i believe gs was wrong about tp

i believe it deserved an 8.2

now before you start flaming me, let me give my thoughts, then you may flameme!;)

1. the wiimote controls were tacked on, gave no real value

2. the gameplay was too similar to oot's, and felt less engaging for some odd reason

3. the puzzles lacked intuity, and were a chore to get through (mostly), except the "action" puzzles were sorta fun

4. stupid, fetch quest twilight missions

5. gameplay was ridiculously easy

6. mostly boring boss fights, again too easy

7. repetitive in numerous ways

as a zelda fan since i beat a link to the past, then beat the legend of zelda, oot, majoras mask, a link to the past gba edition, couldnt force myself to finish the second one though, i was sorely disappointed

I believe you are a bit late to the party.flintgijoe

i believe it deserved an 8.2

now before you start flaming me, let me give my thoughts, then you may flameme!;)

1. the wiimote controls were tacked on, gave no real value *yet in a direct comparison.....Jeff prefered the wii controls, and the wiihas the best version tag*

2. the gameplay was too similar to oot's, and felt less engaging for some odd reason *same could be said for many sequals*

3. the puzzles lacked intuity, and were a chore to get through (mostly), except the "action" puzzles were sorta fun *once again even Jeff comments the cleverly designed puzzles*

4. stupid, fetch quest twilight missions *none of which are as horrible as that triforce fetch quest in the wind waker*

5. gameplay was ridiculously easy *yet still harder than the wind waker and minish cap*

6. mostly boring boss fights, again too easy *^look at my previous point although the bosses were about equal with the WW difficulty wise*

7. repetitive in numerous ways *same could be said for OOT, MM, hell any zelda! You find a dungeon, you beat a dungeon, you get the item*

as a zelda fan since i beat a link to the past, then beat the legend of zelda, oot, majoras mask, a link to the past gba edition, couldnt force myself to finish the second one though, i was sorely disappointed.

mestizoman

[QUOTE="mestizoman"]

i believe it deserved an 8.2

now before you start flaming me, let me give my thoughts, then you may flameme!;)

1. the wiimote controls were tacked on, gave no real value*yet in a direct comparason.....Jeff prefered thewii controls, and the wiihas the best version tag*

2. the gameplay was too similar to oot's, and felt less engaging for some odd reason*same could be said for many sequals*

3. the puzzles lacked intuity, and were a chore to get through (mostly), except the "action" puzzles were sorta fun

4. stupid, fetch quest twilight missions*none of which are as horrible as that triforce fetch quest in the wind waker*

5. gameplay was ridiculously easy*yet still harder than the wind waker*

6. mostly boring boss fights, again too easy*^look at my previous point although the bosses were about equal with the WW difficulty wise*

7. repetitive in numerous ways*same could be said for OOT, MM, hell any zelda! You find a dungeon, you beat a dungeon, you get the item*

as a zelda fan since i beat a link to the past, then beat the legend of zelda, oot, majoras mask, a link to the past gba edition, couldnt force myself to finish the second one though, i was sorely disappointed.

Shinobishyguy

i played for about 2min in a local gamestop

and dont most fans disown that game anyway?????

read the first one.. And really... The controller does not affect vaue, it affects gameplay..

SO please. atleast post intelligent reasons.. Also explain why it is bad.. Or it is just retarded..

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="mestizoman"]

i believe it deserved an 8.2

now before you start flaming me, let me give my thoughts, then you may flameme!;)

1. the wiimote controls were tacked on, gave no real value*yet in a direct comparason.....Jeff prefered thewii controls, and the wiihas the best version tag*

2. the gameplay was too similar to oot's, and felt less engaging for some odd reason*same could be said for many sequals*

3. the puzzles lacked intuity, and were a chore to get through (mostly), except the "action" puzzles were sorta fun

4. stupid, fetch quest twilight missions*none of which are as horrible as that triforce fetch quest in the wind waker*

5. gameplay was ridiculously easy*yet still harder than the wind waker*

6. mostly boring boss fights, again too easy*^look at my previous point although the bosses were about equal with the WW difficulty wise*

7. repetitive in numerous ways*same could be said for OOT, MM, hell any zelda! You find a dungeon, you beat a dungeon, you get the item*

as a zelda fan since i beat a link to the past, then beat the legend of zelda, oot, majoras mask, a link to the past gba edition, couldnt force myself to finish the second one though, i was sorely disappointed.

mestizoman

iplayed for about 2min in a local gamestop

and dont most fans disown that game anyway?????

While some people prefer TP to WW and vice versa, it was still a surperb experience just like the other entries.

read the first one.. And really... The controller does not affect vaue, it affects gameplay..

SO please. atleast post intelligent reasons.. Also explain why it is bad.. Or it is just retarded..

omgimba

i meant it served no useful purpose!!!!!!! did nothing to better the game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think GS should move to multiple scores for different groups and not just one score. To previous fans -9.5. To others - 7.0.Lazy_Boy88

You do know that the reason for JEff giving TP such a low score was because it did nothing new from the other zelda games.. Meaning that the game would actully get a way better score for others....

But you are probably to narrowsighted to realize that even after I point it out.

[QUOTE="omgimba"]

read the first one.. And really... The controller does not affect vaue, it affects gameplay..

SO please. atleast post intelligent reasons.. Also explain why it is bad.. Or it is just retarded..

mestizoman

i meant it served no useful purpose!!!!!!! did nothing to better the game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Let it go. Please just let it go.

Not many people care anymore. GS gave it 8.8. You give it 8.2. It seems you've discovered opinion. Write your own review now.

[QUOTE="omgimba"]

read the first one.. And really... The controller does not affect vaue, it affects gameplay..

SO please. atleast post intelligent reasons.. Also explain why it is bad.. Or it is just retarded..

mestizoman

i meant it served no useful purpose!!!!!!! did nothing to better the game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Could you explain a lil more why it did not add anything, and why that would be a bad thing (If the Gameplay would have been perfectfor the gamecube (Hypotheticly, can't spell, I know.), why would it then deserve a lesser score for the eventhough the gameplay was still perfect?)