Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?

The PC won it 3 years in a row from 2004-2006.hexashadow13

I still think Mass Effect 2 should have won GOTY. Oh btw PS3 didn't win 3 years in a row.

The PC won it 3 years in a row from 2004-2006.hexashadow13

How does RDR even count.

[QUOTE="hexashadow13"]The PC won it 3 years in a row from 2004-2006.Funconsole

How does RDR even count.

BigDaddyPOLO

How does RDR even count.

BigDaddyPOLO

It won GOTY, and it's on the PS3, like the previous two GOTY winners.

[QUOTE="Funconsole"][QUOTE="hexashadow13"]The PC won it 3 years in a row from 2004-2006.ihsanqueen

How does RDR even count.

BigDaddyPOLO

[QUOTE="BigDaddyPOLO"]

How does RDR even count.

lawlessx

[QUOTE="ihsanqueen"]Well I said console, and PC is not a consolejalexbrown

Well technically he isn't wrong since he claimed it was the 1st console.

PS3 winning GOTY implies that it's an exclusive on the console, if you want to say the first console to have a GOTY on it for three years in a row then yes I guess it did.

So ME2 was a lost exclusive for the 360, but RDR counts as a GOTY for the PS3....makes sense

Does it matter?

RDR doesnt count. its a multiplat. obvious cow is obvious

So ME2 was a lost exclusive for the 360, but RDR counts as a GOTY for the PS3....makes sense

DroidPhysX

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"][QUOTE="ihsanqueen"]Well I said console, and PC is not a consolecloudff7tm

Well technically he isn't wrong since he claimed it was the 1st console.

in which case its no big achievement.

[QUOTE="ihsanqueen"][QUOTE="Funconsole"] There you go /threadjalexbrown

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

[QUOTE="cloudff7tm"]

Well technically he isn't wrong since he claimed it was the 1st console.

FatCatPatRat

in which case its no big achievement.

Yeah, it really isn't.

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"][QUOTE="ihsanqueen"] Well I said console, and PC is not a consolecrimsonsabre

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

[QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"] This is System Wars, not Console Wars. Sorry 'bout that, bro. But it does kind of hurt to be wrong, doesn't it?taterfrickintot

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"][QUOTE="ihsanqueen"] Well I said console, and PC is not a consolecrimsonsabre

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

well the forum is system wars

so technically making console only threads is against the rules.

lol.

[QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"] This is System Wars, not Console Wars. Sorry 'bout that, bro. But it does kind of hurt to be wrong, doesn't it?taterfrickintot

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

no. unless it is intended to.

by your logic if i compare the graphcs between two handhelds, like the ds and psp, consoles and pcs are automatically in the comparison? no.

I still think Mass Effect 2 should have won GOTY. Oh btw PS3 didn't win 3 years in a row.

SwagSurf

[QUOTE="taterfrickintot"][QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

crimsonsabre

no. unless it is intended to.

by your logic if i compare the graphcs between two handhelds, like the ds and psp, consoles and pcs are automatically in the comparison? no.

In theory, you can include consoles and pcs because its system wars. Not handheld wars or console wars

[QUOTE="taterfrickintot"][QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

crimsonsabre

no. unless it is intended to.

by your logic if i compare the graphcs between two handhelds, like the ds and psp, consoles and pcs are automatically in the comparison? no.

Well you may have a point, however what you're forgetting is that multiplats tend to be shared amongst the 360, PS3, AND PC, so ya know, its perfectly ok to bring PC into it.

And I'm almost certain RDR will make its way to the PC.

[QUOTE="taterfrickintot"][QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.

no. unless it is intended to.

by your logic if i compare the graphcs between two handhelds, like the ds and psp, consoles and pcs are automatically in the comparison? no.

The PC is a console now?THe4FIFty

LOL I love how some fanboys are denying that RDR is on PS3 so its a PS3 GoTY too :P.

