In terms of fun, SMG better than Brawl?

Well, I just got into an argument with a friend of mine about Galaxy being more fun than Brawl because of it's uniqueness and Galaxy will last longer than Brawl. Brawl will be played a lot more than Galaxy, we know that, and will be great.

"Brawl will be played a lot more than Galaxy, and will be great, but the short time that Galaxy lasted will be better than Brawl. Brawl = Melee plus. Great but not unique enough.

Galaxy which has more unique gameplay, and is a lot of fun, but for a limited amount of time.

Or Brawl, which is like an expansion of Melee. Not making a huge change like Galaxy, but making a lot of smaller improvements in different areas, and more replay value."

personally I think a game doesn't have to be uber unique to be fun, it doesn't mean nothing if it's not fun. I'm with Brawl when it comes to being more fun.

In terms of pure fun,
nothing beats Brawl with a room full of your friends going at eachother.

SMG is great as a single player experience.

Just so people know, I'm the one who he originally talked to about this.

I personally don't think that a game doesn't have to be unique to be great, and I don't think it has to have a lot of replay value as long as what's there is great enough to leave a good impression. But I think that if it's unique, and the things that make it unique are great enough, then that adds a lot more than replay value in a game that is great, but not really unique. I had a lot of fun with Galaxy, and I think that the short time that Galaxy lasted will feel better than Brawl will feel during the years that I play it. Not that it won't be great, but I think it won't be as great as Galaxy is.

In terms of pure fun,
nothing beats Brawl with a room full of your friends going at eachother.

SMG is great as a single player experience.

Andrew_Xavier

good point, that's exactly what i tred to tell him, but no :roll:

Shouldn't both games be released before arguing about them?

7CloudStrife7

With most games that's true, but with this game, it's Melee plus. We already know what to expect, especially with the updates on Dojo.

Shouldn't both games be released before arguing about them?

7CloudStrife7

[QUOTE="7CloudStrife7"]

Shouldn't both games be released before arguing about them?

Hungry_Homer111

With most games that's true, but with this game, it's Melee plus. We already know what to expect, especially with the updates on Dojo.

There's a difference between looking at a website and playing the game.He's right,let's come back to this argument when Brawl is out.

[QUOTE="Hungry_Homer111"][QUOTE="7CloudStrife7"]

Shouldn't both games be released before arguing about them?

789shadow

With most games that's true, but with this game, it's Melee plus. We already know what to expect, especially with the updates on Dojo.

There's a difference between looking at a website and playing the game.He's right,let's come back to this argument when Brawl is out.

if that's how everybody feels, then I'm ok with it, im pretty sure there's more to Brawl than what the site shows

In terms of pure fun,
nothing beats Brawl with a room full of your friends going at eachother.

SMG is great as a single player experience.

Andrew_Xavier

QFT, even if there both nintendo and both have mario, there 2 compleatly different genres and experiances. although i'm personaly with brawl as the multiplayer fun is spreading across the globe :p

In multiplayer fun, no. Playing a Smash Bros. game with your friends is just awesome and fun. SMG, can be more fun in Single Player though.

brawl looks like its going to be a step down from melee in terms of gameplay speed. it doesnt seem frantic and fast paced enough compared to melee.JPOBS

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]brawl looks like its going to be a step down from melee in terms of gameplay speed. it doesnt seem frantic and fast paced enough compared to melee.nintendofreak_2

possibly. i hope advanced techs are discovered which increase gameplay speed when utilized. wavedash :(
JPOBS

They are both fun.

But Super Mario Galaxy may only last like one or two years. Brawl will last you the whole generation.

http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYQTuHCKQs

doesn't look slow paced to me.

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]possibly. i hope advanced techs are discovered which increase gameplay speed when utilized. wavedash :(
nintendofreak_2

Cool!

They are about to punch you, and you punch him instead in mid air!

I hope they have slow motion.

http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYQTuHCKQs

doesn't look slow paced to me.

Shinobishyguy

[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="JPOBS"]brawl looks like its going to be a step down from melee in terms of gameplay speed. it doesnt seem frantic and fast paced enough compared to melee.JPOBS

What's wavedashing?

[QUOTE="JPOBS"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="JPOBS"]brawl looks like its going to be a step down from melee in terms of gameplay speed. it doesnt seem frantic and fast paced enough compared to melee.Willy105

What's wavedashing?

Better link.

Well, I just got into an argument with a friend of mine about Galaxy being more fun than Brawl because of it's uniqueness and Galaxy will last longer than Brawl. Brawl will be played a lot more than Galaxy, we know that, and will be great.

"Brawl will be played a lot more than Galaxy, and will be great, but the short time that Galaxy lasted will be better than Brawl. Brawl = Melee plus. Great but not unique enough.

Galaxy which has more unique gameplay, and is a lot of fun, but for a limited amount of time.

Or Brawl, which is like an expansion of Melee. Not making a huge change like Galaxy, but making a lot of smaller improvements in different areas, and more replay value."

personally I think a game doesn't have to be uber unique to be fun, it doesn't mean nothing if it's not fun. I'm with Brawl when it comes to being more fun.

IppaiMetaru

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYQTuHCKQs

doesn't look slow paced to me.

nintendofreak_2

that was how many years ago :|

before we saw any actual in game ameplay footage

for all we know they could've changed their minds

What's wavedashing?

Willy105

You jump, then air dodge immediately to the ground. The result is that you slide along the floor seemlessly and can launch any attack you please from it. It the most abused/useful technique in the game. watch any pro match, it is done constantly and its so effective, it basically voids the need to dash/run.

[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYQTuHCKQs

doesn't look slow paced to me.

Shinobishyguy

that was how many years ago :|

before we saw any actual in game ameplay footage

for all we know they could've changed their minds

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYQTuHCKQs

doesn't look slow paced to me.

JPOBS

that was how many years ago :|

before we saw any actual in game ameplay footage

for all we know they could've changed their minds

certainly not as slow as the n64 smash

In terms of pure fun,
nothing beats Brawl with a room full of your friends going at eachother.

SMG is great as a single player experience.

Andrew_Xavier