Mass Effect 3 vs Gears Of War 3 vs Uncharted 3

who will win?

I can 100% guarantee you have played none of those titles.

If I had to pick one thatlooks the best to me,it'd be a tie between ME3 and GeoW3

I can 100% guarantee you have played none of those titles.

If I had to pick one thatlooks the best to me,it'd be a tie between ME3 and GeoW3

balfe1990

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

I can 100% guarantee you have played none of those titles.

If I had to pick one that looks the best to me,it'd be a tie between ME3 and GeoW3

guildclaws

No, sorry, you haven't played Mass Effect 3 or Gears of War 3.

[QUOTE="guildclaws"]

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

I can 100% guarantee you have played none of those titles.

If I had to pick one that looks the best to me,it'd be a tie between ME3 and GeoW3

balfe1990

No, sorry, you haven't played Mass Effect 3 or Gears of War 3.

[QUOTE="guildclaws"]

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

I can 100% guarantee you have played none of those titles.

If I had to pick one that looks the best to me,it'd be a tie between ME3 and GeoW3

balfe1990

No, sorry, you haven't played Mass Effect 3 or Gears of War 3.

Hard to say, since we haven't played any of them. If you're asking which we think is going to be best, then I'll say Mass Effect 3. It's my most anticipated game. It also doesn't hurt that Mass Effect is an exceptional game and Mass Effect 2 is this gen's best, in my opinion.

This is how i see it:

Skyrim > ME3 > Gears3 = Uncharted3 >>>>> most 2011 games

for me it's

Uncharted 3 > ME3 > Gears 3

In another equation

UC3 + ME3 + GeOW3 = I'm a happy 2011 gamer

Hard to say since none of those are out yet, but I think I'd choose Uncharted 3 for its environments.

This is how it is, and we all know Uncharted 3 will most likely win GOTY 2011:

Uncharted 3>>Mass Effect 3>>>>>>>>>>Gears of War 3

U3 easily. ME3 also is probably going to suffer from lack of polish considering how many games Bioware is developing at the same time and the fact that its only going to be a year and 9+ months between the time of ME2 to ME3. Gears 3....Ill wait and see after the terrible MP component of Gears 2

It's a tie between U3 and ME3. On one hand, U3, in my eyes, is going to have to do a lot in order to surpass the second game. On the other hand, I'm more interested in the story for ME3, where I think the RPG elements are going to be watered down even further.

mass effect 3 will be far greater than either in terms of depth, story, combat and characters.

Meh, all those will be pwnd by Zelda 8)

For me ATM it's much closer then I would have guessed between ME3 & Gears 3 but if I could only choose one... ME3, no doubt.

If we are talking sales then I would say: (1 ME3: Easily because Multi-plat = more sales, (2 GEoW3: Because a more popular franchise and larger fanbase = more sales, (3 Uncharted3: Stellar franchise but still not as popular as GEoW.

This is how it is, and we all know Uncharted 3 will most likely win GOTY 2011:

Uncharted 3>>Mass Effect 3>>>>>>>>>>Gears of War 3

Blazerdt47

No, we don't. We really don't know that.

I'll go with GeoW 3 = Mass Effect 3 > UC3, but it's hard to compare giants like these.

Uncharted 3 > Mass Effect 3 >> Gears 3

I have a feeling it's going to go like this


Most fun= Gears of War 3(4 players co-op man)

Favorite single player experience= Mass Effect 3

Overall which I like more= Uncharted 3

Who knows, Mass effect 3 might surprise me, I'm hoping it does since it's the last game(I think?).

For me it's:

Mass Effect 3 > Gears of War 3 > Uncharted 3.

Mass Effect 3 > Uncharted 3 > Gears of War 3.

That's my guess at this point.

Uncharted 3 > Mass Effect 3 (by a hair)>>>>>>>>>Gears 3

Uncharted 2 was more a highly critically acclaimed tittle than Mass Effect 2 and Gears 2 and ofcourse won more awards + 40 GOTY awards

You can't compare God Effect 3 to everyday shooters.Blixxed

You can't compare God Effect 3 to everyday shooters.Blixxed

Uncharted 3 > Mass Effect 3 (by a hair)>>>>>>>>>Gears 3

Uncharted 2 was more a highly critically acclaimed tittle than Mass Effect 2 and Gears 2 and ofcourse won more awards + 40 GOTY awards

This is how i see it:

Skyrim > ME3 > Gears3 = Uncharted3 >>>>> most 2011 games

I'll probably like ME3 the best. UC3 will be a close second, though.

[QUOTE="tonitorsi"]

Uncharted 3 > Mass Effect 3 (by a hair)>>>>>>>>>Gears 3

Uncharted 2 was more a highly critically acclaimed tittle than Mass Effect 2 and Gears 2 and ofcourse won more awards + 40 GOTY awards

o0HAPPY0o

Dude.. Mass Effect 2 came out this year. It's impossible for it to have more GOTY awards that Uncharted 2 since that came last year.

You can't compare God Effect 3 to everyday shooters.Blixxed

I guess it's Uncharted>Gears>Mass Effect for me. I know Mass Effect is loved by so many people but I honestly couldn't get past the first three hours of the original, it just bored me to much even if it got better. Gears is good but is overrated, the multiplayer just isn't my thing and it's almost common knowledge that Uncharted has better singleplayer so those are my justifications.

[QUOTE="Blixxed"]You can't compare God Effect 3 to everyday shooters.GeneralShowzer

I guess it's Uncharted>Gears>Mass Effect for me. I know Mass Effect is loved by so many people but I honestly couldn't get past the first three hours of the original, it just bored me to much even if it got better. Gears is good but is overrated, the multiplayer just isn't my thing and it's almost common knowledge that Uncharted has better singleplayer so those are my justifications.

funnilov3

Gears will have the most sales, ME3 will be the best

Mass Effect 3 will be the best.

Gears 3 will likely be left behind in the dust by the other 2...

Can't say, but I'm looking forward to Uncharted 3 most though...

I think I'll probably enjoy ME3 more seeing as I prefer RPG type games, although all will no doubt be good games. Doesn't bother me though, I'll be buying all three.

This is how it is, and we all know Uncharted 3 will most likely win GOTY 2011:

Uncharted 3>>Mass Effect 3>>>>>>>>>>Gears of War 3

Blazerdt47