Metal Gear Solid 4 (PS3) vs. Splinter Cell:Conviction (X360)

Two console exclusives containing two of the most well known stealth/spy heroes in gamedom. Which do you think will be the better game?

Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadJayPee89

^ what he says

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadakif22

^ what he says

What they both say ^^

They're completely different games. If Ubi hadn't gone with the "shaking things up a bit" and made every level in Double Agent like the first, it would have been the best stealth action game ever made. Sadly they chose not to, and the resulting "shaking things up" resulted in boringness.

MGS has never let me down. Again though; completely different games. They really shouldn't be compared.

[QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadcarlisledavid79

^ what he said

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^ 

[QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadcarlisledavid79

^ what he says

What they both say ^^

[QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadcarlisledavid79

^ what he says

What they both say ^^

What them 3 said ^^^

Again though; completely different games. They really shouldn't be compared.

Ninja-Vox

[QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadunreal48

^ what he said

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

[QUOTE="unreal48"][QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadFloppy_Jim

^ what he said

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

^^^^^ i cant believe this is even a thread

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"][QUOTE="unreal48"][QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

^ what he said

thageneral3

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

^^^^^ i cant believe this is even a thread

^^^^^^ me neither! MGS!

MGS4 >> SCC.

Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadJayPee89

Ok, yeah I think in recent iterations of the splinter cell franchise, quality has gone down and so I agree MGS4 looks most likely to be the better game.

But do you really need to put /thread? I'm askming as the TC did seem to simply offer a comparison. As it happens, I am very intrigued by splinter cell and the direction it is going. If it can capture the quality of the first, introduce some new gameplay mechanics and implement them well....then maybe they could pull off a better game than MGS4. However, that is quite a challenge.

Basically, if MGS4 get AAA and SC gets low AA, then I'll accept your /thread...fair?

First of all, I think both will be great games. I just think MGS4 will be better, with more replayability and more freedom to the gameplay. MGS4 will also have more bonuses to unlock, as well as secrets to find.

There nothing alike Splinter cell is ALLA stealth MGS is action with stealthy parts

Viva Pintata > MGS1,2,3,4

Conviction will be another Ubisoft game that sounds great in theory and has some good ideas but in the end its going to be another half-assed installment from an average series. Ubisoft does not deliver.NavigatorsGhost

Neither. Both are overrated series.Aljosa23

'nuff said. If i had to pick, i would say SC, but i can't stand to play it more than a couple hours.

things i hate about the MGS is the odd story lines and xmen like characters.

it doesnt fit.

[QUOTE="gatorteen"][QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="thageneral3"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"][QUOTE="unreal48"][QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

^ what he said

bahamut450

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

^^^^^ i cant believe this is even a thread

^^^^^^ me neither! MGS!

^^^^^^^Me neither! MGS FTW

^^^^^^^^MGS4 NO CONTEST

^^^^---- I agree 100%, I'd agree more if it was possible. MGS

[QUOTE="bahamut450"][QUOTE="gatorteen"][QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="thageneral3"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"][QUOTE="unreal48"][QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

^ what he said

EmperorSupreme

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

^^^^^ i cant believe this is even a thread

^^^^^^ me neither! MGS!

^^^^^^^Me neither! MGS FTW

^^^^^^^^MGS4 NO CONTEST

^^^^---- I agree 100%, I'd agree more if it was possible. MGS

^^^^^^What everyone said!

Neither. Both are overrated series.Aljosa23

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]Neither. Both are overrated series.stereointegrity

and you think the people saying MGS4 are any different? I bet most of them haven't even tried a SC game. And even if they didn't they wouldn't want to admit that it's better than a ps3 exclusive game.

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]Neither. Both are overrated series.stereointegrity

[QUOTE="EmperorSupreme"][QUOTE="bahamut450"][QUOTE="gatorteen"][QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="thageneral3"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"][QUOTE="unreal48"][QUOTE="carlisledavid79"][QUOTE="akif22"]

^ what he said

Arthray

What they both say ^^

what all three of them said ^^^

What these guys are saying ^^^^

^^^^^ i cant believe this is even a thread

^^^^^^ me neither! MGS!

^^^^^^^Me neither! MGS FTW

^^^^^^^^MGS4 NO CONTEST

^^^^---- I agree 100%, I'd agree more if it was possible. MGS

^^^^^^What everyone said!

[QUOTE="stereointegrity"][QUOTE="Aljosa23"]Neither. Both are overrated series.TheDarkDisciple

and you think the people saying MGS4 are any different? I bet most of them haven't even tried a SC game. And even if they didn't they wouldn't want to admit that it's better than a ps3 exclusive game.

I have played SC and i have to say its good and all but I like MGS better

[QUOTE="akif22"]

[QUOTE="JayPee89"]Metal Gear > Splinter Cell /threadcarlisledavid79

^ what he says

What they both say ^^

what those three said

They're completely different games. If Ubi hadn't gone with the "shaking things up a bit" and made every level in Double Agent like the first, it would have been the best stealth action game ever made. Sadly they chose not to, and the resulting "shaking things up" resulted in boringness.

MGS has never let me down. Again though; completely different games. They really shouldn't be compared.

Ninja-Vox

true. all i really wanted to do was to sneak around in the night. "if its not broken, don't break it." chaos theory was my fav, double agent was a good game, but they didn't need to make significant changes in the first place.

mgs and splinter cell are different games and i have always liked both, but in the past i have gone to splinter cell for the better sneaking around gameplay. however, mgs stories can't be beaten so its impossible for me to choose between the two.

now to really get back on topic. i think mgs4 will be better that conviction, but not by much.

I know this won't be possible, but what if Splinter Cell sells more than MGS 4? What would this mean for Cows?dkhw

Exactly, it's not possible :P