IGN failed hard(concerning Uncharted/mario galaxy)

I didn't notice 'til today, but Uncharted has a 9.0 on graphics, and Mario Galaxy has a 9.5.

That's just horrible, I don't really care if it's the Wii, Mario Galaxy does not deserve over a 9 on graphics. ANd Uncharted should have gotten 9.5/10 on graphics.

http://wii.ign.com/articles/833/833298p4.html

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834931p2.html

They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.darklord888

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

hurts, doesnt it? mr. cowaxes03

a bit, wii art style is so nice, but graphics wise it may be these ps360 eyes of mine playing tricks but they suck.

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Out_Kast3000

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

No, you aren't.

You are reviewing a WII game, so you deal with WII's capabilities, and compare them to how well other games on Wii perform. Kind of like how PC has a different standard.

[QUOTE="axes03"]hurts, doesnt it? mr. cowFF-resevil-halo

a bit, wii art style is so nice, but graphics wise it may be these ps360 eyes of mine playing tricks but they suck.

I retract that statement, the wii graphics are fine but I am a little hurt I wish that uncharted had gotten a 9.5 for graphics though okay

The graphics had technical problems... obviously they are going to mark it down. Mario Galaxy is by far the best looking Wii-game... duh its going to get a high score.

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Out_Kast3000

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

Then Uncharted should get a 7 or 7.5 because it looks like crap compared to Crysis.

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Out_Kast3000

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Out_Kast3000

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.darklord888

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

does that mean mario galaxy gets like a 4?

Uncharted's graphics are a 7 compared to Crysis? LOL, no.

Anyway, A PC/Console comparison is NOT the same as a Console/Console comparison.

Uncharted's graphics are a 7 compared to Crysis? LOL, no.

Anyway, A PC/Console comparison is NOT the same as a Console/Console comparison.

Out_Kast3000

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Nickman71

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

Then Uncharted should get a 7 or 7.5 because it looks like crap compared to Crysis.

it doesnt look like crap compared to crysis. sure, its not as good, but it still looks damn good, itsphoto realistic(uncharted is).

[QUOTE="Nickman71"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Paper_Knife

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

Then Uncharted should get a 7 or 7.5 because it looks like crap compared to Crysis.

it doesnt look like crap compared to crysis. sure, its not as good, but it still looks damn good, itsphoto realistic(uncharted is).

Then you haven't seen the latest sandbox editor screens from Crysis.

Uncharted's graphics are a 7 compared to Crysis? LOL, no.

Anyway, A PC/Console comparison is NOT the same as a Console/Console comparison.

Out_Kast3000

I meant all console games obviously. Out_Kast3000

We aren't supposed to read your mind.

OBVIOUSLY OMGFGGJFDH

You're annoying, you troll and troll and then when you get owned and say "OBVIOUSLY I WUZ TALKIN BOUT ________"

IGN did not fail. You did.

FISSION MAILED.

[QUOTE="Nickman71"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

[QUOTE="darklord888"]They're on different systems with different power.

A 9 on the PS3 would be like a 12 on the Wii.Paper_Knife

Still doesn't matter. You aren't comparing Super Mario Galaxy to games on the Wii, you're comparing them to all the games out.

Then Uncharted should get a 7 or 7.5 because it looks like crap compared to Crysis.

it doesnt look like crap compared to crysis. sure, its not as good, but it still looks damn good, itsphoto realistic(uncharted is).

graphics include artstyle, don't they? and SMG's art design/style is some of the best around.

Plus; technical scores must be considered with respect to their system.. why is this not common knowledge?

:lol: these cows are FURIOUS :lol:

mario galaxy outscores the entire PS3 exclusive lineup - not just at gamepsot, but on pretty much every review site out there

it'll outsell the entire PS3 exclusive lineup too

let it burn

This thread is made of fanboy ownage, and fanboy damage control. I like it :D.

Uncharted's graphics are a 7 compared to Crysis? LOL, no.

Anyway, A PC/Console comparison is NOT the same as a Console/Console comparison.

Out_Kast3000

yeah your right, it should be a 6, crysis is beautiful.

I find it funny that people are actually trying to argue that Mario Galaxy actually deserved a 9.5 when Uncharted got a 9. It's stupid, and there's really no reason for me to go on in here because the people I'm talking to have 0 idea what they're talking about.

kthxbi

Out_Kast3000

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I find it funny that people are actually trying to argue that Mario Galaxy actually deserved a 9.5 when Uncharted got a 9. It's stupid, and there's really no reason for me to go on in here because the people I'm talking to have 0 idea what they're talking about.

kthxbi

Ibacai

I think he is a troll cause he has Cedmin in his avatar

[QUOTE="Ibacai"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I find it funny that people are actually trying to argue that Mario Galaxy actually deserved a 9.5 when Uncharted got a 9. It's stupid, and there's really no reason for me to go on in here because the people I'm talking to have 0 idea what they're talking about.

kthxbi

Big_Gamer_Al

I think he is a troll cause he has Cedmin in his avatar

Cedmin? WTF is that?

My icon is Andre 3000.

Anyway, how do you lock threads? This isn't going anywhere and I've made my point so It might as well be deleted.

I find it funny that people are actually trying to argue that Mario Galaxy actually deserved a 9.5 when Uncharted got a 9. It's stupid, and there's really no reason for me to go on in here because the people I'm talking to have 0 idea what they're talking about.

kthxbi

Out_Kast3000