[QUOTE="THe4FIFty"]The PC is a console now?jalexbrown

LOL I love how some fanboys are denying that RDR is on PS3 so its a PS3 GoTY too :P.

Kashiwaba

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

LOL I love how some fanboys are denying that RDR is on PS3 so its a PS3 GoTY too :P.

dotWithShoes

Yup true both got a GoTY.

LOL I love how some fanboys are denying that RDR is on PS3 so its a PS3 GoTY too :P.

It's too bad I can't play RDR on my 360.

Oh wait

Yeah it´s the first console but not the first system.

[QUOTE="cloudff7tm"]

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"] This is System Wars, not Console Wars. Sorry 'bout that, bro. But it does kind of hurt to be wrong, doesn't it?FatCatPatRat

Well technically he isn't wrong since he claimed it was the 1st console.

in which case its no big achievement.

I don't count multiplats only true exclusives. Next year Sony has a big chance at winning GOTY with its exclusives Infamous 2, Killzone 3 or LBP2 (maybe Resistance 3?). You never know, Gears 3 or Diablo 3 could come in and take GOTY as well.

so just because the ps3 didnt have a good enough exclusive game this year we should count multiplats?

GoW3 simply wasn't good enough to play with the big boys, SMG2, SC2 and ME2

so just because the ps3 didnt have a good enough exclusive game this year we should count multiplats?

GoW3 simply wasn't good enough to play with the big boys, SMG2, SC2 and ME2

Half-Way

Still RDR is on PS3 too or we don't count multiplats as games here on SWs :P.

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

so just because the ps3 didnt have a good enough exclusive game this year we should count multiplats?

GoW3 simply wasn't good enough to play with the big boys, SMG2, SC2 and ME2

Kashiwaba

Still RDR is on PS3 too or we don't count multiplats as games here on SWs :P.

well we obviously do count them, lemmings have been hyping ME2 to mars and back.

Dont get me wrong i have nothing against multiplats myself, but it seems silly to include RDR in the 3 years streak, simply because the streak ended when a xbox360 game got GOTY , and it was RDR.

So thats it? the GS GOTY is RPR? nice i'll make sure i get this game next year for PS3

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

so just because the ps3 didnt have a good enough exclusive game this year we should count multiplats?

GoW3 simply wasn't good enough to play with the big boys, SMG2, SC2 and ME2

Half-Way

Still RDR is on PS3 too or we don't count multiplats as games here on SWs :P.

well we obviously do count them, lemmings have been hyping ME2 to mars and back.

Dont get me wrong i have nothing against multiplats myself, but it seems silly to include RDR in the 3 years streak, simply because the streak ended when a xbox360 game got GOTY , and it was RDR.

Nah its not a big problem GS used to give 2 GoTY awards few years ago one for consoles and another for PC games so now we can consider it like this :P GS gave 2 GoTY awards one for PS3 and another for 360.

(Note: Don't use too much logic in your posts its against SWs rules.)

PS3 didnt win GOTY this year dude, are you mental or something? Not PS3 not Xbox 360, just simply Red Dead Revolution.

First MGS 4, then Demon's Souls and then Red Dead Redemption (although it's a multiplat) I think it's quite an achievement, shame on PC though And for you who said 2010 is the year of Wii, just admit it, 2010 is the year of multiplat (X360/PS3) Is PS3 the first console that ever won GOTY 3 years in a row? And with 2011 looking good for PS3, maybe PS3 will got GOTY in 4 years in a row!!ihsanqueen

[QUOTE="crimsonsabre"]

[QUOTE="jalexbrown"] This is System Wars, not Console Wars. Sorry 'bout that, bro. But it does kind of hurt to be wrong, doesn't it?taterfrickintot

so if i compare graphics between consoles, the pc automatically gets to butt in?

if i compare anything on consoles, the pc automaticallygets to butt in?

listen up, the thread asks "Is the PS3 the 1st console that won GOTY 3 years in a row?"

this is talking about consoles.