Is GeoW a classic?

do you see yourself playing it 15 years from now and still saying: Damn this game is a masterpiece. SuperMario_46

I mean the game has great scores everywhere (I personally never played the SP only MP), and it has good gameplay but for those who have play it like thousand times is the game so good to be considered a classic game, you know like OoT that still holds up pretty well after all these years or like AlttP,RE4, GoWand Halo, do you see yourself playing it 15 years from now and still saying: Damn this game is a masterpiece. SuperMario_46

I think it's a classic just for the fact that it basically set the graphical median for this generation.

The gameplay is good and it's a great game, but imo it will never be a classic like OoT, Goldeneye, or (especially) Hal: CE.

No, the only classics come from nes and super nes era.

All games after that went 3d and can look extremly dated.

And Zelda OOt is not a classic

I thought GeoW was great and still think it is. The only complaint I have is that the single player was too short. I dont think 15 years to view it as a masterpiece should work that way, though, cause I use to love the original Mario Bros. games but I cant bring myself to play them now. Same goes for FF3 and Pong. I think GeoW is as close to a classic as any other game can be.

Edit: Dont think I'm alone on this, GS scored it a 9.6, just remember that.

[QUOTE="SuperMario_46"]do you see yourself playing it 15 years from now and still saying: Damn this game is a masterpiece. RobbieH1234

Agreed

Not to me.

The game is already stale. On the flipside I can go play Final Fantasy Tactics/Vagrant Story because I consider them classics.

Far from it in my opinion, it's a fun game, possibly one of the best for 360, but it is no OoT.dackchaar

I couldn't have said it better myself :)

I currently do not play any games from 1992, so why would I play any game now, 15 years later.Heil68

Well i still play a lot of Super mario 64 and Wave race 64, and many SNES games like AlttP and Mario world.

its in my top 30 or top 35 games ever

so yeah id say its classic worthy

I currently do not play any games from 1992, so why would I play any game now, 15 years later.Heil68

I was playing a game released in 1991 just yesterday.

No, the only classics come from nes and super nes era.

All games after that went 3d and can look extremly dated.

And Zelda OOt is not a classic

soiguessialive

Yes it is.

I mean the game has great scores everywhere (I personally never played the SP only MP), and it has good gameplay but for those who have play it like thousand times is the game so good to be considered a classic game, you know like OoT that still holds up pretty well after all these years or like AlttP,RE4, GoWand Halo, do you see yourself playing it 15 years from now and still saying: Damn this game is a masterpiece. SuperMario_46

When I first played Geow I thought it was superb, now...it's barely a GOOD game.

I played OOT and I still think of it as 10/10.

Geow = 7/10

Gears is far from memorable, in fact I find it quite forgettable.

No, the only classics come from nes and super nes era.

All games after that went 3d and can look extremly dated.

And Zelda OOt is not a classic

soiguessialive

Blasphemy!

It's a classic example of how NOT to make a game stand the test of time.

I love the game, but that said, I'm not gonna come back to the game in 15 years.