This topic is locked from further discussion.
Would it be surprising? They gave out 2 perfect 10s in 2 months. GTA probably deserved it but no way MGS4 does. degeneraz
i'm guessing you haven't played mgs4 then
[QUOTE="degeneraz"]Would it be surprising? They gave out 2 perfect 10s in 2 months. GTA probably deserved it but no way MGS4 does. piano_pimp
i'm guessing you haven't played mgs4 then
No he's right. No way did that game deserve a perfect 10. Not to say it's not a good game, but it was far from perfect. GTA4 as well for that matter.
Back to the subject at hand, I doubt it'll get a perfect score as well. RE4 didn't get one and RE5 looks like it's going to be pretty much the exact same thing.
I don't think it deserves a 10, simply because what it's doing has already been done before, and it isn't improving the series in a meaningful way.
Resident Evil 5 will no doubt be more fun than Resident Evil 4, but the latter deserves the "prime" score more for what it did at the time.
It could. I see no reason why it wouldn't, except RE5 is just RE4 with great graphics and a new storyline. That might bring it down half a notch.dream431casame goes for GTA4...and that game went UP in score (which it shouldn't have IMO)
9.0-9.5 most likely. I don't see it outscoring RE4 because RE4 had that wow factor. RE5 looks like RE4 with better graphics.chansaet
I still have a feeling GameSpot would give it a 10, though. I think Grand Theft Auto III was a hell of a lot more groundbreaking than IV, and the sequel still somehow managed to get a 10.
III changed the formula of the series completely and got a 9.6 IV didn't add as many new things and got a 10.
Resident Evil 4 also changed the formula of the series completely and got a 9.6. What will 5 get?
In GTAIV the story was more serious and everything was much more realistic. They took out anything that wasn't realistic enough (flamethrowers, Jetpacks, Katanas) to make the game feel a lot more realistic. I didn't think it deserved a 10 but they did change more than just graphics._Zac_which sucked because flamethrower was totally FTW!!! since maybe the flamethrower is gonna be in COD5...maybe GTA5 (or a spinoff type name) will put it back in
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment