have a lot going on over there with funny dates. Remember that one game with that one funny date? Ah, well. :)

the point is, for the PS3 version to be same/better than the 360 version, PS3 has to be the lead version or be released later (with the exception of Orange Box). games like Burnout, Soul Calibur IV, DMC 4, Tiger 08, Oblivion, and soon to be Alone in the Dark: Inferno, were developed on PS3 first or were released later. thats they are the same or betteron PS3.

if its developed simultaneously with 360, there is a very good chance that the 360 version will be better.

MightyMuna

Oblivion????