if duke nukem forever even does get relesed what score would you expect for it

with a game that has been in development for over a decade i expect this game to be huge. i mean AAAA huge, but i seriously dout it would be that good i dont think it would even be a AAA. I have a fealing its going to be the biggest flop of all time.

It be another 2-Human most likely.

I think almost every one would be prepared to give it a fair go. I mean expectations for this game are actually so low that if it actually were quite decent I think it would get some good reviews. If howeverif it is crap... well be prepared for the duke to beshredded to bits.

none the less I would buy it in any case

Honestly, its release would be such a miracle that no matter what the content of the actual game was, it would warrant a 10.5

A 10. It's gonna be the GOTY 1999. Oh, wait.......

If it actually gets finished, I could see it easily scoring 8.5-9.0. From what I saw of the leaked video, there was very high production values going into it and it seemed like it maintained the old-school shooter gameplay which we haven't seen in at least a decade. If its Duke Nukem 3D in a modern engine, it will do very well.

0/10

i would probley buy it out of pure curosity even if it gets a terriable scoreEmperorZeruel

Yeah I would totally "buy" it :P

this game owns anything on the market pretty much

5, it will be a mediocre/ poor game, it would have to be hilariously funny to get anything. if you take too long on a game the times change, and you just can't keep up. you have to pretty much change the gameplay every year to keep up to date, while developing new ideas.

look at chinese democracy it was nothing on past guns n roses albums, it was a horrible mash of all popular rock music since the 90's.

If it actually gets finished, I could see it easily scoring 8.5-9.0. From what I saw of the leaked video, there was very high production values going into it and it seemed like it maintained the old-school shooter gameplay which we haven't seen in at least a decade. If its Duke Nukem 3D in a modern engine, it will do very well.

foxhound_fox

this sums up my point perfectly, old school gameplay from the 90's, there's a reason we don't still have gameplay from the 90's, because it's outdated.

TC did you make this thread in response to Yatzee's "review" of the game?

And yes I'm captain obvious (not a sig)

It won't get a score because it's never getting released, hence the title Forever.

It won't get a score because it's never getting released, hence the title Forever.

Gxgear

4.5

When its released it will just be a rushed EA game...

6.5..

this sums up my point perfectly, old school gameplay from the 90's, there's a reason we don't still have gameplay from the 90's, because it's outdated.Mckenna1845

[QUOTE="Mckenna1845"]this sums up my point perfectly, old school gameplay from the 90's, there's a reason we don't still have gameplay from the 90's, because it's outdated.foxhound_fox

i guess if you prefer shooters like doom then this game would appeal to you. i just don't think doom measures up to anything, in it's day it would have been great but now i think it's mostly nostalgia. you walk around corridors, with the inability to look around, and shoot sprites that pop up in front of you. i agree that there is a market for more retro feeling fps games, but to mimic their gameplay is a horible idea.

Mckenna1845

From what I've seen minus the Too-Human-like blind hate I say a 7.5 on GS, and I'd still get and play the game happily.

Anything less than a 9 is fail since it took so darn long.

The thing is the game would not even have to be good for it to sell. I don't understand how such a powerful franchise like Duke Nuken can go over a decade without releasing a true succesor (none of this spin off crap). People would buy a Duke Nukem game in the millions even if it sucked... the devs are dumb for not releasing anything...

7.0 maybe 8.0

[QUOTE="Mckenna1845"]i guess if you prefer shooters like doom then this game would appeal to you. i just don't think doom measures up to anything, in it's day it would have been great but now i think it's mostly nostalgia. you walk around corridors, with the inability to look around, and shoot sprites that pop up in front of you. i agree that there is a market for more retro feeling fps games, but to mimic their gameplay is a horible idea.

foxhound_fox

I disagree completely. Technology is used to better engage the player. The focus on realism improves the game immensely for me. I have tried my hardest to go back and play the oldies. I can't, Im to young, I have no connection to them. I played half-life and found it very engaging and I was loving it, until I was actually supposed to fire weapons. I was kicked out of the games brilliant atmosphere by out-dated gunplay.

But it's all opinion I guess. But for some (Dare I say most) technology can on average equal a better game.

10. The duke is here to kick ass and chew bubblegum, and he's all out of gum...

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

[QUOTE="Mckenna1845"]i guess if you prefer shooters like doom then this game would appeal to you. i just don't think doom measures up to anything, in it's day it would have been great but now i think it's mostly nostalgia. you walk around corridors, with the inability to look around, and shoot sprites that pop up in front of you. i agree that there is a market for more retro feeling fps games, but to mimic their gameplay is a horible idea.

hip-hop-cola2

I disagree completely. Technology is used to better engage the player. The focus on realism improves the game immensely for me. I have tried my hardest to go back and play the oldies. I can't, Im to young, I have no connection to them. I played half-life and found it very engaging and I was loving it, until I was actually supposed to fire weapons. I was kicked out of the games brilliant atmosphere by out-dated gunplay.

But it's all opinion I guess. But for some (Dare I say most) technology can on average equal a better game.

You're both right. Graphics can enhance a gaming experience and most modern FPS have done nothing to progress core FPS gameplay (ie boring).